The True Story of Lynn Stuart (1958) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Ripped From the Headlines
boblipton17 June 2010
Columbia goes to a series of newspaper articles about the drug traffic in this story about upper middle class housewife Betsey Palmer volunteering to go undercover for the narcotics squad. The sincerity of the story telling and, indeed, Miss Palmer's acting, manage to overcome a few holes in logic, like her ability to impersonate an ex-con after studying a list of junkie slang.

Basically the understated night-life photography of Burnett Guffey and a large cast of skilled if little-known screen actors of all ages -- including Snub Pollard and Eddie Le Veque as well as Jack Lord as the lead drug dealer -- manage to keep this interesting enough to overcome the problem. Plus Miss Palmer is gorgeous. It's a pity she didn't get a chance to be in more movies until a quarter century later, but she had plenty of work in TV.
18 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
In praise of Betsy Palmer
mls418230 November 2021
Betsy Palmer proves she deserved bigger film roles. She is quite lovely but more importantly, she turns in a very good dramatic performance in this film.

While some aspects of this film are dated, it is still dramatic and suspenseful. You'll be shocked society had such a problem 60 years ago.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Dames! Always causing trouble!
sol121818 June 2010
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** We get an opening speech in the film from non other then California's Attorney General and later Governor of the Golden Sate Edmund G. Brown. Brown explains to the audience about the evils of illegal drugs and how it's almost impossible to keep them out of the hands of those addicted to them. That's as long as their being smuggled into the state by big time drug kingpins who for the most part seem to be immune from the law.

This is what lead civic minded Phyllis Carter, Betsy Palmer, to takes things into her own hands when her nephew Tommy Efron was killed in a police chase while he and his friend, who also died, were high on heroin. Demanding that the police do something to stem this drug epidemic sweeping the state Phyllis gets nowhere until one of the top undercover men of the Santa Anna police department Nat, Than Wyenn, as murdered in Tijuana by American drug kingpin Willie Down, Jack Lord.

With Nat murdered Santa Anna police Let. Jim Hagan, Barry Atwater, has no choice but to accept Phyllis' offer to help and puts her undercover as the just released from prison, on a bank robbery conviction, gun moll Lynn Stuart. Working as a waitress at an outdoor hot dog and hamburger stand Phillis, as Lynn Stuart, gets to know Willie Down who's known to frequent the place. In no time at all Phyllis, in educating herself in the language of drug and gangster lingo, gets real friendly with Willie who later introduces her to his boss or Mr. Big himself in the California illegal drug trade Doc, John Anderson.

As Phyllis started to get closer to what her boyfriend Willie Down was into her life, as well as those of her family members and friends, became endangered. That's In Willie and friends finding out who she is-A police undercover woman-and whacking her like they did to Nat. It's during an heroin drug hijacking of fellow drug smugglers that Willie knocked off three persons that Phyllis got seconds thoughts into what she was involved with. As well as what she was facing if Willie every discovered who she really was: Housewie Phyllis Carter ace police undercover woman!

***SPOILERS*** With Phyllis losing her nerve in what a very dangerous situation that she's into the news over the radio, at Willie's hideout, that her son Jimmy, Louis Towers, is near death suffering from pneumonia almost has her blow her cover. It's then that Let. Hagan as well as almost the entire Santa Anna police department with agents of the FBI DEA and a unit of California National Guard thrown in comes to her rescue in just the nick of time.

In the end Phyllis had to be put into the witness protection program together with her husband Ralph, Kim Spalding, and son, who had fully recovered from his pneumonia, Jimmie in order to keep members of Doc and Willie's, who were now put behind bars, gang getting their hands on them. It was a high price to pay but it did what Phyllis always wanted in putting away the likes of Willie Down as well as putting the fear of God in them in that there are people, like Phyllis Carter, in the country who are willing to risk their lives in doing so!
2 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
True Story Indeed! Love this great picture! You will too!
vilenciaproductions6 January 2021
This picture rocks! Bought a 16mm print of this great movie and we're projecting it again for 2021! Love Betsy Palmer, Love Jack Lord! Love Edmund G. Brown! Sure wish we had a guy like him around today! Film director Lewis Seiler does an excellent job at the helm, turns out to be his last film! What a shame! See it on film if you can! The best way to watch a great black and white motion picture! Another gem from Columbia Pictures! Can't wait until the projector and screen are set up! Now where did I put that darn old Covid-19 mask?
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Pleasant Surprise
mackjay227 February 2020
Surprisingly well-done true-life crime thriller from the late 50s. Based on a real character and her story, this is a tight little noir-tinged film. Lynn Stuart's is a woman so disgusted by drug-related crime in her area that she volunteers to go undercover with police. Betsy Palmer is excellent as Stuart. She has to play a gun-moll type convincingly, and it's pretty amazing that Stuart pulled it off in real life with no experience whatsoever. Also well cast is Jack Lord as the crime boss Stuart flirts into a romantic relationship with her. He's cold-blooded and Stuart soon finds herself in a very bad situation, made worse by her own family problems. The film moves along nicely and believably. Look for TV and movie regular John Anderson as the stone-faced kingpin and Gavin MacLeod in a small role, twelve years before he joined Mary Tyler Moore's sitcom
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed