Out of the live action remakes (which personally I wish they'd stop doing) this has been my favourite so far. Putting aside the original Disney Mulan, as a stand alone film this was pretty good. Is it a game-changing, amazing film? No. Is it as good as the original animated? No. But it's still a good film. I like some of the references to the original animated film, such as in the music, and I liked the use of the kite for the phoenix.
Also, putting aside the controversy about the lead actress Yifei Liu, she was OK. I would have liked a little more emotion from her, but overall she did good.
I had a couple of issues with it, confusing things, unneeded roles, inconsistencies. I felt the story itself was made far too complicated, which I think leads to its downfall. The animated original has a simple story, which is partly why it is better.
Some of the fighting was a bit ridiculous. Weapons not even close to someone yet they make dramatic movements, a lot of flying through the sky etc. I don't mind a little over dramatisation, but it was a little much.
I felt the witch didn't really have a place in this film. All she really did was help them get through the garrisons and in some wYs "uncover" Mulans true self. But there could have been better ways of doing that. Mulan could have also got to Bori Khan without the witch. I guess they wanted more strong females in the film. There were also inconsistencies in it, such as when Mulan returned to tell them about Bori Khans plan, she told them a ton of information yet the witch barely told her anything?
Anyway, it is an enjoyable watch that both kids and adults can enjoy. It is a Disney film after all, it has to be for all ages. Just don't take it too seriously. And remember, you can't have courage without fear.
25 out of 43 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends