To those who have issues with Keel and Grayson in this film -- I think it might have worked splendidly. They were great in Showboat (1951) and Kiss Me, Kate (1953, I think).
Also, a musical like Brigadoon CALLS for legitimate singers to render the demanding showstoppers. Emphasizing the dance in this musical was, in my opinion, a big mistake. True, dancing was and is an important part of this musical, but the showstoppers give the musical its luster, its sheen, its charisma.
The number 'Almost Like Being in Love' is NOTHING without both the baritone and soprano singing the part.
And what's this bit with changing the surnames from MacLaren to Campbell?
In my opinion, most stage musicals should be left on the stage, where they belong, NOT adapted into movies with less than legitimate musical performers (read 'West Side Story').
Also, a musical like Brigadoon CALLS for legitimate singers to render the demanding showstoppers. Emphasizing the dance in this musical was, in my opinion, a big mistake. True, dancing was and is an important part of this musical, but the showstoppers give the musical its luster, its sheen, its charisma.
The number 'Almost Like Being in Love' is NOTHING without both the baritone and soprano singing the part.
And what's this bit with changing the surnames from MacLaren to Campbell?
In my opinion, most stage musicals should be left on the stage, where they belong, NOT adapted into movies with less than legitimate musical performers (read 'West Side Story').