La mort du Chinois (1998) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
1/10
the death of a film
dbdumonteil14 July 2006
Michel (José Garcia) is a writer who pens books for children. Everything is fine in his well-regulated life until one day, his wife Hélène leaves for a Chinese lover. From then onwards, everything goes askew for Michel. He has to come to terms with a serious block and he's especially despondent by his wife's departure. One sole idea remains stuck on his mind: to find again this Chinese lover named Tong and kill him (hence the title of the film). Alas! Manipulated by some of his peers and abusing alcohol and drugs, the frontier between reality and imagination becomes increasingly thin and madness is around the corner...

It's really a shame when a film has a true potential or tries to renew a corny situation (here, the eternal love triangle with a man whom wife deceives him with her lover and he wants to slay him) and totally misses the point. When one watches this hare-brained film, one can guess Jean-Louis Benoît's intentions: to underline Michel's absurd actions and the ways tapped for this to find Hélène and Tong again, to depersonalize Michel and put him in the throes of madness. But it's well known: the best intentions in the world will never supersede a good film.

When one deciphers the story which would seem basically oddball, one notices that Benoît's film is an ill-conceived plan on several aspects. The absence of clarity and dramatic progression are blatant and the scenario is given a desultory treatment with some plot holes. For instance, Michel's editor is incensed by the ramblings stories his writer produces. The problem lies in the fact that we don't always see Michel writing the stories his editor talks about. Then, after Hélène left him with Tong, some Chinese removal men who often come out of the blue move Hélène's furniture and stuff. Why Michel doesn't ask them where Hélène is gone with Tong? Another negative point are the sequences with the policeman acted by François Berléand. Were they necessary for the plot? It's tempting to deem them as filler. And the absurd humor with which Benoît tries to shroud some parts of his movie (the moments when Michel searches his fiancée in unlikely places or with outlandish tricks) generally make these moments fall flat.

Another mistake involves the cast. There is a bevy of true actors here (Garcia, Denis Podalydès, Isabelle Carré) who can shine when they are perfectly guided. But here, it's glaring that the directing of actors isn't the director's forte. They overplay and mix up third-rate acting with humor. I strongly advise you to watch them elsewhere. For example, Denis Podalydès in his brother Bruno's films and if you think that José Garcia is bound to be exclusively typecast in comical roles, well you should have a look at "Extension Du Domaine De La Lutte" (1999), a deeply pessimistic work by Philippe Harel.

So, in the end, what's left in store: a wholly film which speaks volume about the level of input of its creator in his venture. Once again, an unfunny, shoddy film which doesn't make the viewer laugh constitutes a feat from its author.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
The worst ever....
franckgoyer29 June 2003
God! I really tried! Believe me! I have seen a lot of crap movies in my life but this one won the award! I have been with friends to watch it at the cinema because we like some actors acting in this movie (if we can call it so!) but no one of us stayed until the end. The first time I go to cinema and leave before the end. Good luck for those who will try to watch this!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Delicious film, with two levels of reading
evallejr20022 March 2006
Warning: Spoilers
What I love most in this movie is its two levels of "reading". In the first level, we see the protagonist, heartbroken as his wife leaves him for a Chineseman, get involved in by a bunch of strange and progressively crazier characters. But in a deeper level, each one of those characters represent one of the personality traits of the protagonist himself: his sexual urges, his sense of responsibility, his sense of adventure, his intellectuality, and as his world and self begin to fall apart, those different traits lose coherence and fantasy and reality get progressively intertwined. The whole seasoned by hilarious moments of humor. This is one of my favorite films, and a sure bet for those who like a good french film of the new generation.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A harebrained, cockeyed, enthusing film
everaertjoh11 June 2002
La mort du chinois is a 'cracked' light comedy, where Michel writes stories for children with animals that speak. Hélène, his wife, leaves him... So, Michel has no more inspiration... Nor Gérard, his Cassanova friend, neither his new girlfriend Lise can console him. He loses himself in alcohol and drugs... and here the film finds its deeper moments and originality. I adore absurdities, and La mort du chinois gives us them. The hero is lost in a delirium full of... animals. These are surprising even strong moments with wunderful ideas, intersected, yes, by some more heavy gags, but the actors and the whole harebrained, cockeyed film are enthusing.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed