IMDb user comments for
Knallhart (2006) Plus avec IMDbPro »

Filtre:

Meilleur Chronologique prolific Ils ont aimé Ils ont détesté Cacher les spoilers:

Index

7 commentaires au total

---

38 utilisateurs sur 43 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile :
Gripping, 10 septembre 2006

Auteur : Tony de Sydney

This film really got to me, probably because it was almost perfectly realistic. The characters are brilliantly drawn - no simplistic goodies or baddies. The setting, in the not-so-wealthy suburbs of Berlin, is very believable.

Full marks for the acting and directing. There are some gutwrenching scenes in this film. I won't go into the details because I don't want to spoil a thing, but both physical and emotional violence are portrayed with an alarming conviction. I wish more film makers could achieve this instead of resorting to comic book fights or glossing over the brutal reality.

I sincerely hope that this film is released internationally, and that it escapes the censors' scissors. It would be a shame if only German-speaking audiences could see it.

---

15 utilisateurs sur 18 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile :
Outstanding piece of film, 11 octobre 2006

Auteur : Ilina de Chicago

*** Ce commentaire peut contenir des spoilers ***

I caught Knallhart at the 2006 Chicago International Film Festival, where it drew massive applause as the credits rolled.

Intense, realistic coming-of-age story set in the poor, predominantly Turkish suburb Neukoeln in Berlin. David Kross is spot-on as precocious, soft-spoken, world-weary 15 year old Michael, struggling to survive in the new world he's been thrust into after his mother's wealthy boyfriend shoves them out on the street. He seems unfazed through his constant violent run-ins with a local gang, as well as increasingly dodgy messenger assignments he gets through a friendship with the local drug lord, holding his stoic gaze until the escalating events eventually break him, and yet show his true strength and character.

The movie is extremely gripping, gritty, and real; the camera is intimate with its characters, letting the audience marinate in the heaviness of a situation.

The Soundtrack is notably powerful, weighty, and fitting, as is often with quality German films (Head On, Run Lola Run, Princess and the Warrior). Definitely recommended.

---

13 utilisateurs sur 15 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile :
Simple but strong, 4 avril 2007

Auteur : Pascal Zinken (LazySod) de Maastricht, The Netherlands

When a young mother and her 15 year old son have to move from the posh end of town to the run down end of town things aren't going to get better anytime soon. Used to living on the up-side getting used to the down-side is a little hard after all. With mom not being the absolute best role model available it is clear that the son can't be that either. And so the story rolls.

Knallhart, also known as Tough Enough, is thus a drama film and a fairly good one at that. The realism factor is very high and it is hard not to feel a certain amount of pity for the characters as they evolve through the film. Musical background is fitting for a modern film and feels right, acting isn't half bad. Overall an enjoyable watch, if a little depressing to see yet another one bite the dust.

8 out of 10 broken futures

---

1 utilisateurs sur 1 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile :
Knallhart, 19 août 2007

Auteur : anton_hartl de Ried im Innkreis, Autriche

*** Ce commentaire peut contenir des spoilers ***

The rising numbers of violent acts amongst teenagers are a big problem today. Especially young people should have the chance to develop their own identity, without having to deal with threats from fellow students or violence in their family. "Knallhart", a movie by director Detlev Buck and screenwriters Gregor Tessnow and Zoran Drvenkar, is good, because it is very realistic. We see that there is not much chance, that one doesn't get a victim or criminal in the place they are growing up. Our main character Michael has to decide whether he wants to stay a victim the rest of his days or if he wants to do something against it. Parts of today's youth just feel that there is no prospect for the future. Rising Unemployment and the gap between rich and poor getting bigger and bigger may be reasons for that. David Kross does an excellent job in playing Michael, but what makes "Knallhart" a really great movie, is that also all characters aside our hero have their moments. Everyone has a family, a past, problems that they are dealing with.

---

3 utilisateurs sur 5 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile :
Unoriginal but good addition to troubled teenager film, 3 octobre 2007

Auteur : trpuk1968 de Royaume-Uni

Interesting how one person read this film as having a subtext to do with fear of immigration and other races. I found this quite harrowing to watch, it pressed buttons for me, leaving me quite disturbed and depressed afterwards. I d recommend it to anyone doing work with kids around bullying. The central character is faced with some hard choices. After watching this, I was left wondering what exactly I might do, given the same set of circumstances. There's a frenetic, techno charged turbo driven soundtrack, rapid editing and wonky camera angles, but this is used skilfully. There's two scenes of incredible tension where the filmmaker slows down, the camera becomes still which brings emphasis to bear on the events. All in this is competently executed and while not up there with Los Olvidados or 400 Blows is nonethless well worth a look.

---

2 utilisateurs sur 9 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile :
We've seen better, 16 juin 2008

Auteur : Ryu_Darkwood de Pays-Bas

I expected another Gegen die Wand and I got...well, this! It's the kind of story we've seen countless times before, and in many cases better executed. This movie just doesn't add up to other movies about troubled kids going on the wrong path in life. Recent pearls like La Haine or Cidade de Deus are so much better.

The problem I had with this story is that we can predict from the very beginning where it is going to lead us. From the moment we see the good looking, almost angelic kid walking into a police station with blood on his shoes, we know that he'll turn the wrong way by meeting the wrong people. And that's exactly what happens. It doesn't lead us - the viewer - on any new grounds regarding the subject of youth delinquency. The small subplot concerning the mother is strong, but I really felt that they could've heighten it to a higher level. In the end it does deliver as a heart wrenching thriller rather than the society comment it wants to be. The Germans know how to make good cinema, this doesn't belong in there.

---

3 utilisateurs sur 22 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile :
London to Brighton anyone??, 25 décembre 2007

Auteur : dschmeding de Allemagne

Knallhart is in many points a typical German movie to me. The premise of a troubled teenager moving to a new flat in a low class Berlin environment and dealing with violence, drugs and apathy is nothing new. The movie tries to portrait the depressing surrounding in long pictures of the main actor walking through the city in washed out colors. The surrounding and the characters to me seem typically German and unbelievable ... overacted or over-scripted (the mobile phone beating videos were implemented heavy to meet with modern day German news headlines as a very cheap catch). Acting wise the movie was pulled down by the incredibly untalented Jenny Elvers in the role of the lead actors mother. Several other characters are badly acted like the German dealer in the cellar or the Austrian cocaine dealer (this scene is a perfect example for overdoing things by cutting to the baby every 10 seconds.... yeah, its depressing but how come non-German movies like "Ex Drummer" or "London to Brighton" manage to be gripping and getting the message across with far less effort??). Oh and talking about "London to Brighton".... like "KNallhart" its a 2006 movie but I really wonder about the strong similarities. The setting, the telling of the story by beginning at the end and then resolving it, the open ending, the environment and long city shots, the idea of the the main actor being forced to murder a person he hates although its not in his nature... can all this be coincidence??

However the movies are classes apart.... the use of music was really bad in Knallhart and made it hard to feel for the main actor or the plot because it hardly ever transported the visual emotion. It rather sounded like the were selling a modern soundtrack or something. I think a 7.5 average rating is definitely too much for a movie with this many flaws. Even the editing was pretty weak at times... so do yourself a favor and watch "London to Brighton" or "Ex Drummer" if you want a movie gritty and getting you emotionally involved with great cinematography in a depressing underclass-environment rather than this pretentious German effort.

---

---

Ajouter un autre commentaire

---

Liens liés

Plot summary	Notes	Récompenses
Revues externes	Site Officiel	Plot keywords
Principaux Détails	Your user comments	Your vote history