El lugar donde estuvo el paraíso (2002) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
1/10
Rain
jotix10014 March 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Not having a clue as to what to expect, but based on the fact that Federico Luppi was involved in this project, we decided to take a chance. Wrong decision! We had failed to note this was a film directed by Gerardo Herrero, who has had better luck as a producer of some well received films, but who unfortunately, as a director, he does not bring an iota of credibility to this story set in Iquitos, Peru. This was a production backed by four countries, so what came out appears to be a case of too many cooks spoiling the broth.

A consul of a South American country in Iquitos, is seen awaiting the arrival of his daughter Ana, whom he has not seen in years. The man, divorced from Ana's mother, is now living in some kind of tropical splendor in a mansion. He is thinking in importing air conditioned units as a business venture. He is now living with Julia, a much younger woman. The consul took Julia from what we took to be a brothel, although it is not clear the club where she sang was nothing but that.

Ana, resents the new woman in her father's life. The capture of a young pilot, Enrico, whose plane was taken as it landed in a river, brings the consul and Ana to check the situation. The local police chief, Goncalves, knows the man in his custody was up to no good. The consul takes him under his custody back to Iquitos. While Ana likes the rugged Enrico, but no one realizes the young man has also had his way with Julia, with whom he plans to escape by getting Ana's help.

The problem with the film is the screenplay written by Jorge Goldenberg and based on a novel by Carlos Franz. Perhaps in the written page, the book made more sense, but as it develops in the screen, it is just plain silly. The dialogue is trite, full of tired expressions and situations, made even worse by Mr. Herrero's bland approach to the material. The only thing of interest is Alfredo Mayo's cinematography of the river and the surrounding jungle.

It is possible any actor can have a bad day, but Federico Luppi appears bored by the whole enterprise. Elena Ballesteros a Spaniard seems out of place. Gianfranco Brero, the Peruvian actor is the best thing in the film.

See it at your own peril.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Division of Argentinians outside their country
esteban174728 July 2003
Any dictatorship brings about division among the people, ones in favor of the regime probably because they receive substantial benefits although some organic ones (without any benefit) favor the regime, and those, often the majority against the ruler and his government. The division exists inside and outside the country, and this is what has been shown in this film. An Argentinian consul in a nice Peruvian site, who used to help anyone from his country, no matter if the person is pro or contra the dictatorship. The plot goes further to show the difference and hate between both groups, which ends with a death of a diplomat's son in favor of the dictatorship. Interestingly, the killer got away but with the help of the consul. The plot also has some interesting aspects related to the relationship of a stepmother (married to the consul) with the daughter of the consul, and the way the first tried to approach the daughter and the scorn always answered by the latter. The film has several original life aspects and controversies shown in a very natural way.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed