The Sky Dragon (1949) User Reviews

"Innocent act without thinking, guilty always make plans."

[classicsoncall · 5/10 · 19 October 2004]

"The Sky Dragon" would be the last of the Charlie Chan mystery films, this one starring Roland Winters who appeared in a total of six films as the Oriental Detective. Keye Luke, who first appeared as Number #1 Son Lee in 1935's "Charlie Chan in Paris" opposite Warner Oland, appears here in a much more mature characterization. So much so, that this is the only film in which Charlie is called "Dad" instead of "Pop" by any of his offspring.

The movie involves an insurance scam aboard a San Francisco bound airline flight, on which all the passengers are drugged, with the perpetrator making off with a two hundred fifty thousand dollar bundle. Chan must make his way through a host of suspects among the passengers, before ferreting out the guilty party with Lee's help impersonating an injured (actually dead) pilot.

Notable among the cast are Tim Ryan in his third Chan appearance as Lieutenant Mike Ruark of the San Francisco Police Department; and future Daily Planet Reporter Noel Neill as an airline hostess. For trivia fans, her TV Superman counterpart George Reeves also appeared in a Charlie Chan film, 1941's "Dead Men Tell", as of all things, a newspaper reporter! For his last appearance in a Chan film, Mantan Moreland as Birmingham Brown doesn't have much to do, although he does get physical at one point, helping Lee wrestle down a gunman confronting Charlie.

Like many Charlie Chan films, it helps to keep a scorecard to track the characters and their relationships. "The Sky Dragon" has enough going on to keep you guessing, although in the end it's a rather average entry in the Chan series.

The Last Chan

[nova-63 · 6/10 · 9 July 2009]

This film, along with The Shanghai Chest, is my favorite of the Roland Winters films. Here, Charlie is on board a late night flight home to San Francisco. He awakens to find that everyone on the plane has been drugged, $250,000 has disappeared, and a detective hired to guard the money has been murdered.

There are a couple of subplots that at first seem to be distractions, but ultimately tie in to the murder case. The cast is filled with familiar faces, including Iris Adrian, Elena Verdugo, Lyle Talbot, Milburn Stone, and John Eldredge. The skill of these character actors adds immeasurably to the film. There is a little less comedy in this one and that is fine by me. And the presence of number one son Lee (Keye Luke) is always welcomed.

There is no denying that these Monograms lack the technical expertise of the earlier Fox films. But if one accepts them for what they are, low budget B mysteries, you will enjoy the 65 minutes.

Murder and robbery in the sky

[bkoganbing · 5/10 · 15 April 2013]

The Charlie Chan series ended with The Sky Dragon in which murder and a robbery are committed in a passenger airline while in flight. The ultimate of locked room homicides. Unfortunately for the ones who did this caper they had Charlie Chan and son Lee on board. After that they hadn't a chance.

Roland Winters and Keye Luke bring in Tim Ryan of the SFPD who is more than happy to assist the local authorities. Pilot Milburn Stone and co-pilot Joel Marston and hostesses Noel Neill and Elena Verdugo are also suspects. Gracing the cast as she always does is Iris Adrian playing a burlesque queen who was a passenger. She's traveling with brother-in-law Lyle Talbot on a mission of her own.

The guilty party is one who is rather quick on the trigger. In that it's easy to figure out who it is. How the robbery was done was a bit more clever and it involves an accomplice or two.

Keye Luke who was number one son while Warner Oland was Charlie Chan returns for the final film. I had the pleasure of seeing Keye Luke on Broadway in the original cast of Flower Drum Song, my first Broadway show. Ironically he played a traditional Chinese father in that show.

If they had only put a real surprise in the ending this would rate a notch or two higher. As it is The Sky Dragon is a fine film to conclude the series.

Low budget Charlie Chan is not that bad

[csteidler · 6/10 · 3 April 2019]

Charlie Chan and number one son Lee doze on a plane trip. Lee wakes up and discovers that the passengers and crew are all out cold. Everyone has been drugged (except for him and his pop, who didn't drink their coffee). A dead body is lying up near the cockpit and a large packet of cash has vanished.

