Cracked Ice (1938) Poster

(1938)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
The funniest part of this short plays off of an old radio "feud" between two caricatures
llltdesq28 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
This is a very funny short which gets virtually all its laughs by playing off the personality of W.C. Fields (here represented in caricature as a pig names W. C. Squeals). The few gags which don't center around this central joke are relatively minor and mostly pale in comparison, though the new lyrics set to "The Blue Danube" are interesting. Because I want to discuss details, this is a spoiler warning:

W. C. Fields was frequently used as a source for caricature because he was such a colorful character, both as part of his act (that being a cantankerous and cynical horse thief and a fair man with the bottle) and, to a significant degree, in reality (he really was a heavy drinker). Even the title of the short is a double-edged play on words, as the cartoon features a figure-skating contest and cracked ice is frequently used in mixing drinks.

Here, caricatured as a pig, named W.C. Squeals, he's seen a short time into the short, after some perfunctory gags which principally serve to set the atmosphere (it's cold, animals are skating, etc.) Squeals sees a crane fall through the ice and frantically calls for help. A St. Bernard shows up, rescues the bird and pours spirits into him, at which point Squeals develops a notable thirst and a need for "medicinal" help that only the keg can provide. Alas, the St. Bernard ignores his comically "heart-rending" appeals for the kindness of a stranger and Squeals decides that a feigned drowning and rescue is in order. The St. Bernard comes out, mixes a drink and then downs the toddy himself and leaves (a bit unsteadily). So Squeals resorts to a complicated scheme, involving a magnet and a metal dish filled with dog bones.

All through this sequence, Squeals is heckled from the audience by a disembodied voice patterned after Charlie McCarthy, Edgar Bergen's primary ventriloquist's dummy. Fields and Bergen were both prominent on radio for a good number of years and Fields and McCarthy carried on a "feud" for some time, where they would trade insults. The two caricatures here follow suit in trading the same types of insult. Audiences of the time were well familiar with the whole thing and it gave the animators a solid frame of reference which made the gags even funnier.

Squeals tries to get the St. Bernard to chase the dish, but things don't go as planned and the magnet and a fair amount of alcohol wind up in the water, where the magnet winds up stuck on a fish who then gets drunk. The magnet attracts Squeals's ice skates and the fish lurches drunkenly under the ice, dragging Squeals into the middle of a figure-skating competition, which he wins.

Squeals wastes no time in filling the cup he receives as his prize with the remaining alcohol from the dog's keg, all the while gloating to the McCarthy caricature in the audience-until the cup, with its precious cargo, comes into the grip of the magnet and starts careening across the ice, to the sounds of laughter from a very satisfied McCarthy.

This short is available on the Looney Tunes Golden Collection, Volume 4 and is well worth seeing. Recommended.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
"Pardon me, my little canine comrade."
slymusic29 August 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Directed by Frank Tashlin, "Cracked Ice" is a good Warner Bros. cartoon featuring some bright colors and a few interesting camera angles. Not much of a plot, though, but we do see quite a bit of a porcine caricature of W.C. Fields, who casts a sharp eye on a rescue dog's barrel of booze.

My favorite sequence in this cartoon is the opening, which features an amusing vocal harmonization of the Blue Danube while lots of animal characters ice-skate. (Some of them actually lose their balance and fall down, and one of them pushes a hippo.)

It's a good thing I didn't see "Cracked Ice" when I was a little boy. I probably would've failed to see the humor in a little fish struggling to detach himself from a horseshoe magnet and dodge a hungry shark.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Boring and frequently ugly
phantom_tollbooth9 January 2009
Frank Tashlin's 'Cracked Ice' is an oddly dull one-shot cartoon which stars a W.C. Fields pig who attempts to obtain alcohol from the St, Bernard rescue dog. The first thing I noticed about 'Cracked Ice' is how ugly the character designs are. The pig and St. Bernard aren't too bad but the opening sequences in which we see various animals skating on a frozen pond feature some of the worst drawings I've seen in a Warner cartoon. The main plot of 'Cracked Ice', when it arrives, is rather feeble and the two main characters are so cumbersome that the action is inevitably plodding. The jokes centring around the magnet are the highlight of the cartoon but that same setup has been used to better effect in many cartoons. There's also a good bit where W.C. Squeals (as he is called here) talks directly to an cinema audience member (who sounds like ventriloquist Charlie McCarthy, referencing a long forgotten "feud" between the two celebrities) but this, too, has been better executed in several other shorts. With both look and script severely lacking, 'Cracked Ice' emerges as a clumsy film which, for the most part, bores me rigid.
0 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
even though modern audiences probably won't get the pop culture references, you still gotta love what they do here
lee_eisenberg19 September 2007
Fans of Looney Tunes/Merrie Melodies cartoons should know about how the creators often incorporated pop culture references into the cartoons, and understand that these references probably will fly over our heads in the 21st century. One such example is Frank Tashlin's "Cracked Ice". This one starts off with several characters ice skating to the tune of "The Blue Danube", all the while pulling various gags.

That's when a bird falls into a water hole. Overstuffed pig W.C. Squeals summons a St. Bernard, but gets thirsty at the sight of the dog giving the bird brandy. While at first he pretends to drown, the dog sees through his game. But when he uses a magnet...well, let's just say that I couldn't have predicted the subsequent events in a million years! They must have had fun creating this cartoon! So, it goes to show that while Tashlin may not have been the most famous Warner Bros. animation director, he left his mark. And it was a funny one. You're sure to like this cartoon.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
More wild than fun
Horst_In_Translation3 September 2015
Warning: Spoilers
"Cracked Ice" is an 8-minute Warner Bros cartoon from over 75 years ago. This was made shortly before World War II and at this point, W.C. Fields was a pretty big star. So here he gets his pig equivalent always on the lookout for alcohol. This big pig makes a nice duo with the reserved big dog in here and the moment these two are on the screen are definitely the highlight. All the other characters, like the ones early on or the fish, are pretty unappealing in my opinion. This was an okay short film at best. Very few really funny scenes, but lots of wild and chaotic animated mayhem that is not enough though to carry this work. Tashlin, Miller, Blanc and Pierce have done better in many occasions. Not recommended.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A lot of fun
TheLittleSongbird2 December 2012
I don't see Cracked Ice as one of my absolute favourites, the plot is minimal and the ice skating gags are not that much new, in fact they are on the generic side (though they still manage to generate some amusement). However, the animation is great with bright colours and some interesting camera angles. The character designs are not bad either. The music is just as wonderful, I love the luscious orchestration and its energy. The highlight is the Blue Danube sequence at the start, love the music itself and the harmonies were very clever. The gags manage to be very funny, especially the ones with the magnet and the radio feud. The ice skating gags are not that much new but still manage to generate some amusement, which to me is what matters more. The characters are memorable, especially the caricature of WC Fields. The voice work from the ever dependable Mel Blanc is faultless.

All in all, a lot of fun but not what I call an exceptional cartoon. 8/10 Bethany Cox
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed