Bobby G. Can't Swim (1999) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
An other Straight Story
thomas.grob6 April 2001
Let me say right away: I like that movie. At its very beginning I was afraid that director Montias would make the mistake to create a negative protagonist. That means a protagonist who hasn't got anything to loose except his life and who could hardly convince the audience that he deserves our empathy instead of simple pity. Let's face it: What does a drug abusing addict mean to you? You read about them in newspapers (mostly when they're found dead), maybe you feel even a little sorry for that poor b...... . But then, there's your favourite soap on TV (ey, life goes on!). Obviously familiar with that specific problem, what could director Montias possibly do to succeed in making the movie work? First of all: Montias gives us a long and well executed (ok, sometimes too slow) exposition of the movie's ‘hero' and the facts of his life. Scene by scene we soon realize that these characters actually aren't any different from us. Second: There's a big deal of humanity in the character's portrayals without the movie falling in cliché-ridden social kitsch. Third: All characters remain true to their aims and they are three-dimensional. The story's straight and the ending believable, even though you could think of an other one (maybe ‘better' one). Well, it's not a movie your life depends on. But it's definitely not a waste of time! And that's even more than you can say about many recent big budget hollywood flick.

My Rating: 7 of 10
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
B-Movie Remake of Carlito's Way, Taxi Driver, ...
GazongaGizmo8 January 2005
Warning: Spoilers
If you like Carlito's Way, Taxi Driver and a bunch of other "streetgangster"-movies, you'll probably like this one - or hate it! 'Cause the plot is like a mixture of above mentioned masterpieces of the gangster genre.

Bobby G. wants to get out of NY, back to Puerto Rico, with his girlfriend. In order to accomplish that he has to do another coke deal, but this time it's bigger than anything he's ever done before. And of course everything goes wrong.

(SPOILER)

Like in Carlito's Way, the protagonist wants to quit his illegal gangster life, because it didn't do him any good in the past. Like Carlito Brigante's, Bobby G.s dream comes closer and closer: he just wants to get out of that damn city and flee to Puerto Rico with his prostitute girlfriend. Sadly, his past gets to him the very last minute he spends in NY. The brother of some guy Bobby G. killed for money some days ago meets him. In a dark and lonesome alley. And the cab with his girlfriend and enough money to get out waits just ten meters from where he gets shot. Yawn.

(/SPOILER)

Don't get me wrong, it's not a bad movie. But if you have seen Carlito's Way and/or Taxi Driver, you're bound to yawn from time to time. If you haven't seen Carlito's Way, DO NOT WATCH BOBBY G.! I did and I wasn't surprised by the way Carlito's Way ended. From the moment Carlito Brigante hits "Benny Blanco from he Bronx" and decides to spare his life, I knew how the movie would end. 'Cause i've seen it in Bobby G.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
LEAN STREETS
george.schmidt2 July 2002
BOBBY G. CAN'T SWIM (2002) ** John-Luke Montias, Susan Mitchell, Vincent Vega, Norman Middleton, Paul Maged, Donna Sonkin, Andrew Rein. Low-budget indie flick reminiscent of `Mean Streets' but without the footloose charm about a low-life trying to make a big score to get a new lease on life. Some competent acting but predictable script by Montias (who also directed) leaves little to be desired but his female co-stars Mitchell and Sonkin have their few moments in the sun.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
bad film
barnardi200224 June 2003
This is the worst film that I 've seen in a while. very amateurish acting and directing. A bad independent film, an imitation of Cassavetes films. But Cassavetes had talent and a flair for good actors. Nobody sticks out in this film. It was a waste of time.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This isn't just another drug dealer film
allbell21 May 2001
It's hard to summarize this film because the facts of the plot make it sound like a ton of other gritty heartfelt films about drug dealers in Hell's Kitchen. One difference is that it's a Hell's Kitchen film that gets the details absolutely right. These characters aren't rich college kids made up to look poor, appearing on million-dollar sets made up to look shabby. These are perfectly cast actors appearing in perfectly chosen locations. Another difference is that this is a deeply spiritual film in a quiet, haunting, non-preachy way. This is a film that will stay with you a long time and make you want to drag other people into theaters to see it.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Exceeds expectations
publius-319 January 2001
This is a real New York movie, for those in the know, you will recognize the seedy side of Hell's Kitchen and your head will nod as you are transported from your seat to the underbelly of the Manhattan drug scene. A fine acting job is turned in by John-Luke Montias and you will find yourself rooting for the "bad" guy, if in fact he is one. Two thumbs up for Bobby G.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An excellent NYC street movie, along the lines of Mean Streets.
mcannie16 May 2002
I loved this movie. It was touching, well shot and well directed.

John Luke Montius is a one-man wonder having written, directed, and starred in this NYC street drama. The hand held cameras gave it a harsh, realistic drive that captured the raw grit of the streets. I foresee "Bobby G" doing very well with the hip, underground crowd.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
I liked it
reptyle29 December 2000
Yeah, I liked it. Watched this film with its producer Holland, and enjoyed it greatly. He told me some interesting things about it, like that they couldn't afford a real police-car (low budget) and had to skip a planned scene with this ambulance at the end of the film. But now there's some sort of remaking available with titled Drugdealer, like trying to be more snappy. Basically same cast, haven't seen it yet.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Interesting look at life on the streets in NY
bigdmuffla3 May 2000
I recently saw this film at the Minneapolis/St.Paul international film festival and I liked it quite a bit. Basically, Bobby G. is a street level coke dealer who gets in a load of trouble when he tries to sell a kilogram to some stupid suburban kids. It was interestingly shot, it kept my attention the whole way through, and I really enjoyed watching it, so I recommend seeing it if it comes to your town.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed