Le pays sans étoiles (1946) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Déjà Vu
dbdumonteil19 April 2019
To think that many Gerard Philipe fans do not even know that this movie exists.Oddly ,and although he plays the main character ,his name does not appear at the top of the credits ,because he was relatively unknown in the world of cinema whereas he was already famous on stage.

In the French cinema,there was a time when a solid screenplay ,wonderful actors and painstaking directing were all that counts;but in the late fifties or early sixties ,I do not remember exactly well ,a wicked fairy came and said :

-Listen to my spell, you lousy old directors,prick your finger and sleep for a hundred years!

Thus ,many of the great movies of the forties and fifties became sleepers ,waiting for their prince charming ....or for some imdb reviewer such as Writer's Reign to wake them.

Pierre Very's screenplay is absolutely stunning : in this forsaken work ,there are two stories ,cunningly told in parallel ,which become one in the last fifteen minutes ; some curious warnings, an impending curse ,the hero seeing things ,bizarre names (the village of Tournepique ):it was meant to be.Georges Lacombe,who had already displayed flair for film noir ("LE DERNIER DES SIX " 1939),excels himself here : it might well be the best French fantasy film of the forties (along with Tourneur's "LA MAIN DU DIABLE "); he creates an eerie atmosphere in everyday life : the local train ,the cemetery , the old diary , the deja vu feeling of the hero who might have lived another life ...

The acting is first-class:Gerard Philipe is par excellence the romantic actor ,the man with the child in his eyes;his routine life in a notary's office does not satisfy him,even though he has good propects :he longs for something else and his premonitory dreams and his visions ,although they scare him ,fascinate him . The girl he meets (Jany Holt ) may be the great love he is waiting for;but the first scene is revealing : they meet on the village square and they do not notice each other ; this girl was once the village teacher but she eloped with a shady painter ;she returns home to be confronted with a shrew of a mother (the always reliable Sylvie)and a deaf grandma ;the viewer sides with her , and expects that the young dreamer will fall in love with her and save her from the old greybeard her shameless mom wants her to marry.But it's not as simple as that...Holt gives an ambiguous performance,and she is attracted by....

.... another character , the hero's friend , played by Pierre Brasseur at his most cynical;in spite of his nastiness ,he brings a lot of humor in a dramatic story :see him using his hands to express himself when his friend tells him he will refund the money he stole from a wealthy man ;hear him tell the story of the doomed lovers a long long time ago ,how he laughs at pure romantic love :a real tour de force!

A riveting story which will keep glued to your seat till the very last picture ; it is essential viewing for people interested in the old French cinema, the extraordinary cinéma de papa!Break the spell!
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Are The Stars Out Tonight? In Spades
writers_reign21 April 2010
Warning: Spoilers
My good friend Didier is right on the button in his review of this gem. It does date from a magic time when the only things that counted were good, solid screenplays, charismatic actors and directing that was a combination of the workmanlike and the inspired. Try telling that to the New Waveleteers, that small group of intellectual pseuds who contrived to set French Film Making back half a century. Fortunately sanity prevailed and within half a dozen years the French film industry was back in pole position. Georges Lacombe, one of a group of fine French journeyman directors turned to the novel by Paul Very and got him to adapt it for a stunning combination of rom-com and psychological time-travel drama. In only his fourth film Gerard Philipe is ideal casting for the troubled young protagonist with a bad case of deja vu. Roumanian actress Jany Holt provides the love interest and Pierre Brasseur as Philipe's brother completes the triangle. Do your best to catch this one.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed