Seasons 1-3 - 2 is good, 1 is ok and 3 reminds me of a female version of Riverdale.
Binged watched S1-3 and have to say, J. Lange is so overrated in the comments here. Her acting throughout three seasons is always more or less the same character. The elderly vamp, brutal and manipulating, and a little in distress at times. Ok S2 as a standalone would have been good for her, but braced by 1 and 3 it looks as if she can only play one character.
Instead I loved the versatility of Lily Rabe, her many different faces, emotions, characters, she was great. You always felt she brings something different, something special or characteristic to her characters. A different smile, a significant gesture, her posture, many little things the others missed out on.
Paulson also rather repetitive (her "surprised" face with this weird smile...), same as Farmiga (the dreaming teenager), Peters (the haunted and misunderstood boy) and Conroy (the supervisor of everything). If you binge watch S1-3, it becomes very obvious, how limited the range of these guys truly is.
Out of this three, Season 2 was the best I'd say. The writing was ok, I loved Thredson, Pepper, Grace, and of course Dr. Arden! There were true moments of distress in there, and Sister Jude was played well by Lange. Except for the strange opening with the Maroon 5 guy, who felt so out of place, and the overuse of sexuality without any plot driving reason other than to create cheap thrills, the writing was not bad. Conroy as the angel of death had her moments and even Peters was ok at times. Only it seems that he has not more than three expressions - shocked, sad or hurt, and angry.
All in all, a very overrated series, but its possible, that if you watch this once a week, it might work. But watching all those episodes in a row, it becomes rather boring. Especially Lange I have to say. You could switch hundred of scenes between Constance, Jude, and Fiona, and it would not have made much of a difference. The same situations, same mannerisms, same everything, even her drinking and her sexuality. Boring. But Sister Jude was her best performance here - especially her last scene.
11 out of 18 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends