Change Your Image
wnstn_hmltn
Reviews
BBC Sunday-Night Theatre: Nineteen Eighty-Four (1954)
If you've never seen this, the greatest filmed version....
Teaming the ultimate speculative-fiction scenarist (Nigel Kneale) with two of the most monumental actors to have ever had a command of the Queen's English (Peter Cushing and Andre Morell) has resulted in a dynamic trio striking this unflinching rendition of the Orwell classic with sparks aplenty. Later to become living legends over at Hammer Films (particularly Cushing), it was this momentous pairing of Morell and Cushing that led the Hammer powers-that-be to reunite them seven years later in the truly remarkable "Cash on Demand" (see my review). The lovely, inscrutable Yvonne Mitchell acquits herself well as Cushing's forbidden love interest, and the atmosphere of foreboding and dread is so thick you could cut it. Last but not least, watching Kneale apply his inimitable touch to Orwell's concepts is a tremendously exciting foretaste of the wholly original yarns he would later spin ("Quatermass," etc. ) A superlative production all the way around.....don't miss it!
1984 (1956)
Terrific, but the earlier Peter Cushing version.....
......is even better. One might be tempted to call this a remake, and I suppose it is, but it was the first theatrical rendition, enabling audiences to watch Big Brother (watching them) on a bigger screen than was possible via the BBC/Peter Cushing version (1954) of two years earlier. I agree with previous commentator "bux's" observance that, while Edmond O'Brien and Jan Sterling may not have been Orwell's first casting choices for Winston and Julia for the reason stated, the sterling performances generated by the leads and their supporting cast more than compensate. As a huge fan of the late, great Hammer Films luminary Michael Ripper, I was especially pleased to see him helping to take up the rear as an Outer Party Orator, exemplifying the tender loving care with which producer N. Peter Rathvon saw fit to cast even the smaller roles.
Nineteen Eighty-Four (1984)
Superb, but the earlier Peter Cushing version...........
....from 1954 is even better. Be that as it may, this rendition pulls out all the totali-terror-ian stops with such a nerve-fraying atmosphere of all-consuming menace, accented by an enticingly eerie Eurythmics score and unforgettable, breathe-down-your-neck performances by all concerned. What punctuates this version's effectiveness is that it's (obviously) the most recognizably modern, leaving one dogged more than ever by the notion that Orwell's waking nightmare could really happen if it isn't already! Richard Burton, John Hurt and Suzanna Hamilton are unforgettable.