The Golden Eye (1948) User Reviews

"Small thing sometimes tell very large story."

[classicsoncall · 5/10 · 17 October 2004]

A formerly unproductive gold mine suddenly turns out to be highly profitable; it's owner Manning insists someone is out to murder him. He turns to Charlie Chan (Roland Winters) for help, and the Oriental detective and his two assistants, Number #2 Son Tommy (Victor Sen Yung) and driver Birmingham Brown (Mantan Moreland) embark on a pseudo Western adventure. The story is set in Arizona, and to downplay suspicion in their involvement, the Chan party heads off to the Lazy Y Dude Ranch, from where they can keep an eye on developments at the Golden Eye Mine.

Sen Yung and Moreland make quite a sight in their Western attire, particularly Birmingham in his buffalo inspired jodhpurs. Tim Ryan is back in a reprise of his role as Lieutenant Mike Ruark (The Shanghai Chest), but this time he's undercover as teetering lush Vincent O'Brien at the Lazy Y. He's there independently, but it turns out his investigation runs parallel to Chan's, so they use the coincidence to hook up.

It turns out that the Golden Eye is a pass through for a gold smuggling operation originating in Mexico. The obvious brains of the smuggling gang appears to be the mine's superintendent Driscoll, but as usual for a Chan mystery, the obvious is always done one better, in this case, the mastermind is the handsome local assayer Talbot Bartlett (Bruce Kellogg), who's only too happy to assist Chan in any way he can so that he can throw him off the mark. Bartlett is also busy courting Manning's daughter Evelyn (Wanda McKay) to be better positioned to remove the mine's owner from the picture.

"The Golden Eye" is an average Charlie Chan mystery, made somewhat more interesting with the comedic bits by Mantan Moreland and the quite effective interplay of Tim Ryan's drunken character O'Brien. If you're a Charlie Chan fan, you'll have to add this one to your list.

The franchise is gasping for its last breath!!

[planktonrules · 5/10 · 31 August 2008]

This is one of the last of the Monogram series of Charlie Chan films. By 1948, the series had been around for many years--since the late 1920s. Through the decades, Warner Oland and Sidney Toler had made a ton of these fun murder mysteries. By the death Toler in 1946, it was obvious that the series had been gasping for life for several years. However, instead of calling a halt to the films, Monogram plodded along with several more Chan films that starred Roland Winters. Now Winters wasn't too bad--after all, with makeup he was able to look like Chan and his delivery was rather Chan-like (though a bit rapid). However, the wit of the Sidney Toler version was noticeably absent. Another problem is that by 1948, the movies just weren't as interesting and were usually written in such a hasty manner that plot holes abounded--and this one looked rather Swiss cheesy at that! I know this to be so because I have seen all of the Fox Charlie Chan films that are in existence and almost all the Monogram ones--the slide is obvious.

Charlie is out west to investigate how a supposedly played out gold mine is suddenly brimming with gold. During the investigation, the man who hired Chan is supposedly hurt and his entire face is wrapped in gauze and doctors won't let anyone in to see him. It's so completely obvious to anyone with half a brain that either this isn't the man or he's being drugged. Oddly, Chan allows this ruse to continue for some time--even though someone's life might be at risk. Even when the nurse/nun who is caring for him reveals she's an idiot and practically knows nothing about medicine, Chan does nothing.

In addition to lots of inaction, the film is brimming with dull and awkward performances. About the only one who comes off reasonably well is Tommy Chan--who oddly was re-named Tommy even though he'd been Jimmy in the earlier films and was still played by the same actor (Victor Sen Yung). Even the usual comic relief from Mantan Moreland seems very subdued in this film. There simply is no energy or life to this film and a few really broad performances sink the film further.

The bottom line is that there isn't much of a mystery and Chan could easily get to the bottom of it. Instead, the amazingly subdued Chan sits back and lets the film go on for some time until the conclusion. Dull and uninspired.

