The Lie (TV Movie 1954) Poster

(1954 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A complex web with an amazingly simple solution
melvelvit-17 October 2006
Warning: Spoilers
THE LIE, a 1954 Vitapix teledrama from "The Golden Age Of Television" was filmed on location at Bavaria Kunst Studios. The short running time, set-bound atmosphere and nightworld milieu give it a "noir-like" ambiance while the melodramatic scenario, with it's dark look at the tangled web of deception, seems ripped right out of a pulp fiction magazine.

Diamond importer John Hammond goes to the circus one night with his girlfriend Marlene, her brother Philip and Philip's fiancée, Margot. The show's star attraction, trapeze artist "The Great Wilheim", knows Marlene and invites everyone back to his dressing room where he organizes an impromptu "men only" bachelor party for Philip. No one notices the sinister man following them as they say goodnight to the ladies and go out on the town. Wilheim and Phil eventually drop a very drunk Hammond off at his apartment and he awakes in the morning to find the police standing over him. The man who shadowed them the night before lies dead on his living room floor, shot with Hammond's revolver. During the trial, Wilhiem and Philip both lie on the witness stand and send Hammond to prison for seven years. Marlene never visits once but Phil's one-time fiancée Margot does and through her efforts Hammond's released after three years. Although his cell-mate advises him to forget the past and he's cautioned by the warden not to seek revenge, Hammond must find out why he was set up. He tracks down those responsible and discovers the twisted truth behind "the lie". The tale ends with the one who set the lies in deadly motion finally brought to justice.

Lee Bowman, the B-movie Zachary Scott (as John Hammond), and 1940's Universal Studio pin-up girl Ramsay Ames (as Marlene) help give THE LIE the feel of a big screen Poverty Row second feature. It's also a little more ambitious than most 1950's teledramas and, with a little more time and effort, could have been a tightly plotted thriller with a few surprises for those familiar with the conventions of the noir genre. The fact Hammond is a diamond importer and is licensed to carry a gun for protection leads the viewer to assume the plot may hinge on theft, deceit and greed. Hammond's boozy recollection of the stranger he (supposedly) killed standing over him saying something about "staying away from her" could peg Marlene as the de rigeur femme fatale. The twist comes when these red herrings only serve to mask the fact the puzzle's solution is keyed around a stalker with a sexual obsession. Ramsay Ames, as the beautiful but selfish Marlene, is a knock-out as the chain-smoking nightclub canary. Smartly coiffed in a Gina Lollobrigida-style Italian poodle cut and fashionably garbed in 1950's get-ups while waving her long cigarette-holder like a wand, the slinky songstress even purrs a blusey torch song at the club where she works. Ames' confidently laid-back acting "style" fits a character who never considers anyone or anything other than herself and good girl with a heart Margot (blonde Eva Probst) provides nice contrast to the callous raven-haired charmer. The reed-slim and pencil-moustached Lee Bowman is effective as John Hammond, a trench-coated average Joe who's life inexplicably spins out of control overnight. Other staples of film noir include the beefy blond acrobat Wilheim (Harald Maresh) going from Lothario to nasty very quickly once he starts to slap Marlene and her brother Philip (Joachim Brennecke) around and the brief but pivotal role of fedora-wearing "Franz the stalker" as portrayed by creepy Laird Cregar look-alike Reinhard Kolldehoff. A fair amount of suspense is generated when a frightened Wilhiem, who always performs sans net, recognizes Hammond in the crowd just before he begins his circus act. He nervously wipes his sweaty brow and palms before taking to the trapeze and falling to his death. THE LIE's satisfying final scene has the villianess casually raising a cigarette to be lit as police handcuffs appear from nowhere to snap around her wrist.

Although it could have delivered more, this semi-suspenseful TV play from 1954 has the welcome presence of Hollywood B-Movie regulars Ramsay Ames and Lee Bowman along with a half-way decent plot-line. Even if only as an early TV curio, THE LIE is definitely worth a look.

Trivia: Harald Maresch was once known as Harald Raymond and was the man actress Lupe Velez committed suicide for in 1944.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Atmospheric Little Murder Mystery
zardoz-137 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
"The Scarlet Pimpernel" director Harold Young's "The Lie" qualifies as a gritty, atmospheric, little murder-mystery. A man awakens the morning after a drunken bender, and he finds the police staring at him and a body strewn on his floor. Worse, a gun lays near the body, and the gun belongs to our wrongly accused hero. John Arthur Hamilton (Lee Bowman of "Bataan") is in a pickle of a predicament. Not only does he remember nothing about the night before, but he also doesn't recognize the corpse. One thing that he does remember is that his two friends, Wilhelm (Harald Maresch) and Phillip (Joachim Brennecke), brought him back to his apartment and then left. Predictably, the police arrest Hamilton. A diamond importer, Hamilton explains at his trial that he has a license to carry his gun. He insists that he didn't know, Franz Ritter (Reinhard Kolldehoff of "Shout at the Devil"), but his defense isn't airtight enough. The judges sentences him to seven years behind bars. You'll never be able to figure out who framed our protagonist until the last scene. The villains get what is coming to them, especially the mastermind. Clocking in at a little over an hour in length, this made-in-Germany, black & white, television show is concisely written and performed. The inmate with whom Hamilton shares a cell has some interesting dialogue about the people inside prison and those outside. "The Lie" is quite tolerable, despite its low-budget, and the cast is solid.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Why Did They Lie?
boblipton30 March 2024
Lee Bowman is in the diamond trade in Germany. One night after a night roistering with his friends, they drop him off in his apartment. When he wakes, there's a dead man he doesn't recognize, killed with Bowman's gun. No one knows who he is, or what connection he has with Bowman, but when his friends say on the witness stand that they put Bowman in a cab back to his apartment, he's found guilty of murder and sentenced to seven years in prison. After he gets out, he tries to find out who did it.

It's a very slight story, with some decent performances and some interesting off-kilter camerawork by Erich Claunigk. Shot on location, it has some interesting shots of the seedier parts of Geiselgasteig in Bavaria, but those of the limits of its excellence.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
You can see the solution a mile away
bkoganbing6 July 2014
Lee Bowman was one of those many B picture players who turned to television when work became scarce on the big screen. In the case of The Lie this was a made for TV feature shot in Germany. I guess a trip to Germany was worth the price of appearing in The Lie.

It's a noir film and on the dull side. Lee is a diamond importer who has a gun and carry permit. One night after a little celebration Bowman passes out and wakes up with a dead body on his apartment floor.

Of course he's charged with murder and does 3 years though he hasn't got the foggiest idea who the dead man was even. Worse than that three friends including Ramsay Ames the only other American in the cast swear they weren't even with him that night and they took him home.

As any of these films would have it Bowman has to find out the truth and clear his name and maybe check to see if he's not going balmy.

You can see the solution a mile away on this one.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The Unusually Young Cast
daoldiges26 April 2024
The Lie grabbed my attention with its straightforward, two word title. The cast for the most part gave fine performances but they were also a little off in that several of the main characters seemed too old for their specific roles. Not sure why that is but it served to further weaken an already very weak story. Too much of this relatively short film was devoted to circus acts and a lengthy nightclub performance scene. It seems the circus was a popular setting for many films of this era, although this specific circus was particularly tepid. Despite a couple watchable elements, The Lie just doesn't deliver a solid return on the time investment.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed