(2001)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A NOSTALGIC SHORT FILM FROM JAPAN?
quinolas22 November 2001
Warning: Spoilers
-SPOILER WARNING-

The film is set in Japan in the 1930s. Taro, on his first day at a new school is faced with one of his most difficult decisions in life. Asked by his teacher what it is most important for him in this world he answers bean cakes (botamochi). In the 1930s, Japan was at the height of her militarist development and by 1936 had invaded Manchuria. Students were taught that the Emperor was a descendent from the gods and that they were all his sons. Soldiers were trained to fight and die for the Emperor.

Taro refuses to change his answer and is threaten with expulsion. The teacher, outraged, sent him out of the classroom and orders him to sit, in the traditional Japanese way that is on his knees, on the corridor until his changes his mind. A girl, feeling sorry for him, offers him a cushion (zabuton). His mother is called and he changes his mind after being asked by the teacher. After meeting the girl, he now has a powerful reason to stay in the school. Back at home he invites the girl for botamochi. Now, asked by the girl, he has to decide whether he loves botamochi more than her. This a little pearl that won the Palm d'Or for best short film at Cannes this year. The film was a collaboration between students of the University of Southern California and the director's, David Greenspan, thesis film for his Master of Arts degree in television and cinema. It can also be an inspiration for future filmmakers who find difficult to get their projects financed. The cinematography reminds you of classic Japanese films specially the ones made during the so-called Golden Age of Japanese cinema during the 1950s. Ozu seems to be a major inspiration, in particular the sequence in the school's corridor. Shots of corridors were constant in Ozu's films. Recently I learned that the film was not actually shot in Japan but in LA. It really fooled me, not just for the use of location but for the use of sound. At the beginning of the film we can hear the sound of cicadas (semi). This sound brings to mind one thing: Japan in summer. Every single Japanese film that I have seen has used this sound to suggest this season.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A brilliant, nearly perfect short film!
frimp1330 April 2002
Saw this short film at Filmfest DC and though it was the best of the shorts shown there. It really captures the feeling of submission to authority that children often feel in school, and magnifies it through the lens of Emperor-worship in pre-war Japan. The naive honesty of the main character, rather than any attempt at subversion, gets him into trouble with the teacher on his first day at a new school.

Half of the dialogue in this film is conveyed through facial expressions and glances, and it's executed flawlessly. The conclusion is sublime - hyperlogical and humorous at the same time. This short is what film is all about - it's sure to put a smile on your face!
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed