I am kind of surprised at how many reviews here are taking the stance that this was clearly a case of suicide and should not have been part of the series. I completely disagree! COULD it have been a suicide? Yes, absolutely. But is there enough evidence to cast doubt on it being a suicide? Unless a significant number of details/pieces of evidence are complete fabrications, then yes.
Like another reviewer stated, I am not going to opine on the case itself but rather on the episode, which is the point. I liked this episode because to me the events do all seem quite bizarre. But the episode is also highly frustrating because there are huge pieces of the story that are presented to the viewer and then simply dropped, not explored, not mentioned again, or not explained and I do not know why.
The incident with the girl's friend and the credit card fraud seems significant (at least we are to assume it is or else it would not have been mentioned), yet it is brought up once and then dropped. The fact that at least one of her friends stated that she was not happy and was depressed, etc., is shown but then nothing more is said about it (granted the girl seemed like a dolt and every other word she said was "like," so not very articulate and maybe there was simply nothing more to it than that). The fact that the train engineers gave conflicting, changing stories and one of them seemed to have flat out lied at one point (first said he saw it happen, then said he was not even looking at the tracks and saw nothing) is weird and never explored.
The most incredibly bizarre part of this episode, and the one which is easily the most frustrating because it is not explained, is the guy who said he heard three young men talking in great detail about the abduction, torture and murder of this girl--he even provided details to the police based on what he heard them say. Yet when those three young men were questioned by police they claimed to have no clue what the other guy was talking about and that they never had any discussion about the girl whatsoever and knew nothing about any of it aside from hearing she had killed herself. And that is the end of it. How on earth is this even possible? Was the other guy completely making the story up? Or were the three men lying? Why is something so huge not explained or discussed more?
The other aspect of this episode that made me uncomfortable was how exploitative it felt in terms of the family's grief--particularly the mother. She seems a bit mental, for lack of a better term, because of this event. Watching her at her creepy shrine to her daughter, writing messages or wishes or whatever they were and putting them in a box in the shrine, kissing the photos, it was all just too much. It creeped me out because I felt the behavior was really bizarre no matter how tragic the event was, and then I immediately felt bad for judging this woman who has been through something so horrendous. The bottom line is we probably should not be watching that sort of activity. This is all probably on me, but I feel the need to include that part because it really was weird.
As with other episodes, this one could have been told in half the time it took. But overall I believe there IS enough of a mystery here that the story does have a place in the show.
Like another reviewer stated, I am not going to opine on the case itself but rather on the episode, which is the point. I liked this episode because to me the events do all seem quite bizarre. But the episode is also highly frustrating because there are huge pieces of the story that are presented to the viewer and then simply dropped, not explored, not mentioned again, or not explained and I do not know why.
The incident with the girl's friend and the credit card fraud seems significant (at least we are to assume it is or else it would not have been mentioned), yet it is brought up once and then dropped. The fact that at least one of her friends stated that she was not happy and was depressed, etc., is shown but then nothing more is said about it (granted the girl seemed like a dolt and every other word she said was "like," so not very articulate and maybe there was simply nothing more to it than that). The fact that the train engineers gave conflicting, changing stories and one of them seemed to have flat out lied at one point (first said he saw it happen, then said he was not even looking at the tracks and saw nothing) is weird and never explored.
The most incredibly bizarre part of this episode, and the one which is easily the most frustrating because it is not explained, is the guy who said he heard three young men talking in great detail about the abduction, torture and murder of this girl--he even provided details to the police based on what he heard them say. Yet when those three young men were questioned by police they claimed to have no clue what the other guy was talking about and that they never had any discussion about the girl whatsoever and knew nothing about any of it aside from hearing she had killed herself. And that is the end of it. How on earth is this even possible? Was the other guy completely making the story up? Or were the three men lying? Why is something so huge not explained or discussed more?
The other aspect of this episode that made me uncomfortable was how exploitative it felt in terms of the family's grief--particularly the mother. She seems a bit mental, for lack of a better term, because of this event. Watching her at her creepy shrine to her daughter, writing messages or wishes or whatever they were and putting them in a box in the shrine, kissing the photos, it was all just too much. It creeped me out because I felt the behavior was really bizarre no matter how tragic the event was, and then I immediately felt bad for judging this woman who has been through something so horrendous. The bottom line is we probably should not be watching that sort of activity. This is all probably on me, but I feel the need to include that part because it really was weird.
As with other episodes, this one could have been told in half the time it took. But overall I believe there IS enough of a mystery here that the story does have a place in the show.
Tell Your Friends