"Sherlock Holmes" The Case of the Shy Ballerina (TV Episode 1954) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Don't shy away from viewing
hte-trasme11 November 2009
I found this to be a good episode of the 1954-55 "Sherlock Holmes" series with Ronald Howard, and when the series is good it's a very entertaining blend of a solid mystery, enjoyably wacky elements, and humorous but satisfying character moments in a half an hour. One of its strengths is that despite its short running time it can still take the time to luxuriate in well-written character scenes between Holmes and Watson in almost every episode. Here they bicker good-naturedly over Holmes' music and Watson's reading in a way that's fun, builds these versions of Holmes and Watson as believable characters (who Ronald Howard and H. Marion Crawford suit very well) and relates to the main story of the episode.

The mystery grows out of Watson accidentally taking the wrong coat and hat, then consequently getting implicated in the murder of a amateur composer. It's a very solid mystery story this week which holds up while played equally for laughs. The solution depends mainly on something Holmes observed but we should have, though it also depends partially on graphology, which is a bit less satisfying, though it realistic that the Victorian Holmes should have believed in it. Martine Alexis and Eugene Deckers play a pair of wild, stereotyped, implausibly accented, way over the top, and undeniably fun-to-watch "mad Russians," so consider yourself warned on that score. Suffice it to say that Ms Alexis' performance makes it so that the "shy" ballerina of the title is nowhere to be seen. We close with Holmes promising to devote more time to the study of women. All-in-all a fun half-hour.
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Watch Your Coat
Hitchcoc24 September 2008
Watson loses his coat and hat. A man at his club has inadvertently switched his with Watson. A cryptic note is in the pocket. The man is murdered shortly thereafter and the boys become involved in the solving of the crime. The principles are a noble woman, a Russian ballerina, and a hammy artist. Everything is so silly that it's hard to take the episode very seriously. This is about passion, but it's hard to believe that this knucklehead would attract the affection of the noblewoman. Watson, for a while, is accused by LeStrade of being the murderer because his derby was found at the scene. A pretty lame effort to frame him considering Holmes was there when Watson tried on the hat. It was too small. Say, I wonder if there aren't some similarities between this and the O. J. Simpson trial. If the hat don't fit; you must acquit.
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
The Case of the Shy Ballerina
Prismark1017 June 2021
Dr Watson took the wrong coat from his club.

I'm surprised he didn't notice it the time as it was rather tight.

When the rightful owner comes by to swap it. He ends up taking Dr Watson's hat by mistake as he is leaving.

Later the man is found dead. The hat takes Lestrade to see Dr Watson.

Holmes and Watson had come across a note in his pocket when they discovered it was someone else's coat.

When Holmes and Watson had earlier went down to his house to get the correct hat back. His wife had hired Holmes as her husband was being blackmailed by a Russian ballerina.

This could had been decent minor story which is spoilt by sexist cod psychology. Even for the mid 1950s this is embarrassing.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed