The story revolves around Nina, a young, professional ESL teacher and translator, who is anguished to the core of her being by the sudden loss of husband Jamie - a cellist - beautifully played by Alan Rickman. Nina's grief at her loss is so profound that she frequently breaks down in hysterical crying jags. She seems to sense Jamie's presence – and one day, it's not only a sensation, he's actually, physically present in her flat. She's thrilled – she's comforted – they affectionately nuzzle and play duets. Jamie is loving and tender, although he appears to suffer from the cold.
Life with Jamie, living or dead, seems blissful initially. But while Nina is at work, Jamie invites his ghost mates in to watch videos; they are a motley crew who don't allow Nina any privacy, and that is a bit of a turn-off. They impose on her to pick up more videos, and they help Jamie to "helpfully" roll up her old carpet and rearrange her furniture – without asking her, however. One reviewer said that Jamie's actions are intended to alienate Nina, and thus persuade her to move on with her life. I think that may well be true.
When Nina meets with her new light-of-life (Mark) at the end of the film and lingeringly kisses him, the camera pulls back to a long shot of Jamie and his ghost mates gazing down on Nina and Mark from the front window of her flat. I felt wistful and rather forlorn as Jamie waves a tender goodbye. But Nina exits with her new beau with nary a glance backward. Had Nina, equally tenderly, looked up at Jamie and blown a kiss or waved sweetly to him, I would have sensed more of a mutual affection combined with a reciprocal acknowledgement that it truly was time for both of them to move on. Instead, while I felt she was making a new life for herself, with few regrets or reflection, she was leaving Jamie in the dear, dark past.
Life with Jamie, living or dead, seems blissful initially. But while Nina is at work, Jamie invites his ghost mates in to watch videos; they are a motley crew who don't allow Nina any privacy, and that is a bit of a turn-off. They impose on her to pick up more videos, and they help Jamie to "helpfully" roll up her old carpet and rearrange her furniture – without asking her, however. One reviewer said that Jamie's actions are intended to alienate Nina, and thus persuade her to move on with her life. I think that may well be true.
When Nina meets with her new light-of-life (Mark) at the end of the film and lingeringly kisses him, the camera pulls back to a long shot of Jamie and his ghost mates gazing down on Nina and Mark from the front window of her flat. I felt wistful and rather forlorn as Jamie waves a tender goodbye. But Nina exits with her new beau with nary a glance backward. Had Nina, equally tenderly, looked up at Jamie and blown a kiss or waved sweetly to him, I would have sensed more of a mutual affection combined with a reciprocal acknowledgement that it truly was time for both of them to move on. Instead, while I felt she was making a new life for herself, with few regrets or reflection, she was leaving Jamie in the dear, dark past.
Tell Your Friends