L'assassin est dans l'annuaire (1962) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
an innocent man getting caught in a cruel net
myriamlenys9 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
A lonely male bank employee gets a letter from a certain Jenny who tells him she saw him at work and was impressed by the kindly goodness of his features. Meeting up with her he discovers that she's both young and lovely. Soon he considers her his fiancée. Then he receives terrible news : his fiancée was involved in a car accident...

In spite of some light-hearted lines and scenes, "L'assassin" feels like a thriller/drama rather than a comedy. The plot of this black-and-white movie is quite clever and could have made a thriller for the ages, in the hands of a director of Hitchcock-calibre. As it stands, the movie is pleasantly watchable rather than riveting and fascinating. Fernandel, who has the lead role, does not entirely convince, possibly because he hesitates between honoring and subverting his usual persona. You'll notice that this is one of the many, many thrillers in which the villains, when confronted by their victims, do not hesitate to explain their criminal shenanigans in great detail. In real life such persons would be more inclined to shoot the poor victims in silence - and in five seconds flat.

Watch the last few minutes carefully. A middle-aged loner walks up to a small orphan boy to whom he is not related by blood and declares his intention to shower the child with love and affection. And nobody intervenes in order to question the man about his motives or credentials. The early sixties must have been A More Innocent Time.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Comedy,melodrama,film noir,whodunit....
dbdumonteil20 December 2006
....this Leo Joannon effort is all this ...but not more!

Not unlike Julien Duvivier's "l'homme à l'imperméable" which also featured Fernandel,was also adapted from a Charles Exbrayat novel ,and was finally a failure cause Fernandel is definitely not a film noir actor.

"L'assassin Est Dans l'Annuaire" is more entertaining although it is a bizarre concoction.

Bits of melodrama show up now and than:Fernandel is alone in the world,his colleagues' laughing stock,no love of his own,he looks at the orphans who play in the park under their teacher's watchful eye;Marie Dea"s character and her little boy ,Pierre,whose photograph is in the apartment she shares with her brother but who is living in the country...Fernandel-the-man-in-search-of-love is a character he often played in the past notably in Marcel Pagnol's works ("Angèle" "Nais" whose screenplay Pagnol wrote)

Comedy: Fernandel's character is so dumb,so naive that he can be fooled by everyone.Either he is idiot,or he is a genius ,the Police say,but the shrink (played by the director) knows better.

film noir:the harbor (Rouen) ,the dark streets,the bank and his manager,a small part of a femme fatale played by Edith Scob; but the film noir soon turns to.....

...whodunit as one by one ,the gangsters are strangled by an unknown hand ...

It is a bit stodgy,but Fernandel makes it all worthwhile;no masterpiece,by a long shot,but entertaining.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed