The Valiant (1962) Poster

(1962)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
THE VALIANT (Roy Ward Baker, 1962) **1/2
Bunuel197625 January 2008
This was one of a number of Italian WWII-set collaborations with English-speaking countries, a couple of which I watched recently – namely THE CAPTIVE CITY (1962) and TORPEDO BAY (1963). While the handling is fairly dull, the film's main plot develops into a sustained suspense situation as a British vessel (commandeered by stiff-upper-lipped John Mills) is planted with explosive charges by Italian naval officer Ettore Manni and his (wounded) companion, who are then imprisoned on the ship itself after refusing to give details of their mission including the whereabouts of the bomb itself.

An underwater search at night fails to reap the desired results and Mills – with the help of officer Robert Shaw (who's married to an Italian girl) – determines to retrieve the necessary information which could save the ship and the life of more than a thousand men on it. Doctor Liam Redmond opposes his treatment of the P.O.W.s, but remains on board to cure the injured man even after the vessel has been evacuated. The explosion eventually occurs early the next morning – when the ship was scheduled to set sail for war duty; the film, then, ends with Mills awarding Manni for his integrity and loyalty to his cause three years after the fact.

As I said, the film is generally interesting (like the same director's DON'T BOTHER TO KNOCK [1952], it's mostly confined to a single setting) though the interrogation/confrontation scenes do get repetitive; it's also bogged down by resistible comic relief provided by two marines appointed to guard the saboteurs.

P.S. I'd love to revisit Mills' previous effort with Baker (in all, they worked six times together) i.e. the eccentric psychological Western THE SINGER NOT THE SONG (1961) – which I acquired some time ago.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Reviewing the Italian version
malcolmgsw3 May 2024
Warning: Spoilers
As mentioned by another reviewer,this film is an Anglo Italian production. For some reason this film is only available in it's Italian dubbed version. Now this might be an insurmountable obstacle if this were a romantic comedy,but this is a war film, based on real events.

So this is a battle of wills between the Italian divers and the Royal Navy. Most of the film is devoted to the efforts of John Mills and Robert Shaw to find out the location of the mines laid by the submariners.

Lots of familiar English character actors on view even if they seem a bit unfamiliar dubbed into Italian. Probably one of the few Italian successes of the Second World War.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Solid WWII British film
adrianovasconcelos7 June 2023
I have long admired Roy Ward Baker's uncluttered directing style. THE VALIANT presents further evidence thereof. He makes the most of the rather claustrophobic atmosphere arising from filming within the confines of a British Navy vessel.

The acting, in particular by John Mills, Robert Shaw and Ettore Manni, is extremely believable, truly first rate.

The one aspect of the film that impressed me least - in fact even annoyed me - was the script. I realize that the film was probably made on the basis of some real incident in a Royal Navy vessel, but the same ideas are flogged to death, the Britis trying to find out where the limpet mine was placed and when it would explode, and the Italian POWs refusing to give that info.

Mills (playing Capt Morgan) delivers solidly as ship skipper trying to save the vessel and the human lives on it, but his determination to keep a wounded Italian away from hospital treatment so that he too would feel the bomb threat detracts from the sympathy that someone in his position would normally attract.

Anyway, it is worth watching. 6/10.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed