Linda & Ali: Two Worlds Within Four Walls (2005) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Keeping up appearances
ville-55 July 2006
This is a documentary about Ali and Linda who have been married for about 15 years and have seven kids ranging from infant to late teens. The angle in the documentary is that Ali is a Qatari and Linda is/was a US citizen.

Linda has adapted to the foreign culture pretty well and turned from Christianity to Islam before their marriage and accepts almost all the restriction the Qatar society puts on her: what she must (not) wear and how she spends her time outside home, which seems to be just watching TV with her sister-in-law and all the ordinary housewife things.

Ali however hasn't strayed from the Qatar way of life: he loves his family but seems to spend more time with his friends, jogging or business trips and the kids are left completely on Linda's burden. They have even made an arrangement where Ali promises to spend every other evening with his family yet he slips from that very often.

The kids are brought up as bi-lingual Qataris who are quite aware of their mother's origin but are brought up in an Islamic fashion. The teenage son doesn't feel it's right for his little sisters to attend gymnastics classes because of the dress code. 'A woman who would walk down the street not wearing burka would be considered crazy'. Whether he's been taught this way or not is unclear as later in the doc we can see his father at a bar ogling at a lightly clothed young woman and praising the view - and immediately saying that it's great that the young woman is acting as she does, and saying that it would be strictly out of the question if his family members would act that way. Double standards anyone? That moment made me also think how great beaches Qatar must have yet no-one really can use them! There's a hint of sadness in Linda throughout the film. She feels somewhat under-appreciated by Ali and uses instant messaging daily with her mother through the internet. As she doesn't speak Arabian her children have a special bond with their father and it seemed to me that she feels herself a little bit of an outsider. For example, she converses with her oldest daughter - who's about to turn 18 - how her daughter would feel about arranged marriage with a complete stranger and Linda, who doesn't approve such things, is stymied about her daughter's reaction as she doesn't oppose the idea, stoically saying "that's how it is." It made me feel she didn't really know her daughter that well.

And when her mother gets sick Linda breaks down in front of the camera, her mother being probably the only person who she can talk about with an open heart. She's also a bit fixated about how her life was back in the states and longs back to her home country - evident from viewing old photos and in the end deciding to go see her mother.

The documentary style is quite intrusive yet the subjects seem to be quite at ease with it as the camera records several close family moments between all the members, and everyone except the older girls have their moments to let out their thoughts.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
A documentary or just some family "Real World" situation?
dftwilight28 March 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Linda & Ali is a documentary that could have done something more. It's a quaint piece about two people from two different worlds that got married, had children, have arguments and cultural differences, and...wait...that's just life isn't it? No matter where you're from.

Yes, we as the audience, are quite aware 10 minutes in that Linda is still hung up over moving to Qatar from America. We are quite aware that there are MAJOR cultural differences between the two countries as well which we are brow beat with at every moment.

And that's about it. Linda & Ali could have just as easily been a 30 minute documentary with just as much substance. It really doesn't go anywhere and the shots of their, shall we say more than modest lifestyle (read as: they have their own maid and luxurious home), fails to impress or elicit any sort of pity for her situation. If anything, I felt for Ali.

Throughout the documentary Linda consistently nags, whines, and complains. Her presence overwhelms all around her to where no one else can get a word in edge wise. She is loud and rude as she interrupts people (to include her husband and children) when they try to speak as she tries to emphasize how hard her life has been. After watching her, all I could think of was, "Wow, I know there are plenty of reasons the world hates Americans, hopefully they don't see this and add another to the list." I never once pitied her situation. This was a life she willingly chose and knew all too well what she was getting into. If she was being physically or mentally beaten, then yes, I could understand some desperation to escape. But Ali, despite his flaws, seems like a kind person just trying to cope. Who can blame the man for wanting to escape from Linda's harpy-like rants as often as he can?

Another complaint is that at times I had no idea who anyone was, why there was a celebration, who visitors were, etc... Scenes jumped from interviews, to various events that to anyone looking from an outside perspective (such as myself) could not put into any context at all. Linda had a group of obviously non-Muslim women come into her home as she explained why she converted to Islam, blah blah blah. Who were the women?? Where did they come from? Why were they there?? There is a celebration that I finally caught on that it was for a man's coming nuptials. How come some men were kissing or pretending to kiss each other? I could have sworn I saw "Eskimo kisses" as well. These are alien concepts to an outsider and some type of explanation, no matter how minute, would have been better than nothing.

This is a very disjointed documentary. If you have some knowledge of Middle-Eastern culture then I'm sure you will have no problem following the plights and adventures of Linda & Ali. For the rest of us though, we can only sit back, scratch our heads, and wonder when the next episode of "The Office" will air.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed