E=mc² (2005) (TV)

Note Générale:

7,9/10   

Réalisateur:

Gary Johnstone

Scénaristes:

David Bodanis (book)
Gary Johnstone (writer)

Date de sortie:

11 octobre 2005 (USA)

Genre:

Biographie | Drame | Histoire

Intrigue:

The story of the discovery and realization of the famous equation e=mc² by Albert Einstein. The program...

Plot Keywords:

Nuclear Physics | Mathematics | Public Television | Science | Educational

Avis des utilisateurs:

Longest 2 hours about nothing

Ensemble

Andrew Callaway	...	Maupertuis
Andy Crabbe	...	Habicht
Daniel D'Alessandro	...	Algarotti
Brendan Fleming	...	Hermann Einstein
Gregory Fox-Murphy	...	Brande
Ty Glaser	...	Marie Anne Lavoisier
Philip Herbert	...	Count de Amerval
Chris Jenkinson	...	Dr. Haller
Wolf Kahler	...	Horlein
George Layton	...	Emilie's Father
Anton Lesser	...	Voltaire
Alex Macqueen	...	Chater
Aidan McArdle	...	Einstein
Richard Mulholland	...	Emilie's Tutor
Stephen Noonan	...	Marat

Autre(s) titre(s):

E=mc² - Einsteins große Idee (Germany)

Durée:

120 min

Pays:

USA | France | Allemagne | UK

Langue:

Anglais

Couleur:

Couleur

Son:

Stereo

Lieux de tournage:

England, UK

Société:

Channel 4 Television Corporation

Connexions:

figurer "Nova: Einstein's Big Idea (#33.3)" (2005)

Longest 2 hours about nothing

Maybe it had more substance to someone not educated in science, someone whose never heard of basic physics, or someone from America, but this was 6 minutes of material diluted into 2 hours of endless synthetic dialog, narration, and wide shots of grass. The 2 hour length seems only to boost publicity and could have easily been condensed in to NOVA's normal 60 minute length.

The first 90 minutes are about the unknown scientists behind early physics. There is no mention of Newton, Gallileo, DaVinci, like you expect from these stories. Instead its all about unknown scientists behind things like uranium chemistry. The story is most useful not as a means of learning about Einstein but learning about how the business of science works. A lot of unknown scientists did a lot of hard work only to get wiped out of the history books by historical events and each tiny piece of modern physics represents the entire life work of most of these scientists.

The only reason this movie is staying on the hard drive is because it pays a lot of attention to the heroines behind E=mc2. Heroines who today would be depending on men to win the bread while they drove their kids to soccer games in their husband's SUVs, were making huge discoveries in the 18th and 19th centuries. A good line is when Einstein tells his wife the connection between time and light. She replies, "I'll check your math". Pretty good stuff.

The last 30 minutes switch to autopilot, recounting how E=MC2 was used and is used today. It seemed to overemphasize an insignificant branch of research in USA and neglect the truly mind blowing research being done in CERN.