A Little Princess (1917) User Reviews

Last of Pickford's 1917 Child Movies

[springfieldrental · 6/10 · 19 July 2021]

When Adolph Zukor and Jessy Lasky merged their movie production companies into one, the Famous Players-Lasky, they eyed their partner in its Paramount Pictures distribution branch, William Hodkinson, to squeeze him out with an involuntary buyout. Once they did in the summer of 1916, Zukor and Lasky dropped their Famous Players' name and called their combined production and distribution company Paramount Pictures.

Zukor believed in signing the top movie stars in the business. One of his first contracts was with Hollywood's most popular actress, Mary Pickford. Her signature on the dotted line on June 24, 1916, was the first million dollar pact for an female performer. Zukor was willing to pay her $10,000 a week and to give her half the profits for each film she made. He guaranteed over one million dollars (about $20 million in today's inflationary dollars) for the year with her full control of each of her film's production, an unprecedented contract at that time.

Pickford's third film in 1917 in which she played a little girl was a Francis Marion script, this one adapted from Frances Hodgson Burnett 1905's novel, "The Little Princess." The actress again reverts to childhood-mode, playing a rich British officer's daughter who is placed in a boarding school in England after relocating from India. The school's adults are jealous of her wealth while her school chums, initially picking on her, become intrigued with her exotic imagination. Her fortunes turn when her father dies in battle, leaving her with no inheritance.

Pickford's Sara Crewe is forced by the school's matrons to work as a "slave" with actress SaZu Pitts. The pair's existence is pure misery, given little food and working long hours. But SaZu, who excels in the 1924 memorable "Greed," will prove to be a comfort and friend to Sarah, who discovers a surprise in the twist ending.

During the mid-1930's, 20th Century-Fox president Darryl F. Zanuck took these three movies and cast his child star Shirley Temple to play the Pickford lead. Zanuck appreciated Pickford's persona playing young girls, and he transferred some of the silent movie star's traits onto Temple in preparation for these films.

Some lovely moments, needed tighter script

[overseer-3 · 6/10 · 24 May 2003]

This version of A Little Princess has some very fine moments, particularly when little Sarah is saying goodbye to her beloved father, but it would have been much better with a tighter script and more character development among the children at the school.

There is a story dream sequence in India which takes up a big chunk of this movie which I considered superfluous and unnecessary. That time would have been much better utilized showing more in-depth interaction between Sarah and her special friends at the school, and her relationship with her adversaries, and the maid, Becky. The ending also comes upon the film too quickly, with hardly any time devoted to showing the real suffering that the character of Sarah Crewe endured.

The DVD version has a pleasant piano score that complements the film very well. All in all a nice film, but the later versions of this story on film, even Shirley Temple's, which took quite a few liberties with the original story, are more enjoyable, especially the most faithful adaptation, the 1986 Wonderworks version starring lovely Amelia Shankley.

Imperfect in various ways, but overall fairly well done and enjoyable

[I_Ailurophile · 7/10 · 4 March 2023]

Though there are always exceptions, one can consistently rely on films from the silent era for certain things. The filming locations will be lovely, and more than this, the production design and art direction are exceptional, a feast for the eyes. The costume design, hair, and makeup work are quite fetching; with such necessary emphasis on the visual element, of course one should hope so. Sure, the acting in much of the silent era was characterized by exaggerated body language and facial expressions, holdovers from the stage, to compensate for lack of spoken dialogue or otherwise sound. Yet this trait shifted over time toward more natural, nuanced expression generally, and even at that I don't think there's much arguing against the skills of those in front of the camera, especially for the demands that were placed on them in comparison to the modern cinema we know today. There is still room for considerable subtlety in performances from the 1910s or earlier, and likewise for the imagination with which writers could approach intertitles to relate dialogue or exposition

'A little princess,' starring early screen icon Mary Pickford, most assuredly carries all these facets with it, and is as well made as could be said of any of its contemporaries. Just as importantly, sincere storytelling is adjoined by light humor to provide the entertainment, and even a tinge of adventure as a fair portion of the length includes a recounting of the tale of "Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves." Filmmaker Marshall Neilan demonstrates capable direction, and Frances Marion's adapted screenplay feels gratifyingly well-rounded even in so small a runtime, not least in communicating the friendship between Sara and Becky. Where modest effects and tricks of the camera or editing are employed, they all look pretty terrific, with the latter possibly feeling a tad advanced for 1917. Not least of all, the cast broadly turn in commendable acting, with Pickford and ZaSu Pitts particularly leading the pack in their foremost roles. The end result is really rather entertaining - perhaps not super special, all things considered, let alone essential among silent classics, but fitting neatly among its contemporaries and ably providing a good time for one hour.

None of this is to say that 'A little princess' is wholly perfect. Even by Hollywood's standards of casting, that Pickford, then 25-years old, was portraying a preteen child requires powerful suspension of disbelief. Hand in hand with that characterization and the setting, there are aspects of the film that are extra ham-handed. Like no few other titles from the era, this one is also a tad questionable when it comes to portraying non-white characters, nevermind cultures outside the predominant "western" purview, and this is specifically a bit dubious when it comes to the conveyance of a story from 'One thousand and one nights.' To that point, the story within a story occupies so much of the runtime that one risks forgetting there's a plot outside Ali Baba; this would have benefited from a more concise screenplay. Even setting all this aside: for as fine as the craftsmanship here is at large, there are some moments that really kind of spotlight the ethos of "simpler entertainment for a simpler time"; the direction, narrative, and acting all seem oversimplified at points, if not weirdly outright inauthentic. All this is to say that for as well done as this picture may be, it may not be the silent classic that will change the minds of anyone who has difficulty abiding those traits common to the era.

Still, despite indelicacies or idiosyncrasies, more than not this is quite suitably well done, and fairly fun such as it is. So maybe it will most likely to appeal only to those who are already enamored of its contemporaries; this is hardly the only movie for which that is true. Even with that in mind this feature offers steady entertainment, and while nothing revelatory, successfully meets its goal. There's no need to go out of your way for 'A little princess,' but if you happen to come across it, this is a worth checking out.

A Simple But Pleasant Story

[Snow Leopard · 28 February 2002]

This simple but pleasant story is mostly worthwhile as a vehicle for Mary Pickford to play the kind of role that made her popular. Here, she is a young heiress trying to get used to her new surroundings at a school for girls, when a sudden tragedy changes everything. There isn't a lot to the plot, and so much of the screen time is simply used to show how charming young Sara (Pickford) can be. Pickford, of course, knows just how to make her character sympathetic. Most of the other characters are simply stock figures, except for a young Zasu Pitts, who gets a lot of screen time as Sara's friend. It's not one of Pickford's more memorable films, but it's a pleasant way to pass an hour.

The Little Princess review

[JoeytheBrit · 6/10 · 18 April 2020]

The favoured status of the daughter of a wealthy widowed soldier at a school for girls is abruptly withdrawn upon his death, and she is reduced to working as a scullery maid in the school. An entertaining enough tale if you can get beyond a 25-year-old woman playing a ten-year-old child, and the way that director Marshall Neilan constantly focuses on the wonderful wonderfulness of Mary Pickford. The main story, based on the novel by Frances Hodgson Burnett, is easily outshone by a fun Arabian Nights fantasy sequence.

" Mary And ZaSu, A Great Duo "

[PamelaShort · 10/10 · 21 August 2013]

Riding on a wave of success from 2 enormously popular hit films, The Poor Little Rich Girl and Rebecca Of Sunnybrook Farm , Mary Pickford immediately followed with The Little Princess. Mary is adorable as Sara Crewe, but what really makes this film worth watching is the brilliant performances of both Pickford and ZaSu Pitts. The chemistry between the two is especially good, making them a likable and believable duo. Frances Marion who wrote the script for The Little Princess was introduced to the thin, awkward teenage girl, looking for a part. When the young man who brought ZaSu in made an insulting remark about her looks, a furious Frances threw him out of her office. After consoling the timid girl she asked her to tell her about herself. As Frances watched and listened to the young ZaSu's life story, she didn't know whether to laugh or cry and it occurred to her that others might be touched the same way. There was a key part in The Little Princess for a young maid called a slavey. When Frances told Mary the full story, ZaSu was immediately given the role of Becky. As rave reviews poured in for Mary's flawless acting, there was special mention of the actress playing the young maid; "Watch ZaSu Pitts, for she is a coming star." The lighting and the sets in this film are of a remarkably high standard along with bold close-ups and extreme long shots, all help to make this a very fine quality film of the period. Pickford's version of the beloved Little Princess is enchanting and enjoyable entertainment.