Weak Chan, but still a Chan

[jonfrum2000 · 5/10 · 22 September 2010]

This episode in the Chan series features skimpy sets - not rare in the later Chans - and a weak role for the usually entertaining Mantan Moreland, but some Chan is better than none. Roland Winters does a perfectly serviceable job as Charlie - lacking the warmth of Warner Oland, but also lacking the harshness of Sidney Toler in his father/son interactions. The plot is pedestrian, but the series is about Charlie and assistants, not the stories, so a less than perfect plot is OK. This movie lacks the beautiful women in gowns we often get in Chans, and not much of a love affair, so some of the classic Chan features are missing. By this late time, they were spending very little money on the series, and milking it for the value of the franchise. One can imagine that it was a perfectly good way to spend an hour on a Saturday in post-war America.

I noticed that after crediting Roland Winters and one woman actress, Mantan Moreland and Victor Sen Young came next. In spite of the fact that a white man was playing Chan, clearly a black man and a Chinese man came next in popularity with audiences. For some reason, this fact is never credited. The theme of racist America is just to popular to be spoiled by such facts.

There's gold in that mine.

[michaelRokeefe · 14 July 2011]

Oriental sleuth Charlie Chan(Roland Winters), Tommy Chan(Victor Sen Young)and chauffeur Birmingham(Mantan Moreland)head to Arizona at the request of a Mr. Manning(Forrest Taylor), owner of The Golden Eye mine. Manning finds it very odd that his mine losing a lot of money for a good while suddenly has become a gold bonanza. Lt. Mike Ruark(Tim Ryan) is also investigating Manning's mine manager Driscoll(Ralph Dunn)on a different matter that may help Chan's investigation of the situation at The Golden Eye. This mystery franchise is nearing its end and you can tell by the lack of any scenery and flat dialog. But this is a Charlie Chan flick, man. Just not one of the best. Other players: Wanda McKay, Evelyn Brent and Bruce Kellogg.

Dude ranch visit for Mr. Chan and associates

[csteidler · 6/10 · 19 March 2019]

Charlie Chan's old friend from Arizona thinks that someone is trying to kill him. Chan travels to the friend's dude ranch and digs into the mystery, which he quickly discovers is tied up with a nearby gold mine.

Roland Winters is solid if unexciting as the famous detective in this passable series entry. Victor Sen Young and Mantan Moreland are featured in sizable roles this time around; as number two son Tommy and chauffeur Birmingham Brown, they liven up their portions of an otherwise rather bland production.

Tim Ryan attempts to add color as a tipsy ranch guest whom Chan quickly recognizes as his friend Lieutenant Mike from San Francisco. Lieutenant Mike, it turns out, is undercover at the ranch and investigating the same funny business at the mine.

Other story elements include a smuggling ring, a suspicious mine shaft accident, a miner's shack with a trap door in the floor leading to a secret tunnel.... It really doesn't make much sense but it's mildly entertaining.

Three quarters of the way through the film, it dawned on me...

[mozartsw2006-784-220779 · 6/10 · 14 September 2022]

Like several other reviewers, this is my first Charlie Chan film with Roland Winters cast as the detective. I have to be honest; I've always enjoyed Roland Winters in every role I've seen him in, so I'm a bit biased in his favor. IMHO, he brings a certain gravitas to the role that had been missing since Warner Oland's untimely passing. In his defense, Sidney Toler deserves much credit for purchasing the rights to the character, so that the film series could continue, but his health problems and age contributed to the energy draining from his later performances. I also liked that Mr. Winters' Chan appreciated the support of his son Tommy, finely portrayed by Victor Sen Young. It was a refreshing change from the condescension and sarcasm of the Sidney Toler portrayal toward any of his male offspring. Mantan Moreland, who I always enjoyed as Birmingham Brown, was also more subdued in this film. Now, to what dawned on me toward the end of the film... What I realized was that this could very well have been a Hopalong Cassidy movie, replacing Charlie Chan with Hoppy, and Tommy and Birmingham with Lucky and California. That's not necessarily a bad thing; plots, stories and scripts have been recycled for decades. The trouble here was that I realized it as I was watching the film. There was nothing about the plot that was noteworthy. Other drawbacks to this film are that the supporting cast was adequate, but that's about all that can be said. The budget was minimal. As other reviewers have indicated, the series was running out of steam. I sincerely believe that had Roland Winters assumed the role of Charlie Chan a few years earlier, the quality of the series would have improved, and more money would have been invested into the film series. All in all, not a terrible film, but it is noticeable where improvement could have been made. 6/10.

Chan's the man who can solve a murder like nobody can!

[mark.waltz · 3/10 · 10 May 2014]

An Arizona gold mine becomes the location for another murder that Charlie Chan happens to be around when it occurs. As the series began to reach its inevitable conclusion, the plots just got more outrageous, yet this one is perhaps one of the more accessible of the later part of the series. Roland Winters doesn't have the cleverness of either Warner Oland or Sidney Toler, and sometimes it seems like the writers just put together their plots by simply just changing the location, the motivation, the names of all the suspects and toss in a couple of comic bits for Mantan Moreland and whatever # son happens to be there. Victor Sen Yung gets his opportunity to be a dude as he tries on chaps and Mantan Moreland does his usual pratfalls and scaredy-cat double-takes, even talking directly to the camera. Of course, all the usual suspects are there, as is the vulnerable heroine (Wanda McKay), a tough-talking nun (veteran actress Evelyn Brent) and a dumb-as-nails cop (Tim Ryan). These later day entries confound the audience with confusing twists and turns that sometimes make no sense, and give the impression that towards the end, they weren't even really trying.

Ain't that something?

[Bernie4444 · 6/10 · 7 March 2024]

A gold defunct gold mine is mysteriously profitable. The owner of the mine thinks he is being targeted and soon to be dispatched. He thinks this is right up Charlie Chan's alley.

Charlie poses as a jade dealer and with help from his standard entourage, must sort out the dastardly doers and find out what it is they are doing. Can he save the mine owner in time or is it curtains? If the mine owner goes is his daughter next?

"Ain't that something? Good gracious of me. That's Mr. Chan allover. When you think it is, it ain't and when you think it ain't, that is just what it is." - Birmingham Brown (Mantan Morland).

"So much for so much."

[utgard14 · 4/10 · 21 March 2014]

Charlie Chan heads to Arizona to investigate a gold mine mystery. A typically cheap Monogram movie starring Roland Winters, the worst of all Charlie Chans. Mantan Moreland returns as unfunny comic relief character Birmingham Brown. Victor Sen Yung is back as Tommy Chan. The western locale allows both to dress like cowboys. So it's trying to be like a Bowery Boys comedy or something. Except the Bowery Boys were funny. The once-great Charlie Chan series had fallen pretty far by this time. Winters is absolutely terrible as Chan. Poorly written, directed, and acted -- it's a really a stinker of a movie. The one positive thing I will say about it is that actor Ralph Dunn, who plays the mine superintendent, has a pretty cool head of hair.

Below Average

[Lechuguilla · 4/10 · 6 April 2015]

The story is set mostly in Arizona near an old gold mine. The owner is being threatened and wants Chan's help. It's a good premise but the story is dull and unconvincing. There are not enough suspects to make the puzzle interesting. The killer here is easier to figure out than in most Chan stories. There was one surprise toward the end but it only contributed to the story's implausibility.

Characters are shallow and generally uninteresting. Way too much time is spent on the drunk who stumbles around the swimming pool. This character isn't really needed anyway and my impression is that he functions mostly as filler; the film contains a lot of filler, despite the short runtime.

Outdoor visuals do not look much like Arizona. The mine-shafts add a spooky quality. But film lighting renders the tunnels too bright to be convincingly subterranean. Overall lighting is generally too dark. Production design is predictably minimal and cheap.

As bug-eyed Birmingham Brown, Mantan Moreland is always a welcome addition to the cast. But Victor Sen Yung doesn't add much as Number Two Son. And Roland Winters is dreadful as Charlie Chan. Winters just doesn't have the Chan persona that Warner Oland or Sidney Toler had.

With minimal mystery and suspense, few suspects, and a dull Charlie Chan actor, "The Golden Eye" is below average for this series. Only hard core Charlie Chan movie fans will find much appeal in this film.

Charlie Chan in the 'Wild West'

[binapiraeus · 8/10 · 27 March 2014]

This is a VERY unusual entry in the 'Charlie Chan' series: it starts, like most of the movies starring Roland Winters, in a clearly 'Noirish' atmosphere, with a man being mysteriously followed through the dark streets of Chinatown and a little later being shot at through the window in a shop - whose owner is Charlie's cousin, and the man called Manning came here to ask Charlie for help: in the past months, there have been made several attempts at his life. Manning's a rancher from Arizona, and he owns the 'Golden Eye' mine, which has been producing quite a lot of gold lately. So it's off to the 'Wild West' for Charlie, Tommy and Birmingham!

And here, immediately the comedy element sets in: Tommy and Birmingham dress up for the occasion as 'real' cowboys... When they reach the ranch, which is also a big bungalow park, Charlie very soon meets an old acquaintance of his: Lt. Mike Rourke, who's playing the 'drunkard' in a MORE than convincing way to cover up for the investigations he's already making here; there DOES seem to be something wrong with the mine and its sudden gold production... Then Charlie gets to know Mr. Driscoll, the mine superintendent, and his wife, and young metal expert Bartlett - but just a little later, Manning meets with a very serious accident in his mine, falling down 40 feet and fracturing his skull, so that his whole head has to be bandaged and he's brought home to bed in a coma. Then, while everybody's waiting for Manning to recover, an old prospector turns up and gives Charlie a hint to a secret tunnel into the mine - but when Charlie and his assistants enter that tunnel, they find the old miner dead; so now they DEFINITELY know that there's some kind of foul play going on in that mine...

A pretty strange environment for Charlie Chan, the big city gentleman - but a very effective one: by day, the cheerful atmosphere at the bungalow park lightens up the atmosphere; while the nightly scenes down in the mine shafts are EXTREMELY suspenseful. A VERY well-done piece of crime entertainment, with Roland Winters in his fourth appearance as Charlie Chan already obviously feeling very much at ease with his role!

Charlie Chan cheapie

[Leofwine_draca · 5/10 · 17 February 2019]

THE GOLDEN EYE is one of the endless mystery movies shot by William "One Shot" Beaudine for Monogram. This one's a late-stage Charlie Chan outing, with western actor Roland Winters playing the eponymous detective for the staggering 45th time on screen! The action is set around a gold mine, where murders are taking place and sinister villains up to no good. Luckily Chan is around to deliver a wise saying or ten and Mantan Moreland mugs for all his worth as comic relief Birmingham Brown. It's passable enough, but only if you're in the right mood.

My first Roland Winters' Chan film

[bensonmum2 · 3/10 · 13 July 2021]

Charlie Chan (Roland Winters) agrees to investigate the strange happenings at an Arizona (or is it New Mexico - I really can't be bothered to check) goldmine. Along for the ride are son Tommy (Victor Sen Yung) and chauffeur Birmingham Brown (Mantan Moreland).

I have seen all of the Sidney Toler and Warner Oland Chan films - most multiple times. But oddly enough, this is my first experience with Roland Winters. I'm not impressed. Maybe it's my personal bias, but he seems all wrong for the role. Instead of the measured, deliberate Chan played by both Toler and Oland, Winters is too quick in both speech and action. And, if it weren't for the yellow-face, I'd swear Winters was trying to pull off some kind of European, maybe Italian, accent. It was all so distracting.

As for the film itself, you know you're in trouble when the credits begin with the words Monogram Pictures and end with the name William Beaudine. That pretty much says all you need to know. Honestly, it's just a bad movie and not really worth dwelling on.

On a positive note, The Golden Eye doesn't feature an overdose of Tommy and Birmingham. Their comedy bits are limited. And thank goodness because as much as I like Moreland, his Birmingham Brown schtick gets old pretty quick.

Finally, there were two things that bothered me while watching The Golden Eye and both are related to Victor Sen Yung. First, why is he named Tommy in this movie? If you've seen any of his previous Chan films, you know he's Jimmy. Second, in 1948, he was 33 years old - way too old to be playing the bumbling son. In fact, he's way too old to be playing Winters' son. Winters would have been 44 when this movie was made - a difference of only 11 years.

3/10.

New Riches suddenly come forth

[bkoganbing · 3/10 · 11 October 2012]

Contrary to what you might originally think The Golden Eye is not an original version of the James Bond classic. It's the name of a played out gold mine which has suddenly sprung to life. But its owner Forrest Taylor is so fearful of his that he goes to San Francisco to seek out Charlie Chan.

The writers of the Charlie Chan series were getting terribly uninspired in doing this film. Roland Winters goes to a dude ranch with number 2 son Victor Sen Yung and the comical relief of chauffeur Mantan Moreland along to oversee the investigation. While there they meet Tim Ryan of the San Francisco PD who is doing a nice drunk act as a blind because they eventually find out they're on the same case which involves smuggling.

Not much mystery here because just about every other cast member is involved some way in the racket. Evelyn Brent plays a nun, but none too successfully. She gives her disguise away in a truly stupid manner and you didn't need to be Charlie Chan to figure out she was a phony.

Definitely not one of the better Charlie Chan features.

Dudes on the Loose

[Hitchcoc · 5/10 · 24 January 2016]

Instead of taking precautions to aid a man who is in grave danger, Charlie again waits to do anything. He is approached by an old friend who says that someone is trying to kill him. It has something to do with an old gold mine, The Golden Eye, that has begun producing after many lean years. The gang find themselves on a dude ranch where things aren't' as they should be. The old friend supposedly falls down a shaft and is left a broken man, fighting for his life. Once again, there are a couple bodies that need to be dealt with. Charlie pretends to be a jade merchant and exposes his identity to an old detective friend who seems to be aware of the goings on. The problem, as it often is in these poorly done old films, is the slipshod work of everyone as they do nothing to protect those in danger. It was good that this series slowly plodded to an end.

Later Charlie Chaplin programmer in the Old West

[vampire_hounddog · 3/10 · 21 August 2020]

Charlie Chan (Roland Winters) finds himself in the Wild West and is soon caught up in a plot of murder and theft involving gold in an abandoned old mining town.

One of the poor later Charlie Chan entries that adds little to the series including a greater reliance on Charlie's sidekicks in number two son (Victor Sen Yung) and his scaredy black chauffeur (Mantan Moreland). The western location is an interesting addition though.

Perfect fare for insomniacs

[gridoon2024 · 4/10 · 13 March 2016]

By this point, the Charlie Chan series seemed to be going on autopilot: neither the director nor the cast (save maybe for Mantan Moreland) were showing much enthusiasm for the proceedings. In "Golden Eye", about half of the "action" takes place inside a mine, which makes the film look even cheaper and more underlit than usual. It's a bargain-basement and sleep-inducing production, and there aren't even any memorable lines for Chan! There is, however, (precisely) one scene that I did like: Wanda McKay grabbing a fake "nun/nurse" from behind and struggling a gun away from her; such initiative from a woman in a 1940s movie is uncommon to see. *1/2 out of 4.

Slow And Dull

[boblipton · 4/10 · 18 March 2024]

In the preantepenultimate -- look it up -- Charlie Chan movie, Roland Winters is called in by an old friend to clear up why accidents keep happening to him. Before he can meet with Winters, his skull is cracked open and he's lying in a bed, bandaged to a fare-the-well, unconscious, and with a nursing sister played by Evelyn Brent looking after him. Meanwhile, Tim Ryan of the Sn Francisco Police is on the scene tring to figure out why the unconscious man's mine has suddenly begun producing again after years of not paying its way.

The Roland Winter Chans are hard to find, and the lack of interest is understandable, if this one is typical. Winters' interpretation speaks slower, more singsong, and isn't as funny as Toler. The script by Scott Darling doesn't help. It spends most of its time going back and forth over the same two sets. Neither does director William seem to want to push things forward. Victor Sen Yung as Second Son, and Mantan Moreland as Winters' assistant don't seem to have much comedy to offer. Instead, we get to see Ryan do a drunk act as part of his undercover investigation.