Showbiz Moms & Dads (TV Mini Series 2004– ) Poster

(2004– )

User Reviews

Review this title
11 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A show about parents who have no right to be parents
cosmic_quest20 November 2006
'Showbiz Moms and Dads' is meant to be a reality show following five families' dreams to carve a successful entertainment career for their children but it just came across as a programme about sad, pathetic parents and their poor, poor children.

Eight-year-old Jordan Mosley-Stephens and her mother Kimberly seem to be the only normal family in the show. Jordan is a likable little girl whose feet are kept firmly on the ground by a mother who puts education and manners before air-headed ideas of acting fame. She is also the only one with real talent in the entire programme, reflected by the fact she is also the only one to be offered any decent work.

Family number two are Shane Klingen-Smith, aged thirteen, and his mother Debbie. There is apparently a father and brother in the picture but you'd never know since the mother's life revolves almost obsessively around her son, which is just odd when you consider he is at an age where he should have outside friends. Between his mother and background dancers, Shane doesn't seem to have any male influence in his life at all. This boy is aspiring to be a boy band singer but although he is a cute, if almost feminine, child, he sadly lacks any real talent. In many ways, you wonder if he's being forced on by Debbie feeding his ego and discreetly pushing him since we have a boy here who is actually being sick due to the stress. Surely his parents should be questioning if that is any sort of life for a thirteen-year-old.

Next up are poor little Emily Tye, just four years old, and her domineering mother Debbie (it must be something about the name!). Emily is a beauty pageant contender and this series just highlights why these contests are just legalised child abuse. In one scene, we have this toddler-- a baby, really-- being spray-tanned while she bitterly cries because she is tired and just wants to go home. Her mother, however, thinks Emily just needs to grow up. The only people who need to grow up are the parents who should have bought dolls instead of having children if they felt like playing dress-up. Emily has a nine-year-old brother who is just shoved in the background and he's as much a victim in this whole sorry situation as his sister. Of course, Debbie isn't the only one who needs to re-examine herself. When Emily enters a contest, we see the jealous, childish parents of her fellow young candidates telling their children to shun her because they are in a snit over her 'unfair advantage' of the cameras. Imagine adults actually encouraging their kids to ignore a four-year-old; it would be very sad if it wasn't so disgusting.

Thirteen-year-old Jordan Barron, budding actress, and her mother Tiffany are an interesting case. Jordan comes across as a self-absorbed brat with an attitude problem which weak-willed Tiffany refuses to sort out. The girl isn't anything special in terms of talent and what abilities she does have are ruined by the fact she is incapable of reeling in her cheek. However, I felt there was much going on under the surface that viewers weren't aware of because, to me, Jordan seemed depressed and more angry at her mother than what you'd expect from normal teenage rebellion.

And last but certainly not least, we have the egotistical, arrogant David Nutter and his sad family of a wife and seven children, aged between eight and eighteen. He uprooted his family from their happy country home to New York because he wanted to act and this is one man who certainly suits his surname because he really is a nutter if he can't see how much his wife and elder children resent him for it. I'm amazed his wife hasn't left this selfish man and taken the children away years ago.

'Showbiz Moms and Dads' offers an insight into a world that clearly does need regulating to ensure the children's needs are being met and they aren't being forced into fame by selfish parents. It's a rather sad show in that you can't help but wonder how some of these kids will feel when they are twenty or thirty and look back upon their lost childhoods.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
They're not so bad parents!
Sylviastel5 May 2004
As somebody who always wanted to become an actress, I am now glad that my parents were never show business. I feel sorry for most of these families. I can see Jordan Moseley can become a child star herself. She is talented and cute enough. She seems to enjoy the business whether it's a guest appearance and makes the most of it. She is the only one of the six families that I have any hope for to succeed in this tough business. Now for the others, I feel sorry for Emily Tye at four years old to spend her free time in rehearsals, shopping, and practicing for the next competition. The tanning bothered me too. Doesn't her mother know about the possibility of skin cancer? Emily appears unhappy doing all of this. She is the Jon Benet Ramsey. There is even physical similarities to Emily too. She has spent her short life in beauty pageants. That money could have been used for her college fund. The Tyes also have another son but he appears forgotten most of the time. For Jordan Barron and her family, I would recommend returning to Colorado and taking acting lessons out there. While I don't see any talent from Jordan, she should focus everything in her athleticism and pursuing college scholarships to study acting if she so desires. She was talking about making it big but her chances are impossible. She does not have the talent nor the natural drive to become an actress. I feel sorry for her and her mother. I think they should return home and pursue it locally rather than in Los Angeles. I feel sorry for Shane and his mother but not so much. His mother is older and has her own history of coaching dancers. I think his mother has genuine feelings about her son's abilities. His mother, Debbie, is also more mature and should be hired as somebody's manager too. I think no matter what happens to Shane, he will do fine. As for the Nutters, I have a lot to say and it's not pleasant. I feel sorry for Duncan Nutter. I don't think he realizes his mistakes but he has a wonderful wife, Cindy, who is a Saint to do all of this. If Duncan wants to become a stage actor with his kids, they can go back to Vermont and build a theatre on their property. After watching Bravo, I am sure people would like to meet them. The best stage actors in the world call their stage as their home. With his seven children, I think they would be better served if they returned home and built a stage to express their talents. Now, these are my suggestions for a better life. I don't think the Nutters are very happy in New York City. Cindy Nutter is a saint who tolerates Duncan Nutter so much that she must love him. After all, they have seven children. She enjoys teaching.

Anyway, I watched the follow-up special and I was amused by it all. I don't think the families knew what they were getting into. The Nutters aren't so bad neither Jordan whose mother could be an actress herself and has made the way to management in her company. They didn't take themselves so seriously but I think we did. Oh well, they tried to make in the business. When I look at those who have made it, I can't believe they would let their daughters dress that way or let their sons to be pawns as well. At least these parents never forced so much on their kids. I mean at least they are encouraging them to pursue their dreams. Why shouldn't they aim to be the next Jessica Simpson? Justin Timberlake? etc. They make lots of money and look like they have a lot of fun being rich and famous. But I wish these families aimed at getting their kids studying the classics and singing the classics rather than the contemporary music today and drama today.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sad, sad families.
Gigi_Marie18 May 2004
My mom and I are hooked on this show... But not necessarily because the kids have talent. Actually, most of them just need lives. Let me break it up for you, from my favorite to the one most sickening to watch.

1. Jordan Moseley: I like her and her her mother. She has talent, and she has a good attitude. For example, when she didn't get a voice over part in a show, she said "It's okay, I can't get every part I try out for." I find that very respectable in an eight-year-old child. Her mother is also cool. She doesn't seem to push her daughter, and she doesn't let acting take over their lives. She doesn't hesitate to tell Jordan when she's doing something wrong just because they're on TV, like when she told Jordan that it wasn't polite to interrupt the adults. When Jordan's teacher told her that she wasn't applying herself, she told Jordan that if she didn't do better she couldn't act anymore. I like that- She knows where hers and Jordan's priorities lie.

2. Jordan Barron: She seems like she has some talent, but she has a bad attitude, to tell you the truth. Her mother sits there and lets her daughter complain and be rude. Also, at one point, I remember her going "When Jordan is sick she doesn't have to go to school, but she can still go to auditions." Basically, acting is more important than education. Right. Great example, Mom.

3. Shane Klingensmith: No talent whatsoever. But I think he really does want to do this, and he really believes he has talent, and his mother encourages him. I think they really don't see that Shane can't sing and can't dance. At least Debbie Klingensmith isn't forcing Shane into this.

Emily Tye: This is sad, really. I have nothing against beauty pageants, but at such a young age? How can she have a childhood when she's caking on more makeup than a twenty-year-old? In this case, I have nothing against the kid, but the mother. You can tell Emily's only doing this to please her mom. If she really wanted to do this, she wouldn't cry when on the morning of the pageant. More than once I have seen her crying, saying she didn't want to do this, yet her mother makes her go on anyway. At one point, she was so low as to bribe her with candy. It's sickening. She gives her child fake tans, which Emily doesn't like, and she spends FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS on a tiny dress for a four-yearr-old. Once, Emily was complaining that she was tired, but her mother made her go on practicing. Jeez.

The Nutters: A family of 9 in a two-bedroom apartment in NYC. It's painfully obvious to everyone except the father, Duncan Nutter, that nobody in the family wants to act but him. At one point or another, I have seen every single one of the kids say or show that they don't care for acting, but he's oblivious. This is the most sickening part of the show. His wife is nice, but come on- She needs to step in and say "OK, you need to stop this nonsense." 'Cause these kids are going to grow up seriously messed up.

So that's my review. Sometimes it's nice to watch, but mostly it's sickening and scary. All I have to say is- Thank you, thank you, Mom and Dad, that I wasn't forced into anything like that when I was a kid.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great Show! Horrible Parents.
cassieo5 May 2004
There is just so much to say about this show. I honestly hope that the parents represented are *small* percentage of actual stage parents. All of them say to the cameras that this is their child/family's dream and it's what they want but their children's actions are the complete opposite. They seem to be projecting some maturity onto their kids that they do not have. Here's my review of each one:

Jordan Barron: Incredibly spoiled, her mom lets her treat her horribly. This is possibly age-appropriate as she is only 14 but still, it's hard to watch. I don't know enough about her talent to say whether or not she's got a shot, but her personality is bad, especially around her mother. Is mom waiting for her kid to strike it rich or something? Geez! Move back with your husband, if he's still around.

Shane Klingensmith: He's a cute kid but you can tell that he is doing a lot of this to please his mom. Can she really tell the difference between him wanting it for real or just to make her happy? Also, when she freaks out about something, so does Shane. He gets sick, gets upset, is that really neccesary?

Jordan Mosley: Her relationship with her mom seemed the most healthy. There is a lot of love an affection between the two of them, hopefully it is not just because work seems to be going well.

The Nutters: The MOST messed up family. They all moved from a nice home in Vermont to a 2 bedroom apartment in New York to act, the dad's dream. No one else's though. I love how the dad made his sacrifices in Vermont and now it's his turn. Right, because his dream is affecting the whole family. Can't he tell they all don't want to be there? They can say that it's fun, but them not doing well in school or 'forgetting' important things is them saying they don't like it. Duncan is pretty selfish to want the sacrifices from his family but isn't willing to do the same, yeah he already gave a lot up. Is it anywhere near what his wife and kids are now? Not even close. His kids are going to have issues with this for a long time. His wife is a saint but also allowing her children to be miserable. She needs to put them first just a little bit.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Pretty sleazy, sis
cococox15 June 2004
I read where the producers of this show originally told the families that they were doing a show called, "Bravo Kids", and that they would focus on the kids and treat the families with respect. Now the families are all p***ed off because they have portrayed them so badly.

I know that these parents can act pretty badly, push their children too hard, and just generally act like a bunch of jerks, but it still raises the question of whether it is right to dupe people in top something they are not aware of - especially something that they will be judged the rest of their lives for by millions of people.

I know that some people will say that they never would have gotten access to the families if they had told the truth, but is the story really that important? It is not like it is some 60 minutes news investigation or something. And any of you who think that Bravo or the producers of this show had any higher calling other than getting ratings or looking at "these freaks" are deluding yourselves.

In the end, the way everyone on these boards and elsewhere rags on these kids lack of ability surely is more harmful to their self-image than their parents forcing them into the spotlight. Right?

It reminds me of the way they used to treat Chelsea Clinton during her most awkward stage.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Not good. Shame on you
julio-399 June 2004
This show is kind of interesting, but goes for the cheap thrills rather than providing any real insights. It is like a tabloid version of a documentary.

If you want to see a really good film on the same subject (and probably the very thing that Bravo ripped off for this totally unoriginal idea), watch Living Dolls, a documentary that aired on HBO a few years ago. That was a real look at the lives of these young beauty contestants, not just a cheap rip-off like this.

I understand the need to capitalize on the "reality" show trend, and I think that has its place, but I wish that they would stick to eating bugs and dating shows rather than taking interesting subjects that should be reserved for real films and stretching the premise to fit into a TV show format.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Just bad
jimnobile5 June 2004
Usually any reality show or documentary that shows you an inside view of some part of the culture is at least interesting. Mix in a little of the entertainment business and you have a sure winner, right?

Wrong. This show is just garbage. Although some of the kids are genuinely talented, that is really beside the point. This show fails to provide any insights into why these people act like this, and what effect it has on the children.

It also looks very cheap, more like home movies than a TV show. I would give this a lower rating, but it is a good subject. I don't know how they managed to mangle it up.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Yikes!
Rattrap00722 April 2004
Yikes where to even begin.

Basically it follows 5 sets of parents trying to get their kids into showbiz.. Some are kinda delusional.

The families are:

A single mom putting her 4 year old daughter into beauty pagents.

A single mother putting her 8 year old into acting. The girl was apparently on That's So Raven two times... maybe more.

A mother trying to get her 13 year old son into the music biz. He competes in regional competitions.

A mother trying to get her 13 year old daughter into acting while also raising another 7 year old duaghter.

And a father who is trying to get his 7 kids (forget just how many) ranging from 7 to about 16 or so into acting.

God i feel bad for some of these kids.

First off the mother of the four year old, Emily Tye, says she is tired of her daughter being reffered to as a Jon Benet. She says the daughter loves doing this. Well the little girl was crying and didn't want to go up on stage. The mother kinda consoles the girl into getting up there. Mom says she always crys a bit before getting up there but once she is up there she is all smiles. Helllloooo. Your kid is doing it to make you happy. She is miserable doing this. Plain to see mom. Yeesh.

The Second one the 8 year old, Jordan Mosley-Stephens, i guess has some talent to be on a tv show twice so that is something. The little girl seemed to enjoy it a bit so i'm not bothered by it.

Then the lady with the boy Shane. Where to start. Cute kid, not a great singing talent. Plus there is only so many times you can watch him practice singing "Hot Hot Hot" before they even go to the competition. Practices dancing (forget the style) with little sis while mom instructs. The kid got bad news. His back up singing girls had to cancel before a competition so he is solo. A 13 year old amature has back up singers? Yeesh. Well the kid competed. The top ten (of twenty) go on... he doesn't make the cut. Not even good enough with a 50/50 shot. I fewlt bad for the kid when he didn't make it he looked to be near tears. He went over to mom and laid his face into her sholder. Not cut out for music. The kid is a good looking young man. He should try out for advertisements for kids clothes. I could see his smiling face advertising teens clothes in a Target ad... not as a singing sensation.

The 13 year old, Jordan Barron, is a bit of a... well it isn't a nice term. Foul additude. Hated the lunch mother packed her for school, complained that the papers he mother printed out were out of order. Wasn't really practicing her monologe. She had a really negative additude.

Now for my fav one. This is so sad it is funny. Duncan Nutter quits his job in Pennsylvania as an accountant and moves his family of i believe 7 kids from a nice big house to a TWO BEDROOM apartment in NYC to try and get his kids into acting. He even tries acting himself... yet he has no talent. And he is the kids acting coach. I think what one of the audition judges summed it up real well when she said somethign to the effect of "It is sad when you have an audition with a kid who doesn't have a lot of talent, yet it is even sadder when they have an acting coach who has no talent" or something like that. The guy was awful and thought he was good.

Over all it is a sad look into the world of parents who believe their little one is super talented needs all this work forced apon them to make them a star. Here is a tip for the parents on the allspark. You may think your kid is the most talented youth around, but that doesn't make it 100% true. Let your kid be a kid and have a normal life without having to memorize a song or script. It could screw up your kids big time..

The second one just reconfirmed some beliefs.

Duncan Nutter is a moron. He has a possible deal in the works to have a show centered around his family. Well at the lunch to go over a possible contract he criticizes the grammer and mispellings and somewhat berates the exec. Smooth move man.

Mrs. Tye is a sore loser that when her daughter doesn't think the judges are qualified at all and the other family doesn't deserve to win.

Jordan Barron turns 14 and is still nasty additude. She get's a card from her father (who mom is divorced from) and later tells the camera that she hopes when she makes it big that he comes asking for money just so she can tell him no.. Yeesh.

Very interesting show to say the least..
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Dead End!
caspian197818 June 2004
It has finally happened! We are currently living through the reality television revolution. The majority of programming on television has become so bad that you can almost not tell the difference between American and Japaneses television. Average everyday Americans are lining up to make a fool of themselves on national television in order to win a cookie. Since the arrival of Survivor, millions of people are keeping their fingers crossed that they will one day get the chance to be in front of a giant audience. Soon, I pray, this will not be the case. With shows lie Showbiz Moms & Dads, how does one think that the fame they receive from these shows are actually positive?

With an exception to maybe 1% of all people who appear on reality game shows, who actually goes on to make an honest and professional career in what they do? I stayed up all night to watch the marathon of this mini series. By early morning the next day, I wanted to puke. I couldn't believe that the media has stumped so low to produce something like this. Still, the show is very entertaining even though you hate most of the people that appear on the program.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A sick and disturbing reality for many kids.
nessaland23 April 2004
First, I'd like to take a moment to thank my own parents for not forcing me into anything I didn't want to do when I was young. Sure, I took ballet and tap (for awhile), but I did it because I wanted to. When I didn't want to anymore, I wasn't forced to continue. Luckily for me I was allowed to be a kid when I was a kid.

Sadly, that is not the reality for the kids on this, yet another show in the reality genre, "Showbiz Moms and Dads". The only way I can describe this show is "car wreck": It's sickening but you're so intrigued, you cannot help but look. Children as young as 1 and 2 years-old are pushed to be the best in show biz- commercials, pageants, TV shows and films, you name it. And very often the kids have no interest in what they are doing. But the parents are driven by some force here, probably a craving for success they never had and know they will never achieve. But one thing is certain: The parents are selfish and give little thought to how the pressure is affecting their children. This may or may not include the children who participate in this because they want to. I don't know about anyone else, but I as a temporary viewer of this show feel sympathy that these kids won't have childhoods. It's bad enough that they grow up too fast as it is. I can only hope that what happens to them now won't lead to serious repercussions in the teen and adult years, although it probably will.

After watching the show twice, I don't think I'll be tuning it again. It's just too sickening to watch.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
ummm...
Ashlonious4 May 2004
I watch the show on a regular basis because I find it entertaining that the parents are trying SO hard that eventually they think their kids have talent.

The little girl, Jordan, she is talented. I think she will be somewhere in the next couple years.

The Singer, Shane whatever...he has no talent. And his mom as convinced him he has talent so much that he thinks he does.

The beauty pagaent girl is very, very cute. She has won a lot of pagaents, many awards. Everything. But her mom pushes her so much. So much she doesn't even want to do it even though she is good at it.

I kind of like the 14 year old Jordan. I don't think she has the most talent in the world, but she doesn't practice or anything.

The Nutters - I won't even go there. A guy lives in a nice house to a small house with his wife and 7 kids to pursue their acting careers. What a moron.

...overall, most of the kids don't have much talent. I hope the beauty pageant girl and Jordan(the 8 yr old one) make it somewhere. But the rest...I hope they don't keep doing this acting routine until they are all 30 and have no chance at a real career.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed