I saw this film a few years ago and was much taken by it, but only came to realize how good it really is after comparing it to Disney's remake, "Eight Below."
God bless the Japanese crew for telling the story in a straightforward, economic manner, yet missing none of its innate poignancy. So unlike Disney which cheapens the excellent story material with unneeded frills and irrelevant, formulaic add-ons. Not even mentioning the extra doses of cuteness and sentimentality in depicting the dogs' behavior. Yes, dogs are capable of strong emotions and acts of loyalty, but that can be shown without overdone cuteness.
I warmly recommend "Antarctica" to viewers of "Eight Below." It would be difficult to find a better illustration of the difference between Hollywood slop and honest, unadorned storytelling.
God bless the Japanese crew for telling the story in a straightforward, economic manner, yet missing none of its innate poignancy. So unlike Disney which cheapens the excellent story material with unneeded frills and irrelevant, formulaic add-ons. Not even mentioning the extra doses of cuteness and sentimentality in depicting the dogs' behavior. Yes, dogs are capable of strong emotions and acts of loyalty, but that can be shown without overdone cuteness.
I warmly recommend "Antarctica" to viewers of "Eight Below." It would be difficult to find a better illustration of the difference between Hollywood slop and honest, unadorned storytelling.