The premise was interesting and could have been a good story. I generally like thoughtful SCI-FI, dystopian films and George Clooney. The visuals and cinematography were good (obviously a decent budget). Unfortunately, the script was a bit boring and improbable, the story familiar and predictable.
The space side of this story was just silly. A spaceship on a long journey from A to B doesn't suddenly fly off course. In space (which is a vacuum with no friction), there's initial propulsion and then months or years of just moving at speed. Unless something hits the spaceship or it's trying some maneuver around a body, there's no chance of flying off course. The moon they visit has breathable air for humans. One crew member is hit by flying ice while on a spacewalk, but somehow doesn't know that her suit, which is pressurized, has been punctured and that she has been fatally wounded. The spacecraft is moving at 10,000 km/h and a human hit with anything at that speed (more than two times the speed of a bullet) would be pulverized. Radio communication between the spaceship and earth is instant, despite the vast distances. Even assuming some amazing future communications technology that travels something close to light speed, it would take minutes.
In the end, when it's clear that earth is uninhabitable and the Saturn moon is humanity's last hope, two of 4 remaining crew members decide on a suicide mission to return to earth, taking with them one of the 2 landing vehicles and 50% of the crew. No thought or debate about how they will be dooming the remaining two (one of whom is very pregnant) to almost certain death (and our species to extinction). And the captain allows it. Right.
The Arctic is shown to be in constant blizzard conditions, even while the ice is suddenly melting under their feet. The snow vehicle (which exposes its driver to the elements) can go for days without additional fuel or recharging. The main character falls in frozen water and swims around like it's a tropical pool, then somehow not only survives in his wet clothes and shoes but walks for what looks to be a couple of days in whiteout conditions without shelter.
I could go on and on. Ignoring these improbabilities doesn't help the story, because the story isn't interesting enough to compensate for the assault on the viewer's intelligence. The big twist was entirely predictable as well - the person who's not really there device has been overused in recent years to the point that it's now the first thing you consider.
The space side of this story was just silly. A spaceship on a long journey from A to B doesn't suddenly fly off course. In space (which is a vacuum with no friction), there's initial propulsion and then months or years of just moving at speed. Unless something hits the spaceship or it's trying some maneuver around a body, there's no chance of flying off course. The moon they visit has breathable air for humans. One crew member is hit by flying ice while on a spacewalk, but somehow doesn't know that her suit, which is pressurized, has been punctured and that she has been fatally wounded. The spacecraft is moving at 10,000 km/h and a human hit with anything at that speed (more than two times the speed of a bullet) would be pulverized. Radio communication between the spaceship and earth is instant, despite the vast distances. Even assuming some amazing future communications technology that travels something close to light speed, it would take minutes.
In the end, when it's clear that earth is uninhabitable and the Saturn moon is humanity's last hope, two of 4 remaining crew members decide on a suicide mission to return to earth, taking with them one of the 2 landing vehicles and 50% of the crew. No thought or debate about how they will be dooming the remaining two (one of whom is very pregnant) to almost certain death (and our species to extinction). And the captain allows it. Right.
The Arctic is shown to be in constant blizzard conditions, even while the ice is suddenly melting under their feet. The snow vehicle (which exposes its driver to the elements) can go for days without additional fuel or recharging. The main character falls in frozen water and swims around like it's a tropical pool, then somehow not only survives in his wet clothes and shoes but walks for what looks to be a couple of days in whiteout conditions without shelter.
I could go on and on. Ignoring these improbabilities doesn't help the story, because the story isn't interesting enough to compensate for the assault on the viewer's intelligence. The big twist was entirely predictable as well - the person who's not really there device has been overused in recent years to the point that it's now the first thing you consider.
Tell Your Friends