Natascha Kampusch - 3096 Tage Gefangenschaft (TV Movie 2010) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Nice study of the effects of education and critical thinking on adversity in life.
skypalace-2534620 May 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Honestly, when she was initially free and in the media, I didn't believe the story she was telling. She insisted that she wasn't a victim, that she had never been raped, and that she was happy to be free and ready to get on with her life. I wondered how that could even be remotely possible, after being starved and forced to live in a bunker for eight years, especially after being snatched as a child, because rape is usually the reason people snatch children, right?

After hearing this, her complete version of events after several years of freedom, I realize that it's wrong of me to assume that I know ALL of the motives of oppressors, or the mindset and reactions of the oppressed. Natascha is a prime example of all that can be gained from levelheaded thinking, a strong will, and tirelessly working to improve oneself, no matter the circumstance.

It's shameful that society makes the recovery of people like this more difficult simply because we're willing to misunderstand reality for the sake of a good story.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A cruel subject - and controversial documentary
Horst_In_Translation13 April 2017
Warning: Spoilers
"Natascha Kampusch - 3096 Tage Gefangenschaft" or "Natascha: The Girl in the Cellar" is a 43-minute documentary from 2010 that focuses as the English-language title already suggests on the horrible crime that happened to Austrian Natascha Kampusch. She managed to escape from her captor's house after roughly 8 years of abuse and humiliation. This is the subject of this documentary and it is basically all about Kampusch herself giving interviews and talking about her life between the age of 10 and 18. It is important to state that most of the violence did not really have a sexual background. It was all about power and Kampusch was kept like a slave during these years.

I can see why people develop a bit of a dislike towards Kampusch. It may come off in a way where she is attention-seeking with the book she wrote and her presence in television and this documentary here for example as if she was trying to make as much money from it as possible. But regardless of what I think, can you blame a woman who had to go through what she did for anything she makes or decides after her martyrdom ends? And who knows maybe she really managed to deal with the events and this is the way that helps her the most in doing so. I don't think anybody can criticize her for what she did. It is a pretty haunting documentary, but there are moments when I felt that I really did not want to know any of the details to be honest. It's okay that the police knows, but does the general public really need to know? I don't think it will help in the prevention of other crimes of a similar nature in the future. But I also think it would be wrong to say Austria has a problem with the Kampusch and Fritzl cases to be honest. It's just a major coincidence I guess. Anyway, as a whole I would not say this pretty short documentary here is a must-see, but it is an interesting and informative watch and gives major insight in one of the cruelest cases of kidnapping of the last century. You sure need a thick skin though to sit through it. The saddest thing however is seeing Kampusch on these old photos from when she was a child and see her now what these years have turned her into. Then again, she can be very lucky to be alive I guess. On a final note, the one was written by Alina Teodorescu and written by Peter Reichard who also worked on the Kampusch movie from a couple years after this one here. I guess this documentary and also the film got a push in terms of attention thanks to the Oscar-winning Brie Larson film "Room". Feel free to check out my review for that one as well. But back to this one here I suggest you check it out.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
no substance
Calicodreamin2 April 2020
Certainly an incredible and harrowing story, but this short documentary detailing Natascha's abduction has no substance. There's no purpose. The people interviewed are relevant and include Natascha herself, but the re-enactments hardly tell the story, and theres no natural flow to the documentary. Could have been done much better.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"I tried to scream, but no voice came out"
evening15 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Here is a fascinating portrait of a self-possessed young woman who won't let another person's evil behavior destroy her.

The 1998 kidnapping of 10-year-old Natascha Kampusch taught her that "no one is infallible," she says in this short documentary. "Any one of us can find themselves in a position where they lose control of their lives."

Her kidnapper -- she never speaks his name -- kept her locked in a steel- and concrete-reinforced secret dungeon on the outskirts of Vienna, but Natascha always maintained control of her thoughts, coping with her ordeal through routines from home (i.e., dusting and tidying up, using skin cream to polish wood).

It must have been scary indeed for Natascha to consider the hour-long process of reaching her dank, moldy lair (i.e., moving a heavy safe, crawling in backwards). She'd be buried alive and mummified if something happened to her captor and he didn't return.

Natascha's kidnapper sounds to have been a socially isolated, outwardly compliant person with a compulsive need for control. He'd time the lights as if Natascha was in a real jail, begrudge her tears and fingerprints, and cruelly limit her food, arguing she didn't need much to eat, given her five-by-five-meter confines.

He eventually allowed Natascha into the rest of the house, and, briefly, outdoors to a garden, where she savored the grass and breeze, beseeching a hedge branch as a memento of the natural world.

Natascha's captor was not without a conscience, she says. He'd let her read books, apparently left over from his school days, and, when requested, bring her the non-fiction and philosophy she preferred. He was good at math, so she'd ask him to give and grade tests, which he tackled with a vengeance, crossing everything out in red.

Natascha guessed that her captor, due to what he'd experienced in childhood, felt a need to be in charge -- that since he hadn't been able to gain a sense of control in his life, one day he simply went out and grabbed it.

"He just liked having someone to dominate, to boost his own self-esteem," she says.

Meanwhile, her mother (we never hear a word about her dad), lacking proof of her daughter's demise, tells us, "Natascha was never dead for me." She would look at photos and say, "Don't give up -- you're a strong, strong child!"

Natascha recounts the day of her abduction. She'd seen a man up ahead of her on the sidewalk, and contemplated crossing the street, but decided against it -- an ineffably fateful move. Another young girl saw her being dragged into a white van, and the disappearance sparked wide publicity and a dragnet. (Amazingly, Natascha's kidnapper was interviewed but never arrested, and heads eventually rolled as a result.)

At times throughout her ordeal, Natascha apparently considered suicide, asking herself, "What's the point?" But she'd remember that she mustn't allow herself to be defeated. She survived by forgiving her captor, she said: Without that, "I'd be so full of hate...it would have destroyed me physically."

It was obvious that the perpetrator was weak and unstable, a victim of his problems, and Natascha actually felt pity and compassion for him, she said.

She had lived underground for so long -- 8.5 years -- that no one on the outside would eventually have recognized her. So her captor came to take her off of the property, introducing her to a friend as an "acquaintance," but warning her he'd kill her if she tried to escape.

However, when Natascha's golden opportunity arrived, and she made a run for it while the bad guy was on the phone, it was he who met up with death, seemingly committing suicide by train without hours.

Natascha seems to have dismissed the media's prurient interest in her case, deeming the press's behavior itself as abusive.

"People love horrible things, and can't get enough of them," she concludes.

Who'd dispute it?
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Badly done documentary
phenomynouss31 March 2019
It feels incredibly awkward to be criticizing a documentary about a kidnapped child who manages to escape, but this documentary is just so badly done and terribly produced, it almost does a disservice to the story its meant to tell.



It is extremely low budget, to start. Aside from the low quality production and music choices that seem to be a string of unrelated tones from a free audiobank, they make some inexplicable decisions that somehow manage to contribute almost nothing.

The majority of the documentary is centered on Natascha herself, telling the story. Unfortunately, what ever questions the documentary people are asking her are largely inane, unimportant, or incoherent. As a result, Natascha spends a lot of time talking about basic details of her torment, such as the technical details of getting in and out of her cell, and almost no time talking about the actual unfolding events or what exactly she did to survive. If they asked her anything about her own state of mind at various points in her captivity, they largely cut all the information out and stopped largely at just "she was hungry a lot and also scared" and almost nothing more.

The story she tells basically amounts to her being kidnapped, locked in a cell, harassed and tormented over cleanliness, working in the house, getting to go outside once, then escaping. Virtually everything else, even the escape and the aftermath, is treated as an afterthought.

Inexplicably, the documentary starts out seeming to set up a follow-along with the police investigation, including typical dramatic re-enactments of police detectives doing typical police work. Then, inexplicably, they just stop showing these altogether, after getting so far as "they followed up on an incredibly vague lead and filed it away". Following that, nothing else is dramatized or re-created.

On top of that, barely any actual news footage is used either, so the vast majority of what we're watching consists either of Natascha herself speaking, or long, droning pans across objects and rooms meant to resemble the house she was kept in. Yet absolutely no detail is given of anything beyond the hidden door to her basement cell so all this imagery is functionally worthless.

This is, sadly, a case of a kidnapped child in which you get far more information and insight and even the emotional experience from reading the Wikipedia article
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Unfortunately not great.
KoalaMug9 March 2021
This might work for someone who's followed the news and knows everything about her case from the media; if you are not acquainted with the case the documentary is bewilderingly unhelpful. A pity that the girl's story was wasted between shots of faucets and sounds of dripping water.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed