Andy loses the engagement ring he was going to give to his girlfriend Beth, who is a fatalist. He believes he lost it somewhere in the subway station he just exited. Does losing the ring mean, in Beth's terms, that they are not meant to be together? Even though the ring is turned in to lost and found, does the fact that the woman who turned it in does not believe in the institution of marriage mean that they aren't meant to be together? Despite advice from an outside source, only Andy and Beth, based on their shared history, can truly answer whether they should be together, and if Andy should take the advice and "go for it".
—Huggo