Where Chimneys Are Seen (1953) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Interesting and fluid movie from the classical period of Japanese cinema
Andy-2963 October 2015
Warning: Spoilers
An interesting film from the classical period of Japanese cinema, the 1950s. The action takes place in a poor neighborhood around Tokyo (which seems almost a slum) during the hard years of the early postwar in Japan. Near the neighborhood are located four giant smoke spewing chimneys. A motif in the film is that depending on where you are located, a chimney can cover other one, so you only see three, or even two of them (this is alluded in the Japanese title).

In a modest house in the neighborhood lives salary man Ogata (Ken Uehara), with his long suffering wife Hiroko, a war widow (played by Mizoguchi regular Kinuyo Tanaka). In the second floor, two tenants live in different rooms, a young man and a woman (she is played by the great actress Hideko Takamine), who slowly seems to be falling in love. Though they are quite poor and struggle to make ends meet, Ogata and Hiroko live a seemingly tranquil life, only interrupted by his jealousy when he learns that unknown to him, and in order to earn a few more yens for the household she has taken a job as a seller in the bicycle race track stadium. Their seeming happiness is suddenly interrupted when someone, apparently her former husband she has claimed died in the war, leaves a crying baby in their house. The couple not only has to deal now with the baby but also with her seeming dishonesty about her past.

The cultural mores and some melodramatic flourishes of the movie seem dated now, but the film is interesting, the direction well paced and the camera-work fluid. Directed by Heinosuke Gosho.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
How Many Chimneys Are There?
boblipton31 August 2019
Kinuyo Tanaka lost her husband during the bombings at the end of the War. Two years ago she married Ken Uehara. They own a mews in a part of Tokyo where the rains flood the ground. They live on the ground floor of one of the building, and rent out the other houses, and the top floor to two tenants in two apartments: Hideko Takamine and Hiroshi Akutagawa. It's a noisy neighborhood from dawn to dusk, what with drums banging and radios blaring. It's distinguished -- in the minds of the occupants, because from the viewpoints of the neighbors, Tokyo seems to have three industrial chimneys. Go elsewhere in the city, and the number varies from one to an unlikely four. The married couple have the sort of quarrels that married couples have, but they are happy, until a baby who cries constantly, adding to the mews' constant noise, is left in their apartment. A note explains that Miss Tanaka's first husband left the baby, because she is his wife, after all, and so the baby is hers.

Heinosuke Gosho's tragic comedy about babies, justice, courtship, and the unreliability of people in general weaves its erratic course between tears and laughter in a surprising fashion. It's a great cast and everyone knows you have to play a comedy like this straight. Miss Tanaka fills her character full of sly and shy grimaces; Uehara is bombastic, Takamine is charming and Akutagawa is an idealistic idiot. Other people fill out this movie with eccentric characters who add the confusion and plot and the ending settles the matter of exactly how many chimneys there are.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Great stuff
rufasff18 March 2003
Another strong postwar melodrama of hard, hard times in Japan. This one, however, has the heartbreak undercut with a certain hopefulness and humor. A little uneven at times, and the character who starts out as the storyteller falls into the background. Still, if you get a chance to see this(it's not on video or DVD) jump at it. Nine out of ten.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed