The Pupil (1996) Poster

(1996)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
The tutor
jotix10021 July 2010
Warning: Spoilers
A young teacher, Julien Barnes, is engaged by an aristocratic family. In joining the household, he discovers a strange atmosphere in which his employers make eccentric displays about just everything. His pupil, Morgan, proves to be a boy with a high intelligent mind, but little discipline. In trying to get his new charge to accept him, and his authority, Julien discovers to what extent the boy comes to admire his guidance and friendship.

Based on a Henry James short story, "The Pupil", this French film was directed by Oliver Schatzky, who also adapted the material with Eva Deboise, for the screen. The production, set at the end of the XIX century, offers a glimpse at the aristocratic classes in England. The family in the film is far from being rich, but managed to live well through the connections they have made, more on the money they had.

The work of Henry James requires another tone, perhaps, something that the creators have not taken well into consideration. The casting of Vincent Cassel, who has made a career playing tough guys was a surprise, as it shows a versatility from this actor, unknown to his film persona. His Julien Barnes is a prissy man that, while liking the rich atmosphere in which he has come to live, is never quite at home being among these aristocrats. Caspar Salmon, who plays Morgan, makes an excellent contribution to the film. Jean-Pierre Marielle, a veteran screen actor appears as Armand, the patriarch of the family.

Carlo Varini, the cinematographer, captured the atmosphere that goes from splendor into decadence. The Polish exteriors, we believe they were photographed in Krakow, pass for the Russia where they are supposed to take place. Romano Musumarra is the composer of the musical score.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Actually a Henry James short story..
dbdumonteil30 July 2003
..which features ,like "the turn of the screw" -which Jack Clayton adapted for the screen under the title "the innocents" (1961)-, a private tutor and a child .But unlike Clayton's unforgettable movie,there is nothing supernatural here.

The film begins quite well,in a castle where ruined aristocrats eat macaroni in porcelaine .The young actor shines as the whizz kid who knows Latin grammar by heart and never had one friend before his teacher came.Particularly successful is the night scene which displays the child's strange culinary preparations.

But when the family has to leave the desirable castle,it's downhill and even the ending -which is not even faithful to James- does not redeem "l'élève".The film becomes a hodgepodge (hotchpotch) which fails totally to convince:from the ball with the old contessa to the French cancan in a brothel,what nonsense.

Fair-haired (dyed) Vincent Cassel is rather ugly,and is outshadowed by his young co-star.
4 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Just great
gato16 April 2003
A true delicacy of French cinema. Not many films have the touch and manage such internal reflexion and beauty such as this one. It reminds us of one of Balzac's or Victor Hugo's best novels, taken to the screen by a magnificent director.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Vincent Cassel
gabusa31 May 2007
What a great story. An apparently very rich family living in a luxurious French manor, hire a tutor for their son who is a genius..... I was about to divulge too much about that movie and eventually kill the suspense for you... Incredible actors and great subject. I saw Vincent Cassel for the first time in "La Haine". I live in Los Angeles and I did not know that Vincent was the son of Jean Pierre Cassel. In "la Haine", I thought that Vincent Cassel was not a professional actor but a real gang member who had been hired to play in "la Haine" and would never be seen in another movie.(he was excellent too) When I saw L'Eleve and recognized Vincent Cassel as the main actor I could not believe he was the same actor than the one in "La Haine". What a performance. What a great actor!!! More than real as a gang member in "La Haine" and absolutely convincing as a well educated tutor in "l'eleve"
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed