Given the choice, I would have done a 7.5 rather than an eight, but I'm rounding to the highest number here.
First off, it's unfair to compare this movie to his father's works. Goro's standing in a huge shadow and has a lot to live up to. This movie, I feel was pretty darn good... if you don't compare it to the elder Miyazaki's material. Also, if you've read the books, don't expect this to BE the books, but rather a different retelling of them (much as, despite what I said about comparisons, Howl's Moving Castle was a different retelling of the original book).
It was a visually stunning movie, with Goro following closely to his dad's style there, and the music was also excellent. The character designs I have mixed feelings about. LeGuin, writer of the Earthsea books, was rather well-known for the majority of her characters in Earthsea being people of color, with the exception of Tenar and the other Kargish people. While Ged very obviously had the red-brown color we expected, everybody else felt rather whitewashed. For Cob, it was oddly fitting since it enhanced his very creepy demeanor (something which I give major kudos for). But it made Tenar, who was supposed to be the only major white person in the story, seem not foreign at all. The only thing that constituted her "foreign-ness" was her blond hair... and she wasn't blond in the books. And Therru's scar, which was supposed to be a major deformity that blinded her on one side of her face, was also really not that bad. Hardly noticeable, in fact.
The writing was a bit... lacking, I suppose. There really should have been more background information. Example, the drug Hazia, in the books, was mentioned to turn people's lips black. In the movie, Hazia was mentioned but its side-effects (aside from euphoria) were not mentioned, so when Arren is tricked into drinking something with Hazia in it, a person who hasn't read the books wouldn't know that and feel that Hazia was something mentioned simply for the sake of being mentioned. Arren's backstory was a bit complicated as well. I didn't quite understand it, and when I do try to it seems... well, unnecessary. Tenar's past also could've been more in depth, perhaps with them mentioning that she was a priestess of the Nameless Ones, the darkness that is so often alluded to in the movie but never really named. Therru's dormant magical powers also could've been alluded to more often too, as her change into a dragon at the end seemed rather forced since she showed no signs of being 'special' magically, except for the one moment when Ged mentions something but never elaborates.
Aside from that, the plot was really something, even if the writing was a bit sloppy. Cob's personification in the movie was downright nasty, and really did give the impression of being a BAD guy. I'll be honest and say he gave me the heebie-jeebies, ridiculous as it may sound. Hare was a completely different character than in the books, but I don't mind and found that he actually made quite an evil side-kick. You definitely want to kick him in the balls, that's for sure. And again, the movie is visually stunning with great music.
So while it lacks in writing and isn't terribly faithful to the original character designs, it's still enjoyable and fun to watch, and generally rather faithful to its source material. But again, you can;t expect it to be the books.
0 out of 2 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends