The episode benefits from at atmospheric setting, a creepy "antique", and some focus on Ryan's backstory. Specifically, the mention of his dead brother Jimmy, which will come into more play at the premiere of season 3.
The bad things are Micki reduced to a damsel in distress, the obvious telegraphing of the villain, and the over-reliance on the scarecrow. When the two cousins can restrain it, it doesn't come across as much of a threat.
The episode also moves the cousins out into the countryside. Which comes across more as a concept (killer scarecrow) looking for a place. Rather than a natural concept of an antique popping up. Granted, you'd have to put a scarecrow in a farm setting: it's not like it could just pop up in "the city". The scarecrow doesn't make sense as an antique, which is why one gets the impression that Marc Scott Zicree and Larry B. Williams came up with the idea and tried to shoehorn it in.
The fact that there's no backstory tends to support that. Who bought the antique from Lewis? How did it get to the town of Riverdale? And so on. Instead, the cousins (sans Jack) just shows up looking for the scarecrow.
I'm not sure if Zicree and Williams are taking a mickey on the Friday the 13th movies. The scarecrow is as close to an unstoppable blade-wielding killer that can appear wherever it wants, as the series ever got to its supposed source material. However, this tends to make the scarecrow look incompetent by comparison. It takes forever to even try and kill Micki, who avoids it with ease. The use of the raincoat, both by the killer (shades of Mama Voorhees!) and the red herring of the sheriff having a raincoat that throws Micki off the scent, is also reminiscent of the movie.
The idea of the scarecrow targeting its victim by photo is clever, as is how the killer eventually falls victim to her own machinations. Like "Dr. Jack" (which was also authored by Zicree), there's some relatively clever stuff going on here. The photo-target concept is never explained: it's just tossed in as a "hoist on one's own petard" bit.
Patricia Phillips makes a decent killer. She's no Ray Walston, but she's not entirely a leering maniac, either. The bits like her calmly knitting while Micki screams, then her picking up a pair of scissors to deal with Ryan & Company, is good. The end, where she does turn into a scissors-wielding maniac, isn't so good. The bit where she tries to seduce Charlie is just weird.
I don't get the fascination with the missing heads. Who cares where they went? Why is it such a big point of drama, that Micki comments on it to Ryan as they leave town? Is there some significance to the heads that I'm missing?
It seems like there are some loose ends, too. What happens to Jordy at the end? And who does Sheriff Comins think killed Marge? She's decapitated, and Ryan's fingerprints are on the scythe. Does he know about the cursed scarecrow now, or shouldn't Ryan be in jail as a killer?
Overall, "Scarecrow" is an episode that doesn't bear a lot of scrutiny. But then again, most episodes of the series don't. It's got atmosphere in spades, some good portrayals, and a decent concept.
But that's just my opinion, I could be wrong. What do you think?
1 out of 1 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink