Caroline's apartment is broken into and her suspicion falls on Annie's new boyfriend, who has just been released from prison. Annie is upset at Caroline but they have to find out who is correct.
Annie is very excited about her new boyfriend Stephen, even getting a tattoo with him. They all have dinner together when he admits he was in prison. That night, whilst Caroline is asleep, her apartment is broken into. Caroline's suspicions are that Stephen sneaked in during the night from Annie's apartment but Annie is upset with Caroline for thinking this way. They set a trap to find out.—jem