Imitation is NOT the best form of flattery in this case.
6 July 2002
While I enjoyed this film, I feel that there were a couple of problems with it.

The first is that it was shot in color. Having seen the original Lilies of the Field in black & white, there was a certain "feeling" about seeing it in b/w, and somehow seeing the sequel in color just didn't do it for me.

The second is with the role of Homer Smith. While I had no problem with Billy Dee Williams playing the role, I have a big problem with him mimicking the voice inflections, hand motions, and movments of Sidney Poitier. I felt that it was too contrived.

Sidney Poitier was the perfect actor in the original Lillies of the Field back in '63, he has certain mannerisms and vocal inflections that make him who he is.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed