The movie chose action sequences over character development and I can support that. The visuals are amazing.
But it seems that the Germans had to be both mean and stupid in this film.
They had to be depicted as evil so they have them taunt the convoy and it's escorts by radio. No sub captain would give his position away like that.
On top of that the Germans had top be depicted as stupid too and completely surfaced their Uboots all the time within visual range of the escorts BY DAY when they had perfectly good periscopes. Even in the middle of the convoy, right next to a destroyer at a range of a couple hundred yards. Lunacy, this never happened. Of course when they actually used periscopes they rose up like 10 feet into the air at a range of a maybe a mile from a destroyer.
No no no. When a sub spots a destroyer, he goes silent and goes away, he does NOT attack and surely not head on. Subs did not want to sink destroyers, they saved their precious torpedoes for merchant ships only. When a sub is forced to surface between two destroyers they also don't shoot it out, that's plain suicide.
Cowboy action, bubblegum for the brain, nothing more.
On top of that the Germans had top be depicted as stupid too and completely surfaced their Uboots all the time within visual range of the escorts BY DAY when they had perfectly good periscopes. Even in the middle of the convoy, right next to a destroyer at a range of a couple hundred yards. Lunacy, this never happened. Of course when they actually used periscopes they rose up like 10 feet into the air at a range of a maybe a mile from a destroyer.
No no no. When a sub spots a destroyer, he goes silent and goes away, he does NOT attack and surely not head on. Subs did not want to sink destroyers, they saved their precious torpedoes for merchant ships only. When a sub is forced to surface between two destroyers they also don't shoot it out, that's plain suicide.
Cowboy action, bubblegum for the brain, nothing more.
Tell Your Friends