Skinflint: A Country Christmas Carol (1979 TV Movie) User Reviews

Unintentionally Hilarious

[donquixote235 · 3/10 · 25 August 2012]

It seems as though every genre has adapted Charles Dickens' classic tale A Christmas Carol to its own tastes, and 1970's country music is no exception.

This movie contains some of the worst dialog I've ever heard. Here's a prime example:

Dennis Pritchett (Bob Cratchett): "Well, ole Skinflint (Scrooge) can go jump in a lake!"

T.J. (Tiny Tim): (despondently) "I sure do wish that I could jump in a lake..." (in his best mopey "aw shucks" voice)

If you happen to find this on some channel or other as you approach the holidays, it's worth having as background noise while you do other things. Otherwise it's a waste of your time.

odd spin on A Christmas Carol

[thomandybish · 23 July 2002]

It's hard to think of a story in English literature that has inspired as many filmatic adaptations as A CHRISTMAS CAROL, Dickens' sentimental statement on Victorian social ills. Setting aside the more than numerous animated versions, we still have countless live-action versions, with many more undoubtably to come. One of the strangest is this, a seemingly forgotten TV effort that, to my knowledge, only aired once during the 1979 Christmas season. It was the basic story, with the kicker being that the setting was transposed from Victorian London to present day Tennessee, and the cast was populated by Country/Western singers! Really. Hoyt Axton as Scrooge, Mel Tillis and Lynn Anderson as the Cratchits, Tom T. Hall as Marley, and I believe Barbara Mandrell as the girl Scrooge left behind. I'm sure there were more, but can't think of them. Since I'm a fan of the story(and love tracking down all the film versions and variations), this one sprang to mind while I was watching scenes from the George C. Scott version(truly the best version in the past 20 years). With the rise in cable availability it seems like this forgotten version would rise to the surface(given all the channels vying for holiday programming), but that hasn't been the case yet. Maybe someday TNN or CMT will show it again.

Blast from the past

[steeleronaldr · 7/10 · 29 November 2023]

How I remember this well and at the time was crazy about country music. Having one of my idols Lynn Anderson in it along with Barbara Mandrell fresh off the smash hit (Sleeping Single In A Double Bed) not to mention such popular acts at the time as Mel Tillis, Tom T. Hall, Hoyt Axton, Dottie West and Larry Gatlin. The acting I'll agree wasn't the best and the production was alright considering all the then big name's in country music at that time. It does however come off as a stage play which places it in it's own platform.

The story which has been told countless times as a mean miserly who is mean to everyone. Is cheap, doesn't spend any money and refuses to be happy. It's when he's visited by a ghost who warns scrooge (skinflint) to change or face three ghost. Tom T. Hall plays the ghost's, we all know the rest of the story. Don't expect too much Christmas songs as most are ample album filler.

Now after 44 year's you would think that this movie would have been released on either VHS, Beta or DVD by now. As someone else states that with all these cable stations showing anything Christmas that this one would appear. Though it's not the best version of it but not the worst either and many of the cast have done since retired, passed away or continue on the road performing in smaller settings.

If you're not a classic country music fan you might find it hard to get into as I say that the acting isn't the best. Every year I look for this one to no success. If you get the chance give it a try, you might not like the movie but it does have some good music in it.

A SKINFLINTS Christmas

[dddefur · 10/10 · 23 November 2016]

This is by far the BEST Christmas Carol I remember to date. There have been many others that are great, what sets this one apart is the setting and the atmosphere. It makes a BELIEVABLE Scrooge version. Maybe if you've never done without or tried to choose between paying the electric bill or eating, this might not hit home so much.But, for those of us who have worked hard just to keep a roof over our heads in some pretty poor,rundown places with slum landlords, this one hits home. I believe in today's world, this would fit in and maybe the spoiled kids,that think the world owes them everything, might see how life was in America once upon a time. I've searched for this to be released, but, so far...nothing.