Now let me start off by saying this movie totally stunk. If you want to see a good love story by the same author see Message in a Bottle, now that is a great and passionate love story. But honestly, when I was done watching Nights in Rodanthe I was like..wow, that was so cheesy and totally overrated. It just seemed that the author of the book was overusing his famous plot of killing off one of the lovers, it's getting kinda old. And also the actors, yeah, Richard Geer can be an amazing actor but I think he did horrible in this film, it was almost as if he didn't put any heart in the character at all! And Diane Lane, well she was at least a little better, but was still kinda annoying.
But when I was keep watching it, it got so boring, it dragged on and on, until the storm scene. And wow... he so happens to save her dear life from a falling bookcase, and they all of a sudden fall in love? that is so unrealistic if you ask me! And what was with the part in thowing away all of the canned foods!...completely unnecessary and they were acting immature. And I think the part where Richard Geer had to resolve a misunderstanding with the man who he accidentally killed his wife, it just seemed like that part of the movie was thrown in there just because they couldn't think of anything more interesting. But the toward the end of the movie, the scenes were cut off way too short and you could hardly keep up with the story. The scene with the party was way too short and confusing, and I don't want too get into the next scene but let me tell you, it's not right that people sleep together once and they think they have stumbled upon the love of your life! that's not how it works! and it's definitely not God's way! And then. Oh boy the guy dies...an overused dramatic plot to the story..it can be good for some films but sometimes it's just too much.
Bottom line, if your in the mood for a good old fashioned romance..Do Not See This Movie! I recommend Message in a Bottle or The New World
2 out of 6 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends