The Five (1995) Poster

(1995)

User Reviews

Review this title
26 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A Colorful & Commendable Crime Caper
Mikihiko Bandai is a disco owner whose business has been severely affected by the economic downturn. He is in massive debt to the Yakuza, and has no way to pay them back. After a scuffle in his disco, Bandai decides to rob the Yakuza, enlisting the help of an ex-cop, a gay hustler, an unhinged salaryman and a Thai pimp. The five pull off the robbery, but in a most frantic and unprofessional fashion, and the Yakuza subsequently hire a couple of deranged sadomasochistic hitmen to track down and take out the thieves. So begins a game of cat and mouse, where Bandai and his crew struggle to stay ahead of impending death, in Takashi Ishii's 'Gonin.'

A corker of a crime film, 'Gonin' is an unpredictable and entertaining trip across Tokyo in the company of wild and crazy fellows that one will find hard to forget. Written and directed by Ishii, his tale is full of unexpected moments and biting, pulpy dialogue, as well as featuring brilliantly realized, distinctive characters and a fantastic ending. The heist sequence is thrilling, while the ensuing hunt is one full of tension and suspense. The film also examines the nature of homosexual relationships with particular regard to power dynamics, and how these can be both healthy and unhealthy, while still containing genuine affection among those involved.

To expand upon this point further, there are two sets of homosexual couples in the film, one of which is based upon affection and respect, the other of which is based on sadomasochism and violence. While Ishii clearly makes the healthiness of these relationships distinct from one another, both are based on love and a deep need for connection. Though perhaps a somewhat cursory investigation, Ishii's exploration of homosexuality in all its' forms is most interesting, giving the film another dimension for viewers to ponder.

'Gonin' features arresting cinematography from Yasushi Sasakibara, who makes excellent use of light and shadows to reinforce the darkly mysterious tone of the film. His work under Ishii's direction is fitful and evocative of noir, exuding at times a dreamlike quality that makes the irregularity of the narrative all the more potent. Akimasa Kawashima's editing is intuitive and intelligent- no scenes go on too long, nor does the film's determined and frantic pace ever lose momentum. It is a supremely fine picture in visual terms, with much to laud over on the technical side of things.

Additionally, Goro Yasukawa's score is dramatic and stirring, giving to the proceedings a mournful quality that heightens the narrative impact. Alicia Hayes's costume design is also of note, especially her crocodile skin outfits for the gay hustler, which adds both to his characterization and to the depth of the picture's detail. On the whole, 'Gonin' is an achievement on practically every level; and a very memorable one at that.

The film features an ensemble cast, though Koichi Sato is the ostensible star, playing Bandai. He delivers a performance of unwavering certainty and resolve; were this film 'Oceans 11' he would be Frank Sinatra: calm, cool and consistently collected. Masahiro Motoki co-stars as the gay hustler and seriously impresses with his range of emotions and mastery of understatement. The character becomes something of the emotional heart of the film, and Motoki will move any viewer with heart left enough to stir.

Also worth mentioning from the cast are Naoto Takenaka and Takeshi Kitano, playing the unbalanced salaryman and the leader of the hitmen, respectively. Takenaka showcases the madness of his role wonderfully, going rather over-the-top, but not in an offensive way; remaining sympathetic- though utterly insane. Kitano all but steals the show as the sadistic, gay hitman, a role echoing the one he played in his previous 'Boiling Point.' He is terrifying, sometimes a little humorous; and always captivating to watch. Though he has less screen time than Motoki, Sato or Takenaka, Kitano really makes his presence known, dominating the latter half of the movie completely.

A colorful, commendable crime caper, Takashi Ishii's 'Gonin' is a marvelous movie sure to entertain and thrill audiences everywhere. Featuring an original, wild story full of sharp dialogue and well-rounded characters, the film is an unpredictable as it is enjoyable. Boasting strong performances from an ensemble cast, an assured visual style and a fine score from Goro Yasukawa, there is very little not to commend about the picture. If you are a fan of crime fiction, watch 'Gonin;' it shouldn't disappoint.
23 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A hidden gem of Japanese Noir
BeyondHardBoiled1 March 2015
This film by Takashi Ishii should be more well known.

A night club owner, a extortionist, a pimp, an insane business man, and an ex-cop come together to create the title's team of Five to rob the Yakuza. As the film goes on, they are hunted by two pro killers that are seemingly around every corner.

The story itself is nothing groundbreaking, but the style makes it worth it. There are several elements Ishii uses to create this solid crime thriller.

The overall cinematography is excellent, presenting dark shadowy shots, which reflect the film's dark tone and settings.

The characters are also well done, each one's backstory slowly revealed as the film goes on. They're fairly unique and interesting, enough so that the audience can sympathize. Each actor puts on a satisfactory performance that is pretty realistic.

The soundtrack combined with the great directing constructs genuinely unsettling scenes.

Some parts here and there are a teeny tiny bit forced, but can be easily forgiven.

Many of this film's viewers come to see Takeshi Kitano, but he's only a small part of the whole thing. If you're disappointed, there is much more to this picture to look forward to. It's one of Beat Takeshi's best films he only acts in.

Ishii is well known for his manga art, but that should not over shadow his film making capability. I have not seen Gonin 2, but look forward to seeing it. He is know releasing a third, Gonin Saga which I am excited for.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
good movie with great spots
Lumpenprole21 January 2002
An extremely fast paced gangster film with a couple of great elements that rescue it from being ordinary. Takashi Ishii's wonderful neon/fluorescent aesthetic runs throughout the film. Everything is either some kind of oddly-colored light source, an actor, or pitch black. The music is moody and the violence is just erratic and savage enough to be fairly unpredictable. Of course, nobody conveys violence quite like Takeshi Kitano who shows up for the last half of the movie as a hitman creepy enough make Christopher Walken uneasy. The homoerotic tension between the heroes is surprisingly touching by the end and there is one psychotic salaryman that makes an awfully big impression, which I won't risk giving away.
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A very dark, strange and violent crime thriller.
Infofreak5 June 2003
The first Takashi Ishii movie I watched was his excellent rape/revenge thriller 'Freezer', but his reputation as an exciting director with a lot of potential mainly rests on his yakuza movies, of which 'Gonin' is perhaps the best known. This is a really impressive movie, very dark, strange and violent. The bare bones of the plot - a group of guys decide to rob some gangsters, the gangsters vow revenge - is one that we have seen many, many times before in American movies, but Ishii manages to put a fresh spin on it, with unusual characters, and consistently original direction. I was fascinated from beginning to end. The ensemble cast are all excellent, but the most memorable performances are by Naoto Takenaka (who later appeared in 'Freezer', and Tsukamoto's astonishing 'Tokyo Fist'), who plays the unhinged salaryman Ogiwara, and cult figure Beat Takeshi, who plays Kyoya, the ruthless eyepatched hitman. Takeshi steals every scene he is in, and plays one of the nastiest characters of his career, only really topped by the psycho he played in his own 'Boiling Point'. 'Gonin' is highly recommended to anyone who enjoys doomed caper films, a genre that has its fair share of classics from 'Bob Le Flambeur' and 'The Killing' to 'Reservoir Dogs' and 'The Usual Suspects'. Add 'Gonin' to the list of those crime classics. Yes, it's that good!
16 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Dark stuff...
timnil16 May 2003
Unlike a lot of stylized American crime cinema, this was an unrepentantly dark film. Filmed with many shots for dark, dank, rainy streets and warehouses, the cinematography reinforces the bleakness of the situation the characters face. As the Japanese economy busts in the mid 1990's, a group of out of luck businessmen rob a crime boss of a large amount of money. The gangsters send a couple of hit men out to even the score with predictable results. (6 out of 10)
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
needs to be more bleak
Nephilim-627 November 2003
I won't say this is a bad movie. It really isn't. But when I see the name Kitano on the cover I expect bleakness, utter despair, or hilarity.

This movie however doesn't know what it wants to be. You have yakuza, extreme violence, some really sick scenes, loss and then... quirky humorous characters... While I don't mind quirky humor, it doesn't blend well with the rest of the story..

A bunch of guys plan to rob the Yakuza but even though they get the money all hell breaks loose since the yakuza track down the robbers and send 2 hitmen after them. Result: lots of (often intense sick yet sexy) violence Tarentino can learn from with drama and: humor ?!? Doesn't really work for me.. Atleast not when I'm in a nihilistic/destructive mood.

All in all. an okay maybe even fun movie but not one for those of Kitano's usual movies. (and yes I know he didn't direct this one)

6.5 or 7 out of 10
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A superb movie with wit...
Bruceva3 June 2003
I watched Gonin about 3 times by now and still I have to say that it is a great movie even if evaluated under different perspectives. Each character is a profound mixture of different shapes. Out of a certain kind of despair every person in the movie develops its unique behaviour which is a result of their lifes they were living. Gonin includes many interesting themes such as homosexuality, childhood, fear and last but not least what life can make out of every person when it crushes upon you. Lately it appeared to me as if the modern hero has to be an introvert ruthless killer without emotion and basically I have to say that those tendencies are found in Gonin as well - Although it is rather an antihero who is presented in Gonin by the actor Takeshi Kitano in the role of the killer taken into service by the Yakuza-boss. The most remarkable scene as far as I'm concerned is the one where the story of the weird man, having lost his job, comes back home after they had stolen the money from the Yakuza. Gonin is a movie with great suspense and, if watched carefully, with profound and emotional content.
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Even a talented director has flaws
neverfragged22 November 2001
When I first saw this movie on TV - and the movie seemed to be heavily cut - I only thought that Takashi Ishii is really a director with talent and the ability to create something special and unique. The fighting scences looked sometimes very improvised, but were in fact strongly choreographed and filmed in a stylish way that gave you an intense feeling while watching them. But there were also scences where I unfortunately didn't get the point. For example: The ex-cop is sitting in a restaurant, his wife and daughter are at the restroom, so he is waiting. Then a cut and suddenly everybody in the restaurant has disappeard - no guests can be seen anymore, no waiters and so on. The wife and the daughter come back and the action begins... and where is the rest? That was definitely a directional flaw. 2. When the man with the glasses comes home he sees his daughter - all fine. He goes in the room of his son, but he can't even see, that his son is lying dead in the bed. His wife has obviously left him, so he is phoning a prostitute and 2 secs later the action begins again. Excuse me, but that's terribly directed. 3. The two desperates are attacked by the two hitmen, escaping in a restroom, waiting there behind a door made of wood. The hitmen fire through the door, they scream and seconds later, the hitmen are away. That's sheer nonsense in my opinion... The characters seem to be underdeveloped. What's up with their background story? Nothing can be found... Especially the gigolo. I still don't know what's up with that person.

First and last an interesting movie with some flaws but a great atmosphere, never before seen acts of violence and a very bizarre ending.

7/10 - still better than any Hollywood picture
0 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Powerful use of symbols creates a complex movie from a small story.
Pingo-216 June 2004
GONIN is one of the best Japanese movies I've seen. It's use of symbols and dreams in almost every scene makes it a bit hard to get into at the first watching, but if you see it several times, you will see why this is one of the highlights of Ishii.

The story is easy to follow and is about five men trying to rip of the Yakuza. Things doesn't go exactly as planned (do they ever?), and they end up chased instead.

This could have been a really bad film because of the simple plot, but because of the extremely powerful characters, the complex figures that we see and with full blown motives of everyone involved, this gets to be a very interesting and good movie.

I've seen this movie about five times now, and I must say that it has grown. I see new things and can explore side-plots still, which is why I keep coming back to this wonderful film.

If you think it is too slow, too weird, too violent, too Japanese or antyhing like that, maybe you should give it a second chance.

This is NOT your standard action movie. This is NOT Violent Cop or a HK-film. This is pure drama with an action movie thrown into the mix. Beautifully made, with exploring of gay sexuality, mafia psychology, more true characters than any other action film. It's a gem.

I've voted 9 of 10. I would have given it a 10 if I had thought what I think of this movie the first time I saw it. Now, it might be a bit too complex, but that again just makes it a film that will be nice to see in ten years from now.

Very good film.
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
A Gloomy, Bloody and Mean Spirited Film
jmaruyama20 August 2000
Tadashi Ishii's Gonin is a crime drama, thriller much in the same vain as Quentin Tarantino's Reservoir Dogs and Ringo Lam's City on Fire. As such it is very hard to watch. The world of Gonin is a dark, cruel and gloomy world inhabited by sadistic gangsters, cold blooded killers and suffering opportunists. Gonin is a very good looking film. Ishii's flair for style and action is clearly apparent and admired but the story is such a gloomy and sad affair that one cannot help but be turned off by all the tragedy and suffering his main characters go through. Takeshi Kitano (aka Beat Takeshi) plays a small part as one of the Yakuza assassins sent out to kill the Gonin after their heist. If you like the raw intensity of Reservoir Dogs and Pulp Fiction, then Gonin may be your cup of tea.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Touching, surprising
barryalanmarshall18 May 2006
Warning: Spoilers
I have had this film in my possession for 18 months but had not got round to watching it all the way through until a couple of weeks ago.

The plot is old hat: an attempt by some small timers to get one-up on the mob, but this film succeeds, in spite of its flaws, because of the connection we feel for the characters and the connections between the characters themselves.

Mr Bandai is a nightclub owner. It's not a successful business or glamorous interior. It is, in fact, gaudy, almost tawdry, and certainly empty. It's in the middle of nowhere, going nowhere. We only really see it frequented by those to whom Bandai owes money and who are there to collect. Obviously Bandai hasn't got the money, so after being threatened and ordered to pay up or else, he decides to rob them.

The gang he assembles to pull off the heist are themselves society's drifters, outcast and tawdry, failed people. One cannot help but connect this film to the economic crisis in Japan at the time, when many in a society, where 'keeping face' is of the utmost importance and unemployment a social stigma, were thrown off the economic shelf onto the scrapheap. In fact, as the film reveals, one of the characters pretended to his wife and kids he still had a job, but they left him, unable to bear the stigma.

If this film is about confronting taboos in this respect, it also transcends others. The relationship between Mr Bandai and Mitsuya forms the core of the film. Mitsuya extorts money from wealthy men who don't want their secret lives revealing. He enters the film extravagantly, his behaviour is deliberately arch and artificial and his brash clothes and long hair hiding a vulnerable young man. As a homosexual he is one of society's outcasts, but Bandai accepts him for who he is – even after Mitsuya makes an early move on him.

As the film develops, Bandai and Mitsuya are pursued by hired hit man Takeshi Kitano, with whose side-kick there is a sexual relationship – but the inverse of that between Bandai and Mitsuya: one based on domination and abuse. Connecting the two main protagonists, however, there is respect, help and communication, which through the course of events flowers into a deep bond and love.

Sadly, given the film's progression, we can never know what would have really happened between the nightclub owner and the hustler. After they have almost made their escape together, Bandai is killed and in the moment before he dies he simply kisses Mitsuya. Whether this is as a thank you, a concession to Mitsuya's feelings, or Bandai's true love, the important aspect is that he could not express it until being alive really matters – when we are about to die.

A sad film, beautifully photographed with a dreamy haziness. Bandai and Mitsuya's relationship progresses steadily and realistically. There is nothing sensational or overplayed in the film and with its conclusion comes a sense of palpable loss.

High above standard Asian cop thriller fare. Miike Takashi with feeling.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Pointless gorefest
bleub0y17 April 2004
Handsome Mr. Bandai, disco owner deep in debt to the mob, conceives a bold plan to rip off the very people to whom he owes money. Can he really think they'll not notice when he attempts to pay them off with their own jack, especially as he's present, unmasked, at the ripoff?

His boyfriend, Mitsuya, goes from trying to kill him to taking a shower for him with no stop inbetween.

Two more of his confederates are so obviously unstable it's a miracle anyone would trust them with an errand to buy a quart of milk let alone with a 100 million yen heist at the risk of everyone's lives.

The only one with any sense in the whole undertaking is the ex-cop, Hizu, unless you count having a thing to do with any of the rest of them as indicating an obvious lack of sanity.

You know up front they're all going to get blown away in the end. When finally it happens the only thing you wonder is why it took so long.
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Homo homini lupus
ChWasser4 October 1999
A night-club owner, an unemployed businessman, an ex-cop on drugs, a small-time pimp and a transvestite (well, sort of) find together to rob a yakuza-gang. Against expectation they can pull off the heist, but afterwards they are hunted down by two professonal hitmen (one of them played by Takeshi Kitano at his stoic best). Without giving too much away one can say that the end can compare to "Hamlet" in terms of (relative) body-count.

The story is really simple and has been told many times before, but the great cinematography, the good performances and the intensity of the violence make it seem fresh and exciting. I recommend this film to anyone who likes dark, nihilistic gangster-movies. Definitely not for the squeamish.

("Gonin 2" is not a sequel, but tells a similar story with women in the leading roles. Although also quite good it's not as great as the first one.)
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Dark - Yakuza - Thriller
DJ Inferno14 June 2002
After all you only need three words to describe "Gonin" apt:

DARK

YAKUZA

THRILLER

Got it?!? If you want to know more check out my following review: A very explosive film indeed that seems if director Takashi Ishi had crossed Hollywood examples like "Reservoir Dogs" and "Thing to do in Denver when you´re dead", and added some stylish pictures and typical Asian gun violence to the result. "Gonin" is distinguished by a sinister and hopeless atmosphere as well as the great performances of his main actors. Once more, the appearance of the unique Takeshi Kitano makes the whole film!

Maybe not the greatest movie of Japan´s 1990s cinema, but still a great work and better than 90 % of all those Tarantino rip-off gangster flicks which come from America!!!
10 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Underrated neo-noir gem
FlorianLaur30 November 2020
I never understood why this movie got such bad reviews. I think it's because the people who watched it don't know much about Japanese society and how absolutely excruciating it can be! In Japan, you MUST be part of the group. As an individual, with your own free mind or choices, you're likely to get crushed.

In a way, this is what happens to all our "go nin", literally "five people". One can't make the transition from successful Japanese singer to nightclub owner (due to the Bubble bursting), another lost his job of 20 years. A third makes his living by extorting rich, homosexual man, but actually is homosexual himself (although he won't let anyone know, wearing a mask of kinds). One is a pimp who actually loves one of the girls he should look after, eventually leading to both their demise. And the last is a cop that went to jail for something he didn't do, losing his job and family that meant so much to him.

Society has taken from these men. It made them outcasts. Now you have to remember that the Yakuza started as exactly that! A group of people the feudal Japanese society shunned for their jobs, who in return formed groups to protect themselves. So what irony is it then that a group of outcast robs another group of outcasts? And is finally hunted down by a homosexual hitman couple in a dom/sub relationship, also being outcasts themselves.

From its excellent soundtrack to the beautiful, gritty way it is filmed, Gonin to me stands far above most of Kitano's other movies. I do like Brother and the Outrage saga is great. But Gonin, although hardly having Kitano in many scenes is the strongest of them all, probably because it goes against all mainstream and rules. I can definitely recommend this movie.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Not a good movie
rbverhoef7 October 2003
'Gonin' contains nothing of interest during the whole movie accept for the ending, which has some style and makes the right choices. All other things in this movie are not good. Some things are not bad either but because the rest is bad we hardly notice those things.

The story is the first weak thing. A guy named Bandai (Koichi Sato) owns a disco. Things are not going very well and he accepts money from the Yakuza-gang but can't pay it back. Therefor he decides to steal money from that gang with the help of four friends. When the gang has found out who stole their money they hire two hit men to kill Bandai and his helpers. One of the hit man is played by Beat Takeshi, and he probably is the only one who creates a real character. After this simple set-up the only good thing we see is, like I said, the ending.

Another bad thing is the violence and the way it is presented. Some say this movie is very violent and in a way it is true. But I think you should not take the violence too seriously. Early in the movie a guy is hit by a baseball bat, many times and with some power, and he is still perfectly standing on his feet, ready for a counter attack. Yes, there is violence, but compared to a lot of other movies ('True Romance' comes to mind) 'Gonin' is not that violent.

In the end you are left with a movie that is not interesting at all. It uses slow motion in a strange way, the cinematography is not that special and that combined with a weak story and everything but perfect acting you have a bad movie. Fortunately there is the ending. First of all it saves some of the wasted minutes and second of all we are finally done.
2 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Really really violent
devil.plaything19 June 2001
Wow, nothing short of a masterpiece IMO. Brilliantly filmed, edited, scored, acted, scripted and directed... in fact I don't think I could fault the film in any aspect. Be warned that it is violent though. Very violent. Stylish, surreal and very very violent - one of the most violent films I've ever seen in fact. Not HK-style millions of bullets and a huge body count (counting survivors in GONIN is more appropriate), but a much more japanese style of brutal, realistic violence. Takeshi Kitano films are obviously a good point of reference, though GONIN isn't a Kitano film at all, despite his prominence on the Ocean Shores DVD case. His part is actually very small (but classic Kitano).

The plot involves a guy who runs a disco, who gets into financial problems, so he borrows money from the Yakuza that he then can't pay back. He comes up with a plan to rob the Yakuza of their own money, and assembles a "motley crew" to carry out the plan. This annoys the Yakuza. You don't want to annoy the Yakuza.

The style of the film is somewhat reminiscent of the Korean film NOWHERE TO HIDE, but more violent. Did I mention that it was really violent yet? I'd probably take bets on the director of NTH having seen GONIN before making his film in fact.

I think that's all you need to know. If you're a fan of Takeshi Kitano, extreme Japanese cinema and very well crafted films, get GONIN in your next order.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Overly convoluted heist flick, with not as much substance as it tries to portray.
tntokmenko19 January 2013
I've been watching Asian crime films for quite a while now, and this is hands down the most bizarre I've seen to date. Fans of this movie will claim I don't fully understand the "dynamic of the characters", but frankly this failed robbery/vengeance story has been done before, and in much more comprehensive structure. The only original element is the homosexuality subplot thrown into the mix, but it's not engaging enough to capture your interest in the midst of the crime. Takeshi Kitano doesn't get much screen time or acting range as you'd hope, despite being advertised on the cover, mainly he's just a cardboard supporting character. The real story revolves around a group of five robbers, who's interactions with each other can only be described as baffling. The main protagonists are well aware of Yakuza consequences yet they make mistake after mistake inexplicably. They don't work well to prevent such consequences either, so the climax and conclusion both become predictable. The gratuitous violence was expected, but feels hollow without reason in most places with the exception of the finale. Granted this is a Japanese film and I'm viewing the movie from a Western perspective, however the characters are overall disjointed thus you don't develop a connection with any of the bunch. You don't care if anyone lives or dies so the tension dissolves. I'm a fan of this genre and if your looking for a film in a similar vein, personally I would avoid this one. The movie opens up many doors but leaves them open, thus the viewer receives little payoff. -3/10
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the best action dramas ever!
ishii27 October 1998
This movie is great. I've seen it many times and my enthusiam still increase at each time. The complex storytelling mix with extreme stylized direction by Takashi Ishii make this an unforgettable experience. The violence is intense and at some point graphic but never gratuitous. The director pushes the boundaries of "homoeroticism" action film and all the technical aspects of the film are inventive and flawless. A must-see and one of the best action films ever!
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Underrated
MagnusVulture21 July 2004
Warning: Spoilers
Honestly, I have to disagree. You have all the right to your opinion and I'm not criticizing or arguing with you. I just think it's one of the most subtle, interesting Yakuza movies I've ever seen. Subtlety may throw some as inconsequential nothingness. I dunno, I think by and large Japanese cinema, even mainstream Japanese cinema, is incredibly subversive. On the surface this looks like a weepy gangster movie about five losers who steal then get killed. I think underneath it's about the underdog being crushed by the ruling powers, in this case...five losers who steal then get killed. I dunno, I love it. Gonin 2 is lame as hell though.
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
beautiful great movie
marymorrissey22 April 2004
so what if it doesn't make much sense so what if it's this ridiculous

tough guy gay story at the root, it's so wonderfully written, the

performances are ooonfooockingbelievable I saw it at the theater

and was terribly disapointed at how bad the vhs (an old copy) I

recently rented looked it had been very beautiful and I hope the

DVD is better cause this movie so deserves to look its stylish

wondrous best. so perversely romantic, and full of scenes that are

just kind of like a one two punch, layered and outrageous and

confusing and bewildering but never really making one think "this

doesn't make sense" in short I guess the film creates a universe

of its own that has a certain sense to the audience... I wouldn't say

it's "perfect" but it's got something better than perfection : a beauty

beauty beauty of a film . . . and actually it is perfect
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
a mess of a movie
DanStarkey7 July 2003
An incoherent mess of violent visions, not helped by the execrable quality of the "Ocean Shores" DVD and its dubious subtitles. The popularity of Beat Takeshi must derive from something other than this film, in which he wears an expressionless face and shoots people. If you want to have a better opinion of director Takashi Ishii, watch the far superior girls-with-guns flick Black Angel.
0 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Great Movie, great Photography
pefo192121 July 1999
This is a great movie!!! 9 out of 10; Totally offbeat, and unpredictable as to how it turns out. Also with great photography of Japan.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Outstanding jewelery piece from Japan
searchanddestroy-125 October 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I first discovered this true masterpiece back in 2001, during the Strange Festival in Paris. And I remember that, just after the viewing, I ran through all the Japanese restaurants asking the owners or employees from Rising Sun country if anyone of their relatives could purchase this film for me. I offered at this time the equivalent of two hundred bucks. This crime movie literally froze, astonished me. The kind of crime film I have always craved for. I found here the very same scheme that in Barry Shear's ACROSS 110TH STREET, where a bunch of hoodlums stole the mob's money and then had to fight another bunch of fierce killers hired by the same mob. I won't add much to this pure gem from Japan, but I recommend to every one to watch it. Everything here is flawless, directing, filming, acting and editing. And I adore the moments where you begin to hear the castanets... Watch this film and then you'll understand what I mean.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
This film has permanently scarred my psyche
Masking-tape_Muldoon20 October 2003
It's been a year since I rented this film. I still get nightmares. There is one scene in particular (and I think we all know which scene I'm talking about) Which I've been revisiting over and over again in my most horrible dreams. This film has disturbed me in a way that no film ever has. It's a testament to how dark a feature film can be if the filmmakers choose to go there.

Personally, I know that I will never be the same.
2 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed