Le scandale Clouzot (TV Movie 2017) Poster

(2017 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Why I don't like HGC
bob99829 February 2024
I think about the directors of the period 1930-1960 that I admire--Renoir, Clair, Carne, Gremillon, Duvivier and others--and I realize that I have little admiration or affection for Clouzot. His obsessive, paranoid style of filmmaking has little attraction for me. There's no joy in being the French Hitchcock, in bullying your actors and putting nightmarish scenes up on the screen. Take Les diaboliques, with the awful scene of Paul Meurisse lying in the bathtub, then rising slowly to frighten Vera Clouzot to death: only a sadistic personality could shoot a scene like that. It's Clouzot's Psycho, and just as worthless as art. A collaborator is interviewed: she says his flaw was in not having any imagination. He'd ask his actress Suzy Delair to make up some dialogue because he couldn't think of anything to write down.

The end of this 60 minute documentary came not too soon. I've got some films by Jacques Becker I want to rewatch... now there was a real filmmaker.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Unsurpassed master.
dbdumonteil21 November 2017
Clouzot was one of the absolute masters of the French cinema ,the only one who enjoys TWO movies in the IMDb top 250, an incredible feat for a director from France.

This documentary is a must for his fans (that is to say for people who do not think that French cinema began with the Nouvelle Vague );sometimes labeled "Cinema De Papa " ,what an insult for an artist who took more chances than any highbrow of the early sixties!

The documentary shows how his movies were often a sign of a times.In his occupied country , HGC was given Carte Blanche by German Continental producer Graven whom Goebbels had urged to give French audience "light" movies. "Le Corbeau " was anything but light: its depiction of informing reflected the bundles of letters the French would send to inform against the Jews.

At the liberation,HGC was suspended for two years . The documentary focuses on the classic "Quai Des Orfèvres" and many of it great scenes.But the director's own vision of the post-war days ,his settlement of scores ,"Manon", is sadly passed over in silence.The same goes for "Les Espions" his most complex work,which depicted the cold war cynically.

Much time is given over to everyone's favorites "Le Salaire De La Peur" and "Les Diaboliques " the IMDb users took to the top 250 movies and which were both remade in US.They put HGC's second wife ,Vera,under the spotlight ; here again, the director's attitude was ambiguous :he did love this very attractive South-American and he would bully her as much as he did for his other actors ;Roger Boussinot,who hated "Les Diaboliques " , wrote:" it's not one of its least morbid appeals to see his wife (who had a heart condition in real life) play her own role on the screen.

With the underrated "La Vérité" ,his work had,once again, its finger on the pulse of a changing society ,not yet prepared to accept that a woman should live like a man .That was Brigitte Bardot's finest performance -she wrote it was her best movie in her memoirs-,the scene when she cries out of pain ,in front of her judges and the populace ,afraid of an incipient women's lib has remained in our memories.

An educated man,HGC never stopped experimenting : he filmed Picasso at work,an invaluable document,and as the young Turks of the Nouvelle Vaguelette were ridiculing him, he tackled his most ambitious work ,"L'Enfer" which would have made his detractors bite the dust ,if it had been completed (people interested in this doomed project should see 'L'Enfer D'Henri-Georges Clouzot" an absorbing documentary ).Some of its elements were integrated into his swansong ,"La Prisonnière".

Let this documentary be an introduction to HGC for people who only know his two top 250 movies.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed