Little Joe is on a jury that is hearing a case that involves murder. From all the testimony it appears that Irishman Terrence O'Toole has murdered Fred Demmer during a robbery. Joe has a problem convicting the man since he will be sending O'Toole to the gallows. But he goes along with the others and a guilty verdict is reached by the jury.
Afterwards, Joe feel bad about his decision and starts looking for someone else that may have wanted O'Toole to hang. A very easy person is the dead man son, Jeb Demmer. He has been gambling since the trial and Joe has a problem about where all the money is coming. Joe sees Jeb throw away an item that turns out to be his dead father's wallet. Now Joe believes that O'Toole is innocent.
Sounds like a regular type western until we find out that the dead man's wife, Molly, use to know O'Toole in Ireland. We learn that they had a very close relationship many years ago. Now it is not as clear as we first thought.
A very different and interesting end to the story. Without the ending this would have been a average show that has been played out in many other shows. But hold-on and watch the ending where most stories never seem to venture. Good watch.