Daughter of the West (1949) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Positive look at Indian reservation life
SimonJack19 April 2014
"Daughter of the West" is an unusual film. It is mostly about Native Americans. It takes place mostly on an Indian reservation. And, it is a generally positive look at the efforts of an Indian nation to adapt to farming and land management using skills and knowledge of the white man. Many Western movies either have denigrated the Native Americans, or have focused on their plight in being forced onto reservations. So, this movie is a look at one reservation's efforts to become self-sufficient.

It takes place in the late 19th century. The hero, Navo White Eagle is played by Phillip Reed. He has just returned from Carlisle Indian School in Pennsylvania, where he studied basic agriculture, geology and other courses that could help his people. The heroine is Lolita Moreno, played by Martha Vickers. She grew up as an orphan in the Mission San Capistrano in California, and leaves there to become a school teacher at the Navajo reservation.

The plot involves some bad guys who try to swindle the Indians out of their valuable mineral rights. The opening credits are quite crude, but then the production value improves. This is a poverty row production, with little known actors. But they do well enough to keep one's interest. James Griffith is recognizable from a lot of Westerns where he played mostly bad guys. Vickers was a somewhat better actress who had some nice minor roles. She might have done more but she died of cancer at age 46. She is also known as the second wife of Mickey Rooney.

This movie most likely was filmed somewhere in California – the film credits don't say where. Had it been shot on the actual Navajo Reservation, it might have had some scenes that would be familiar to many movie buffs. The Navajo lands are the largest Indian Reservation in the U.S. Their 27,425 square miles spread across NE Arizona, SE Utah and NW New Mexico. Since 1939, movie buffs have become familiar with some of the landmarks of the Navajo territory. That's when John Ford filmed his classic Western, "Stagecoach" in Monument Valley. The valley is completely located within the Navajo lands in Arizona and Utah. Ford made many more Westerns there, and many other films have since been made with scenes of the famed buttes and spires that rise above the desert floor.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
No violence! (Except as a last resort....)
mark.waltz4 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
With the arrival of new teacher Martha Vickers on the Navajo reservation, the past is reopened for an old scandal to be revealed and a scheme against the residents to be attempted in regards to copper mining rites as well as prejudices within the nation itself. Philip Reed plays a Navajo man educated in white man schools, having taken on certain traits and the look of the white man, threatened with banishment by chief Pedro de Cordoba after being set up by local commissioner Donald Woods for committing crimes that he himself committed. Woods is willing to do anything, even commit murder, to get the copper rights.

This is a very unique Western in the sense that it takes place on a Navajo reservation and deals with the attempts to defraud them and other prejudices they faced. This was filmed in Cinecolor (a cheaper photography pretty cess not as vivid as Technicolor or other filming processes), but the print that I discovered was a very grainy black and white, looking almost like an early TV show. But the film is still better than expected because it shows a more realistic portrayal of the natives that you rarely see in the movies, especially in the heyday of the B Western.

The print, even as poor as it was, did have one benefit. It made itself look like early crude photography with pictures that I've seen taken on reservations, making the natives look as they really were. Their portrayals are far more complex and realistic, with the characterizations not either one-dimensionally good or savagely bad. In fact, the two villains of the film (Woods and James Griffith) are Caucasian, and in the end, a hearing is overseen by a white military officer who is aghast by the fraud perpetuated on the Navajos and promptly provides a swift, severe retaliation. That's veteran actor William Farnum as the priest in the opening scene. I normally do not watch films like this more than once, but I would gladly watch a restored print in the original Cnecolor if it became available.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
great western
milescorn4 January 2002
I own a 16mm copy of this great western that is not like any other of it's kind. Set on an Indian Reservation that is filled with a vst supply of oar, a scam artist that is the Indian Officer sets up the chiefs daughter to sign off the land to him. Then he frames the well to do Indian that has just come back from coledge and discovers his plan to throw out the Indians and take over mining the Reservation for the copper oar that is in the hills. It is also a love story as the new school teacher finds out that she is half Indian and falls in love with Navo, the hero of the story. It is also a great drama that is so diffrent then most weasterns of its time. This is a hard to find movie on vhs, but if you do find it and you are a fan of the old west I recomend this film very highly.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed