- Juan: [after "interrogating" Penelope by having passionate sex] I may need a few more hours to pump her for information.
- Juan: You want to know what I did? You all want to know what I did? I, Juan Castillo, went to jail, for having sex with a goat. All right? What do you want me to say? We lived on a farm! And I got lonely! We were just a couple of stupid "kids".
- Hank: When you're all done with your little pink panty meltdown, let me know... 'cause I'd like to get down to business.
- Coconut Pete: I thought it was time to bring in the pro.
- Sam, The Fun Police: Hank?
- Coconut Pete: Yes, Hank. The head of security on all my tours.
- Jenny: So, what? He keeps aging hippies from stealing the bong out of your tour bus?
- Coconut Pete: It just so happens that Hank used to be a federal agent. Yes, that's right. Headed an FBI task force on serial killers. Single-handedly caught the Minneapolis Mangler.
- Lars: Who's the Minneapolis Mangler?
- Hank: Exactly!
- Dave: Pete, you are aware that I've personally served this guy 20 beers a day for the last 10 years, right?
- Hank: [shows a nasty scar on his stomach] Hey, I was in Nicaragua, junior! When you can stuff your intestines back in your pockets and walk 20 klicks to an aid station after a knife fight with guerrilla drug lords, then you talk to me!
- Coconut Pete: If it isn't too much to ask, have sex with the guests. Cause some of 'em aren't bad lookin'!
- Juan: [very upset] Pete! Yu and Hank are dead!
- Coconut Pete: Why? What did we do?
- Juan: No, man. Yu and Hank are fucking dead.
- Coconut Pete: You threatening me? 'Cause if you are, you little hairless lap dog...
- Juan: Ay, puta! Just come and look!
- Jenny: [Re: Coconut Pete's song "Naughty Cal"] Our lives depend on us interpreting the dumbest fucking song I've ever heard!
- Juan Castillo: [reading Penelope's name-tag] Oh, that is a beautiful name. Peen-a-lope. Peen-a-lope. It's breathtaking.
- Penelope: [smiling at his mispronouncing her name] Um, thank you.
- Island Guest: [After hearing the Machete Phil story] Wait, wait... you're telling me that there's some totally deranged dickless dude running around out there?
- Dave: All I'm saying is: I don't go into the jungle alone if I can help it. 'Cause you can hear him, and I've heard him... crying out... "Where's my penis? Where's my penis? Where's my penis?"
- Putman: [suddenly stands up, his pants fall down; he is doing a "dick-tuck" so that it is not visible] And that boy was me!
- [shocked reactions from the group: some are screaming, some are laughing]
- Dave: [stands up, his pants fall down, he is doing a "dick-tuck", too] You're an asshole, Putman.
- [mad that Putman stole his punch-line]
- Fiona: [requesting a song written by Jimmy Buffett, not by Coconut Pete] Play "Margaritaville"! I *love* that song!
- Coconut Pete: [annoyed] Darlin', I think you're referrin' to my song "Pina Coladaburg."
- Fiona: [insistent] No, "Margaritaville"!
- Coconut Pete: I think you mean "Pina Coladaburg." A little song I wrote seven and a half fuckin' years before "Margaritaville" was even on the map! Of course, you wouldn't know that, 'cause you weren't even born yet!
- Coconut Pete: [trying to teach two immigrants to cook for the resort - they don't understand] You think Eddie Money has to put up with this shit?
- Penelope: [lying on top of Juan, who is lying on the ground, and talking in a creepy soft voice] You have been very bad today, Juan.
- Juan: What did I do?
- Penelope: When you were supposed to be in the maze, you were eating watermelon.
- Juan: [shocked] How did you know that?
- Penelope: Because I see everything, Juan.
- Penelope: I go to Oral Roberts.
- Juan Castillo: Oral Roberts? Is that like Anal Johnson? Because I have done that a few times. Or was it Dirty Sanchez? Yes. It was that.
- Putman: David, you hated him for killing your parents. You see, what none of us did know, what none of us could know, was that David's parents were trampled to death at a Coconut Pete concert.
- Jenny: What the hell's wrong with you Putman? Everyone knows Dave's parents got killed at a Pete show.
- Juan: Yeah, way to bring up a sore subject.
- Sam: [referring to lyrics from a Coconut Pete song] You know, octopus spelled backwards is supotco. Juan, isn't that Spanish for something?
- Juan: Supotco? No. But, the word for shoe is zapato.
- Sam: Hmm, shoe.
- Putman: [returning from being on stage] What'd I miss?
- Jenny: Apparently somebody's going to get killed with a shoe.
- Juan: [after Penelope does gymnast moves in the bed room, landing right on Juan] What the fuck are you, a praying mantis woman?
- Dave: [as Dave, Jenny and Sam are watching Juan and Penelope have sex; to Jenny] If you are the killer, that's cool, just, you know, don't kill me!
- Lars: [walks up behind Jenny, who is drinking some booze, and does a Tai-Chi move on her back] Hey, Jenny.
- Jenny: [by sheer reflex, her mouth opens, and the drink in her mouth slobbers down her front] Oh!
- Lars: Sorry.
- Jenny: Give me a heads-up before you do that.
- Lars: It's just a habit. I could see how tight you were from a mile away.
- [Lars starts to drink]
- Jenny: What can I say? Some girls are just tighter than others.
- Lars: [by sheer reflex at what she said, he accidentally sprays out his mouthful of booze in her face] Sorry.
- Hank: All right, since there's no way off this rock, we're gonna have to catch this guy.
- Putman: Catch him? We couldn't even catch the bloody raccoon that was stealing my wristbands last month.
- Hank: You didn't ask me to catch the raccoon, did you, pimp? All right, now here's the plan: you're gonna give this wing-nut exactly what he wants. You're all gonna do your jobs.
- Juan: All right then, tell me something. How the hell are we esposed to do our jobs, when somebody is killing the deek out of everybody on the island?
- Hank: Take it easy there, menstrual cramp.
- [It has just been revealed that Juan has spent time in prison]
- Dave: What the fuck did you do, man? Costa Rican prison - that's some hardcore anal action, man.
- Lars: Back off, fun pig! You wanna fun-fucking-arrest me? You better get a fun-fucking-warrant! Otherwise, stay outta my... fun-fucking-face!
- Jenny: [Dirk and Jenny are in the pool at night; Dirk sneaks up behind Jenny and scares her] You asshole!
- Dirk: No, I'm not an asshole. I'm just young, dumb and full...
- [pretends to be scared]
- Dirk: What the fuck? Something just brushed up against my leg!
- Jenny: [shocked] Oh, my God! What is it?
- Dirk: Seriously, there's something down here!
- Jenny: [frightened] What?
- Dirk: [laughs] Oh, no, wait. It's just my gigantic cock.
- [after putting one of his patented massage moves on the killer]
- Lars: He'll orgasm for another few minutes. Go!
- Putman: I was Andre Agassi's tennis partner for a week. I'm the one who taught 'Dre how to play Cocks and Quarters. Can you believe he'd never played Cocks and Quarters?
- Paul: [from Outtakes] That is so whack! That is so cheebah! That is some trick shit! That is so on time. Off the hook! Tight! And heavy! That is so... out of the planet!
- [laughs]
- Paul: How many other dumbass catchphrases can I say?
- Dirk: Yeah, I heard you. Something about "cocks and quarters". Yeah, we have that here in the States, only we call it "hide the sausage".
- Sam, The Fun Police: Ladies and Gentlemen, welcome to Coconut Pete's Pleasure Island. You have the right to fun. If you choose not to have fun, fun will be provided for you.
- Juan: [to Jenny, hiding in the closet] Eh, I'm still not sure. I may need a few more hours to "pump" her for information.
- Jenny: [mad, whispering] You asshole! Now you're just trying to get laid. How would you like to be stuffed in this closet while I go out there and have sex?
- Juan: That is a great idea.
- [toilet flushes]
- Juan: Shh! Here she comes!
- Sam: Nobody ever suspects the Fun Police.
- Juan: Bullshit. I always have suspected you.
- Sam: Bullshit. You did not.
- Juan: You are the bullshit! He's the guy from the campfire story: Machete Phil, the kid with no dick.
- Sam: No. That's just an old campfire story.
- Juan: What do you piss out of, your asshole?
- Sam: It's just a story! I have a dick. I'm not Machete Phil. I'm Machete Sam.
- Sam: Alright, Lars will probably come after us here.
- Jenny: We don't know for sure that it is Lars. We don't know if he got out, or if someone else got in.
- Sam: [accusing tone of voice] What is it with you and Lars? I'm beginning to wonder if you two aren't in cahoots! I mean, let's see. You had sex with Rolo, and he's dead. You and Cliff, right? He's dead.
- Jenny: [defending herself] Give me a break. I screwed Juan and Pete, and those guys aren't dead.
- Putman Livingston: [feeling hurt that Jenny never had sex with him] Bloody hell, Jen! Am I the only one?