Just before the final act of Karan Johar's Ae Dil Hai Mushkil, the brilliantly orchestrated title track begins, with a close-up of Ranbir Kapoor, lip-syncing in earnest, to Arijit Singh's melancholy voice. It is an uncharacteristically long shot. A shot that focuses on his somber, unflinching, eyes. It requires an actor of Kapoor's caliber to maintain that intense gaze for a minute and a half, such that even the beautiful song is relegated to the background.
The journey leading up to the said song (and the song itself) is trademark Karan Johar, and yet it isn't. The movie has his cinematic stamp all over it, what with the sheer Bollywood-ness of the proceedings. However, this time around, he lends each character a certain credibility, rather than the larger-than-life, family- value-toting protagonists that he usually prefers.
Make no mistake, this isn't a movie with amped-up pathos, and unnecessary slow-mo shots. Surprisingly, neither is the movie about Aishwarya Rai Bachchan, but more on that later. Superfluousness takes a backseat, and instead the characters live, laugh, talk, love and even hate like any normal person would.
Ranbir Kapoor's Ayan Sanger is a budding singer stuck doing MBA in London, per his wealthy father's wishes. He chances upon Alizeh at a party, and one meet-cute and two sloppy kisses later, they become friends.
Both are shown to be Bollywood fanatics, as evidenced by them constantly hamming dialogues from popular movies of the past. There is even a nifty little sequence in the beginning where both Ayan and Alizeh make pop-culture references straight from Dharma Productions' movie list.
They get along well, too well, in-fact. Ayan falls for Alizeh, but she doesn't reciprocate that attraction. Her past love, Ali (Fawad Khan) resurfaces, and she gets married to him. How Ayan copes with not getting the love that he so passionately yearns for from Alizeh forms the rest of the story.
Pop-culture would give Ayan's predicament a cringe-worthy name - being 'friendzoned'. It is a pathetically convenient term to an unfortunate, complex situation. Johar, who has confessed that this movie is semi-autobiographical, goes out of his way to convince us that the 'friendzone' isn't really a terrible thing, and succeeds.
As far as the performances go, Kapoor is mesmerizing. He borrows various aspects of his personality from his past characters - the angst of a broken heart from Rockstar, the man-child behavior from Wake Up Sid, and his vulnerability from Tamasha, bringing all of them together to add another feather to his stellar acting cap.
Aishwarya Rai Bachchan, who essays the role of a poet (Saba) who Ayan has a (primarily sexual) relationship with, while trying to move on from Alizeh, is the biggest disappointment of the movie. She has barely fifteen minutes of screen time and one song. Johar portrays her like an ethereal goddess, her character is scarcely believable. A world- famous divorcée poetess living in Vienna looking for a fling, conjuring up Urdu couplets for breakfast just isn't convincing enough, in a movie trying it's best to be grounded in reality. It seemed like Johar was so happy with himself that he managed to finally direct Aishwarya Rai Bachchan, that he forgot to give her a role.
Fawad Khan has two scenes and three dialogues in the entire film. That's a costly fifty million rupees!
Speaking of Khans, Johar's favourite Khan, makes a fleeting appearance, espousing the central idea of the film in a crucial piece of dialogue, paving the way for the film's denouement.
But this movie's show-stopper is Anushka Sharma. Alizeh is a complex character to play, simply because she becomes the 'villain' of sorts. And yet, you can't help empathize with her. Sharma, in her best acting performance till date, wins you over. Whether she is embracing her Bollywood-fan-girl dreams, resigning to the fact that she's still in love with her ex-boyfriend, or breaking down at the sheer helplessness of the situation she finds herself in, Alizeh is the character you want to root for, throughout the movie.
There is a scene, the only one with the troika, referencing Noor Jehan's famous rendition of Faiz Ahmed Faiz's words. As Ayan completes aliases recital of 'Mujhse pehli si mohabbat', with the devastating 'mere mehboob na maang', Alizeh's piercing eyes could smash a thousand glasses. That look alone, is worth the price of the ticket.
The movie makes use of songs beautifully. Two of them, the title track and Bulleya, have gone on to become chart-busters, and their depiction on-screen, is perfect. The highlight of the soundtrack, though, is Channa Mereya, a typical Johar tearjerker, which plays out during what is the movie's best-acted scene.
'Friendship over love' is an ideal that has tasted little to no success in Bollywood. What impressed me most was Johar's resistance to going with the conventional movie ending, especially considering his body of work. Yes, the last half an hour is a contrived, almost unnecessary final act, which could have been handled better. But for the most part, the direction is top-notch.
What is most surprising about this venture is how Johar manages to make the film remain realistic throughout the ups and downs of the characters. There is no magnum opus feel; protagonists don't wait for background music to support them while proclaiming dramatic dialogues. Instead, Johar focuses on establishing the fact that love need not be limited to romance, underlined by Alizeh's last-ditch appeal to Ayan in the film's climax. Disproving Mohnish Behl's infamous line from Maine Pyaar Kiya is no mean feat, but Johar, through Alizeh and Ayan, does it with utmost grace and conviction.
In his debut movie, Johar convinced us that friendship is love. With this one, he drives through the point that love is friendship, and I couldn't agree more. Sorry, Shah Rukh Khan, but this adage rings true more than that one ever could. 'What's the difference?', an apathetic person would ask. Everything.
1 out of 3 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends