So this film has a lot of negative reviews and having watched it I can understand why. I think it is largely due to the fact that this film is marketed as a "horror film" but doesn't really follow any typical horror ideas. To me this film at no point was really scary and was more of a spiritual film and I think it's low rating is because it's misold to the viewer.
Horror enthusiasts like myself watch horror films because they're scary and we want to be scared. We don't really want to think, we don't want to have empathy or feel sorry, we just want a cheap scare and a thrill and this film doesn't offer any of that because it's really categorised into the wrong genre.
I don't really know how I would categorise this film if I'm honest with you. Putting it bluntly this film follows the main character who is alive and seeking a break away from the trauma of her life because she was abused by our father as a child. However, it also follows the storyline of a ghost who seems to be trapped in the cabin with her. He seems to spend a lot of his spare time sitting or standing while staring angrily into the distance or staring at her. One morning she even wakes up and he's lying next to her in bed. Without any background to this character, you don't know whether he is a sinister entity or if he loves her because she has lived there a long time or fact that they could've potentially had some relationship in the past. Really not enough is explained to help you understand the plight of any of the characters in the film. Without that explanation, you lose interest.
The Man in Black ghost, I couldn't work out whether he was just another ghost who enjoyed scaring people to get in with the devil or whether he was a representation of the Devil himself. I felt at one point as the man in black was a representation of the Devil and the angelic ghost at the end was a representation of God and that the ghost was being tested, to see whether he would spend eternity in hell or heaven. However once again there really is not enough explanation to get a sense of what's going on so it's hard to become invested or to really care about the outcome.
I actually thought it was really well written, I liked the idea behind the film but there were times where there was just not enough effort put into the storyline and there was no explanation and without, an understanding of the characters you're watching for a film like this that is thought-provoking, it's very hard to develop an interest.
Also one bit that still bothers me now is the birds that flew into the outhouse. There really was no explanation for this and I couldn't tell whether it was a symbolism thing, whether the ghost had the power to influence the birds to fly into the outhouse just to scare her... I found it slightly unclear as to the point of that.
Overall, I think it was a really good idea but needed better execution, a bit more background to the characters you're following so that you can actually have some kind of thought process in regards to the journey in the film in the outcome .
Horror enthusiasts like myself watch horror films because they're scary and we want to be scared. We don't really want to think, we don't want to have empathy or feel sorry, we just want a cheap scare and a thrill and this film doesn't offer any of that because it's really categorised into the wrong genre.
I don't really know how I would categorise this film if I'm honest with you. Putting it bluntly this film follows the main character who is alive and seeking a break away from the trauma of her life because she was abused by our father as a child. However, it also follows the storyline of a ghost who seems to be trapped in the cabin with her. He seems to spend a lot of his spare time sitting or standing while staring angrily into the distance or staring at her. One morning she even wakes up and he's lying next to her in bed. Without any background to this character, you don't know whether he is a sinister entity or if he loves her because she has lived there a long time or fact that they could've potentially had some relationship in the past. Really not enough is explained to help you understand the plight of any of the characters in the film. Without that explanation, you lose interest.
The Man in Black ghost, I couldn't work out whether he was just another ghost who enjoyed scaring people to get in with the devil or whether he was a representation of the Devil himself. I felt at one point as the man in black was a representation of the Devil and the angelic ghost at the end was a representation of God and that the ghost was being tested, to see whether he would spend eternity in hell or heaven. However once again there really is not enough explanation to get a sense of what's going on so it's hard to become invested or to really care about the outcome.
I actually thought it was really well written, I liked the idea behind the film but there were times where there was just not enough effort put into the storyline and there was no explanation and without, an understanding of the characters you're watching for a film like this that is thought-provoking, it's very hard to develop an interest.
Also one bit that still bothers me now is the birds that flew into the outhouse. There really was no explanation for this and I couldn't tell whether it was a symbolism thing, whether the ghost had the power to influence the birds to fly into the outhouse just to scare her... I found it slightly unclear as to the point of that.
Overall, I think it was a really good idea but needed better execution, a bit more background to the characters you're following so that you can actually have some kind of thought process in regards to the journey in the film in the outcome .
Tell Your Friends