I think Cynthia Watros actually was in this episode as Libby. If you look closely at the Elizabeth person Desmond got the boat from you'll notice a few things...
1) The actress is obviously wearing a wig.
2) The Elizabeth character makes Libby-esquire leaps of insight several times in the conversation with Desmond (that psychologist/mental patient background).
2a) These insightful jumps are written into the dialogue in a bit of an incongruent way that makes you think "wow...what a weird woman", making the actions stand out, like they want it to be easy to realize it's Libby.
3) If you stream the episode from ABC.com and pause you can see it's Cynthia Watros. The eyes stand out.
4) Libby is short for Elizabeth.
Anyone else notice this, too?
1) The actress is obviously wearing a wig.
2) The Elizabeth character makes Libby-esquire leaps of insight several times in the conversation with Desmond (that psychologist/mental patient background).
2a) These insightful jumps are written into the dialogue in a bit of an incongruent way that makes you think "wow...what a weird woman", making the actions stand out, like they want it to be easy to realize it's Libby.
3) If you stream the episode from ABC.com and pause you can see it's Cynthia Watros. The eyes stand out.
4) Libby is short for Elizabeth.
Anyone else notice this, too?