Dear Caroline (1951) User Reviews

Carry On Candide

[MogwaiMovieReviews · 6/10 · 22 January 2023]

Very French in being both earthy and romantic, poetic and erotic, Caroline Cherie is a handsomely shot shaggy dog story and tragi-comic romance set in the thick of the French revolution, the 'Candide'-like tale of a spoilt young aristocratic girl suffering greater and greater indignities and deprivations during the Reign of Terror. Production values are excellent and the black & white photography is inventive and beautiful. Some shots reminded me of The Third Man, which of course was made around the same time.

What most stand out today are the occasional glimpses of the nude body of lead actress Martine Carol, which would have been unthinkable in any British or American film of the same era, but here they just seem a part of the story along with everything else.

It's not a first rate film - the witty characters never take on enough weight and depth, and it's a little too slow-paced and long - but it's a delightful confection to exist and certainly worth checking out, even if only the once.

6.7/10.

Very entertaining,and quite mad!

[dbdumonteil · 8/10 · 2 July 2002]

The highbrows will turn their nose up,but like it or not ,"Caroline chérie" is a treat,a delight,sparkling like champagne and full of humor at that.

14TH July 1789:The De Bièvre family celebrates something in their old dusty castle;no,not what you're thinking of,something else :a ball,in order to marry their ugly daughter to a wealthy noble.But the girl in question has a little sister,the gorgeous Caroline (Martine Carol),18,a beauty to die for...This is the beginning of amorous and fantastic adventures,which take the audience from the streets of the Revolution to the prison de la Conciergerie,from the strange private clinic where doctor Belhomme takes in the nobles who can pay an arm and a leg to save -temporarily - their precious head to the Vendée where the counter-revolutionaries(the chouans) wage their war to restore royalty.An ironical voice -over tells it all:"the problem of the civil wars lays in the fact that,wherever you go,you get busted."

Jean Anouilh's dialogue is funny,witty,there are lines that Billy Wilder would not disown.Sometimes it even becomes sarcastic and somber,sending away the opponents (aristocrats and sans-culottes)without pronouncing in favor of either.Richard Pottier ,an underrated director,works wonders :never a dull moment with him,a sense of rhythm and of humor a lot of his colleagues could and should envy.He films so incredible scenes it's a wonder he can get away with them:an aristocrat woman(Marie Déa) hides Caroline under her mattress while she's lying on her bed,fooling the gendarmes."I feel like a pancake" the safe Caroline sighs; doctor Belhomme simulating a suicide with a corpse he got from the morgue,to allow Caroline to escape;Caroline ,"proving" to the Chouans she's a woman;Caroline's husband ,a new dignitary of the directoire government,then the day after a convict en route for the penal colony on the islands in the sun (or not).

It's a long movie (running time:2h15) ,but so many things happen you will not get bored a single minute.A lot of colorful characters appear ,and joys of joys ,even God Himself is invited for the last picture.And,believe it or not,at a time when sequels were hardly known,there were two of them "un caprice de Caroline chérie"(1952) and "le fils de Caroline chérie"(1954),both by Jean Devaivre who's no match for Pottier,both in color.Martine Carol is featured in the former (and her furtive nudity during her bath caused an outcry at the time!),but she's no longer in the latter.These sequels were ahead of their time:they were already proof positive that sequels should not be made.

But do not think twice:watch "Caroline chérie" if you can!