The Chans investigate, of course, and suspects include a pilot and his stewardess girlfriend, a pair of suspicious-looking passengers who appear to be stalking a different stewardess, and a security guard in charge of transporting the now missing money. Back on the ground, the action flows from a nightclub to the Chan home and finally back to the airplane, where Mr. Chan gets everybody back on board to explain his deductions and draw out the killer....

Roland Winters and Keye Luke are just fine as the Chan father-son team. Unfortunately the script doesn't offer them much in the way of clever dialog, but they dutifully investigate the case and manage to keep it fairly lively. Mantan Moreland offers support as chauffeur Birmingham Brown. Tim Ryan as a detective and Milburn Stone as the airline pilot are among the other vaguely familiar faces in the cast.

It's not particularly exciting or surprising but at least the plot makes sense. So it's no classic--but heck, it is kind of fun.

People Take Things So Seriously

[Hitchcoc · 7/10 · 25 January 2016]

This is it for Chan (at least for the three actors that did the B-movie thing). It involves a plot that has been done any times since. That of a murder on board an airplane. We have a finite set of suspects. There is some history among the passengers. There is a large sum of money involved. And, Charlie and Lee (Number One Son) are on board. We have been told that Lee has been trained as a pilot for several episodes, so there is no big deal when assumes control of the plane. This has a nice cast of very recognizable actors. Noel Neill who was Lois Lane in "The Adventures of Superman" and Milburne Stone from "Gunsmoke." I also remember a show called "The People's Choice," which starred a heavy set guy who played the Mayor. There is no way to keep these people on that plane and they are allowed to leave. Of course, murders are committed and lots of drama ensues. For the final time, a light is turned out and a man is assaulted by an intruder.. How many times!!! This is the most entertaining of the Roland Winters films. I'm puzzled at the great disdain held for him. The earlier Chan movies weren't really all that great anyway. Having Caucasian men play a Chinese detective creates problems from the start. I guess there is a charm in seeing these actors do their thing for very little money. We could criticize till the cows come home, but these weren't ever works of art.

Finale of the Chan franchise.

[michaelRokeefe · 7/10 · 29 July 2011]

Also known as MURDER IN THE AIR, this is the sixth Chan film starring Roland Winters. To be exact, this is the last in the Charlie Chan franchise that began at Fox Films about 19 years earlier with Warner Oland playing the American-Chinese detective from Honolulu. The series pretty much began declining in substance and popularity when Winters took over for Sidney Toler as Chan in 1947. This film has Charlie on board a flight to San Francisco with #1 son Lee(Keye Luke)and his bug eyed chauffeur Birmingham Brown(Mantan Moreland). Before arriving at their destination passengers and pilots are drugged and upon waking up an insurance courier is found dead and the quarter-million-dollars he was carrying is missing. Winters is lackluster in performing his duties as the honorable detective. Moreland provides some rib splitting comic relief as usual and Luke gets to fly the plane to the closing credits. (Did they not plan this to be the end of the series? You would figure the lead character would close out the string of murder mysteries). Also in the cast: Milburn Stone, Noel Neill, Tim Ryan and Lyle Talbot. Ah so, Charlie Chan.

The last of the Charlie Chans!

[JohnHowardReid · 5/10 · 25 April 2018]

Director: LESLEY SELANDER. Screenplay: Oliver Drake, Clint Johnston. Story: Clint Johnson. Based on the character, "Charlie Chan", created by Earl Derr Biggers. Photography: William Sickner. Supervising film editor: Otho Lovering. Film editor: Roy Livingston. Art director: David Milton. Set decorator: Raymond Boltz, junior. Make-up: Web Overlander. Special effects: Ray Mercer. Production manager: Allen K. Wood. Music director: Edward J. Kay. Assistant director: Wesley Barry. Sound recording: Tom Lambert. Producer: James S. Burkett.

Copyright 1 May 1949 by Monogram Pictures Corp. No recorded New York opening. U.S. release: 1 May 1949. U.K. release through Associated British-Pathé: 24 September 1949. Australian release: 8 December 1949. 6,129 feet. 68 minutes.

Alternative title: Charlie Chan and the Sky Dragon.

SYNOPSIS: All the passengers and the crew of an airliner on which Charlie Chan is travelling, are drugged. The plane continues its journey on automatic pilot. When the great detective awakes, it transpires that the sum of $250,000 is missing.

NOTES: 47th and last entry in the Charlie Chan series, and the 17th of the Monogram films.

COMMENT: The last of the Charlie Chans boasts a reasonably impressive cast, a moderately intriguing mystery, competent enough direction and an extremely modest budget. Everyone agrees that this is not one of the better films, but all the same, it's a pity the series finished off just as Roland Winters was finally getting into stride.

mayhem on a plane

[blanche-2 · 6/10 · 16 July 2021]

Roland Winters is Charlie Chan in "The Sky Dragon" from 1949.

Chan and his son Lee board a plane to go to San Francisco. Lee is very excited, as he's been taking flying lessons from the pilot. If Lee looks a little older here, it's because he's 45, and his father is the same age.

Coffee is passed around, and Lee spills his coffee on his dad. The coffee was drugged; so fortunately, Lee doesn't get much. He finds the detective hired to guard $250,000 that was on board plane dead, the pilots drugged, and the money gone.

Charlie figures the money was thrown out of the plane via parachute. And there are a lot of suspects - like everyone. The hostesses, played by Noel Neill (of Superman fame) and Elena Verdugo (of Marcus Welby fame) are suspects, as are the pilot (Milburn Stone of Gunsmoke), the copilot (Joel Marston), a burlesque queen (Iris Adrian) and her brother-in-law (Lyle Talbot), and a Mayor (Paul Maxey of The People's Choice). A baby-boomer movie for sure.

This was the last Chan film, with Winters a rather staid, formal Charlie spouting his words of wisdom. "Innocent act without thinking, guilty always make plans." Humor is added by Mantan Moreland as Birmingham, who aids Lee in an investigation, breaking into the burlesque house.

Enjoyable with some interesting camera work - everyone in the plane turning and facing the camera while Charlie is talking.

Though it's seen as un-pc today, this was a fun series.

Thankfully, the last of the Monogram debacles!!

[rapzz · 1/10 · 6 June 2006]

It's too bad that Fox hadn't continued on with the Chan series as they could have made an excellent movie with a small amount of rewriting of this script. Sidney Toler had done his best to "rescue" the 11 Chan movies he made for Monogram before his death – but Winters is simply a cartoon of Chan in the 6 movies that he made, including this one. This vehicle was a sad ending for the Charlie Chan series, first started by Fox with healthy budgets allowing excellent movies that audiences enjoyed throughout the world. But then degraded substantially after Monogram entered the scene with their miniscule budgets (Tolar was unable to raise enough capital on his own to continue the series after Fox dropped the series).

Regarding the childish "racist" comments from others: My wife, an RN with a Masters Degree, was born and raised in China, moving here to the U.S. in her late 20's. We have collected all of the known Chan movies, and she thoroughly enjoys the Oland and Tolar movies for what they are – interesting, provocative detective episodes. When I asked her if she felt the movies were racist, she firmly stated that people making those statements obviously don't understand the world as it was when these movies were made. They should be enjoyed for what they were meant to be. Her actual final comment was that "it's too bad that people like that can't seem to grow up and get a life!"

Roland Winters imitating Asian speech is the best part of this film

[CourtoftheTable · 4 August 2002]

As an avid collector of all Charlie Chan films except for the Fox Four, I have avoided getting Roland Winters 6 films but finally purchased the Sky Dragon. It will end there. There is no magic at all it is a stilted film with no imagination and a story line to match

Coffee? Tea? Chloroform?

[mark.waltz · 6/10 · 18 September 2023]

Such is the service on this San Francisco flight that Charlie and Lee Chan happen to be on in the last of the series which lasted for nearly 20 years. It's also a well done one thanks to a feisty supporting cast and an above average plot involving the theft of $250,000 and the murder of its guard after the crew and passengers have been knocked out. There's also intrigue involving the presence of blowsy burlesque queen Iris Adrian, confronting stewardess sister Elena Verdugo over running off on husband Lyle Talbot who is traveling with Adrian. Tim Ryan repeats his role as a San Francisco police detective.

Then there's a shootout at the burlesque, providing this with lots of action and comedy featuring driver Mantan Moreland, flirting with Adrian's maid, Louise Franklin. With her brash personality and voice, Adrian steals every scene she's in, or at least gets unwanted attention for those who are annoyed by her. No. #1 son Lee (Keye Luke) has come along way since the Warner Oland days, 14 years older and more mature, and giving indication that in addition to being a great pilot, he'll also be a fantastic part time detective.

Great title. Poor picture.

[admjtk1701 · 2/10 · 20 April 2000]

The last Chan film made by Monogram and Roland Winters is a sad final bow for the great detective and great film series. The supporting cast is good for a Monogram picture. The best thing about it is that Keye Luke is back as Lee Chan. Great title. Poor picture! Sorry Charlie!

The End

[utgard14 · 5/10 · 24 March 2014]

The Charlie Chan series at Monogram comes to an end with this picture. The plot sees Charlie (Roland Winters) and "Number One Son" Lee (Keye Luke) on an airplane where all the passengers are drugged. While they're out, a man is murdered and a quarter-million dollars stolen. Also appearing in this one is bug-eyed comic sidekick Birmingham Brown (Mantan Moreland). The rest of the cast includes Milburn Stone (Doc from Gunsmoke), Noel Neill (Lois Lane from Adventures of Superman), and Lyle Talbot (movie star extraordinaire). Winters is weak as usual but the plot is surprisingly fresh for Monogram. Keye Luke is fun and the supporting cast is decent. It's ironic that the Winters series ended after its two strongest films. But it was a case of too little too late, I think.

Last...and among the least.

[planktonrules · 5/10 · 31 July 2018]

After almost four dozen films, this was the final installment in the Charlie Chan series from Twentieth Century Fox and Monogram Pictures. Like the final six, this one starred Roland Winters as the detective...and his version of Chan was far weaker than the one played by Warner Oland as well as Sidney Toler.

The story begins on an airliner. Chan and #1 son, Lee (Keye Luke), are aboard and things seem pretty normal. After all, Charlie had just finished a case and they're heading home. However, something evil is afoot....and Lee realizes it when he awakens to find everyone either asleep or dead! One of the pilots was stabbed and someone obviously knocked everyone else out by lacing the drinks with something....and a fortune in money being transported in the plane is gone!

Like all the later Charlie Chan films, this one is weak...but still watchable. Roland Winters simply isn't as fun as Sidney Toler and the solution to all this was telegraphed. When baddies all 'accidentally' get shot and killed by the same person, it doesn't take Charlie Chan to figure out they are evil! Fair...at best.

Chinese Wisdom

[tedg · 23 September 2004]

Spoilers herein.

Yes, this stuff is racist, and poorly produced to boot. But originally, the idea was to annotate the game of detection - that strategic movement between writer and reader - with Chinese sayings. Those were really pretty apt, both so far as the mystery and the denoting of wisdom.

In the hands of a good writer, it was innovative and useful. In the hands of a hack, its Saturday morning skit quality.

Ted's Evaluation -- 1 of 3: You can find something better to do with this part of your life.

The final Charlie Chan film is not the worst

[gridoon2024 · 5/10 · 14 March 2016]

"The Sky Dragon", the final film in the Charlie Chan series, is described as the "nadir" of the series by Leonard Maltin and given a BOMB rating in his book. Now, I haven't seen many Chan films (yet), but this cannot be the worst when it is in fact better than another one which I saw only yesterday, "Golden Eye". It opens with a rather unusual setup (a murder, plus the robbery of a quarter of a million dollars, aboard a plane), and if it had stayed on the air it might have been a much-needed change-of-pace. It soon (crash)lands on earth, and becomes deadening at times, but at least it returns to the scene of the crime in the last 10 minutes for a traditional gathering of the suspects and unveiling of the culprit(s), and there is some cleverness in way the robbery is carried out (though the main killer is obvious). It's a movie only for the most dedicated buffs of the mystery genre, and they may get some fun out of it. My favorite Chan line: "Tired man's idea like children's nightmare: easily dispelled by light of day" ** out of 4.