Mel Gibson is certainly capable of acting in a revenge flick. But this is a puzzling film. While one would expect the director to convey to the audience a hero with whom to sympathize, Gibson's Craven is an unlikable "hero" who overreacts and overacts right from the start in unnatural fashion. When tragedy strikes his family immediately, Gibson practically bites the head off anyone around him, barking at everyone which continues throughout the film. It's the result of bad directing and probably a mediocre script and production. It was difficult not to notice how horribly sloppy the rainstorm is shown on screen in the opening, seeing only half the screen filled with rain (from the garden hose above) in at least 2-3 scene perspectives. It was a foreshadowing of the feel of low budget films.
Throughout the rest of the film I could never escape the feeling like Gibson is acting. Unlike Neeson in Taken, whose rage is tempered and surfaces when provocation is near, Gibson is always a 10 on the rampage meter. The police in his home, at the office and in the morgue - he's chopping them all up in this stoic and then sudden bursts of outrage. This is the case even some who seem to be colleagues with whom he works and has an existing amicable relationship. Completely unconvincing and unnatural.
Further, if Gibson is supposed to have been portrayed as a totally unlikable loner, then the audience really doesn't care one white about whether Gibson's Craven lives or dies or fails in his efforts to discover why the tragedy happened and exact revenge upon those who brought it. And I couldn't find anything redeemable about the guy that you'd like from the start, other than that he seems to adore his daughter. Fine. But he seems to be a miserable person who gives all a reason around him to hate him, even if they continue to extend olive branches throughout the film.
Police captain - you can't work on this investigation. It's against the rules. (Of course it is due to a conflict of interest and impossibility to properly testify at trial.) And it is Crime 101. Suddenly the captain agrees that if there is at least some information he must provide (which would be no different than any other crime victim) then somehow he's allowed to work on the case. Uh.... say what? OK, let's say he's giving Gibson a tad of leeway sympathy. Gibson's character seems totally ungrateful in every way. He's plainly not likable at all from the start. This is really not a great film and one of Gibson's worst efforts. Looking up the director, he's the one who directed Green Lantern. Enough said and validates this entire review.
1 out of 9 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends