The vaguely titled DON'T TELL is a multi-layered story of repressions and the horrors of family secrets that threaten to explode at any moment -- a movie about pregnancy, both in a literal and figurative sense. With such a premise, this Italian movie should have been titled in English as "The Beast Within the Heart", which would have made more sense as it is what it is about. Sabina (Giovanna Mezzogiorno), a name that brings to mind "The Rape of the Sabines" and to the dark heroine of the same name of Anais Nin's erotic masterpiece "Spy in the House of Love", is the name of the woman at the center of the story. She's a voice-over actress doing some dubbing work for a unnamed movie in which a female jogger gets raped by a sleaze-ball. Little does she know, the screams of help and resistance that she is acting out will become all too real when her decision to have a child suddenly opens the floodgates to dogs that were better off sleeping in their black caves.
It becomes clear that in order for Sabina to live a normal life -- if there is such a thing as "normal" -- she will have to face her inner pain instead of stifling it and further alienating herself from her friends and current boyfriend, a soap actor. A trip to the United States where she visits her brother Daniele (Luigi lo Cascio) further discloses not only the source of the pain, but its ramifications, and in a chilling scene, Daniele confesses not only his own trauma, but how he dealt with it, and how it left him a marked man. It's a very naked moment, and one that is in stark contrast to the torrent of emotion that Sabina has been experiencing, and one that leaves her hanging on a thread that threatens to snap at any moment.
As an extra touch, and one that doesn't seem to occur in American movies, DON'T TELL gives some its supporting characters their own lives by telling parallel stories that may not be central to the action but at least sheds some info on them. It's a technique that rounds the movie out quite well in parts but becomes rococo on others. It's almost as if director and writer Cristina Comencini loved the characters from her novel of the same name so much she wanted to include all of them in one movie, and while that's okay in an ensemble, this is a drama that focuses on one woman's road to her past, and becomes cinematic filler. It's as if Krysztoff Kieslzowski would have crammed the events of his TROIS COULEURS trilogy into one movie: it would have been too much, even when all three stories are inherently powerful.
On the upside of supporting characters, Sabina's gay best friend, Emilia (Stefaina Rocca), lives in isolation and is totally dependent on her due to her blindness. Sabina, however, decides to introduce her to Maria (Alessandra Finocchiaro), a friend and co-worker in the dubbing field, who's been separated from her husband and awakened to her own lesbianism. The scene where Emilia in her blindness reveals Maria's beauty is potent as it's simple and in a single shot, their attraction and seduction looks utterly beautiful. Their own relationship could spawn a movie in its own right, because it goes through its own shades of darkness that mirrors Sabina's, and is self contained.
On the downside, Sabina's boyfriend, Franco (Alessio Boni), has a storyline that should have terminated when she leaves to the US, but we continue to see him initiating an affair with another woman. The director of the soap opera where he works also gets more screen time than necessary, and his "comedic" presence is a little jolting to a story that is melodramatic. However, such things are a small complaint, because DON'T TELL (LA BESTIA NEL CUORE) is very moving at times and has a visual climax that brings back the past into the present in a seamless montage of vivid images.
It becomes clear that in order for Sabina to live a normal life -- if there is such a thing as "normal" -- she will have to face her inner pain instead of stifling it and further alienating herself from her friends and current boyfriend, a soap actor. A trip to the United States where she visits her brother Daniele (Luigi lo Cascio) further discloses not only the source of the pain, but its ramifications, and in a chilling scene, Daniele confesses not only his own trauma, but how he dealt with it, and how it left him a marked man. It's a very naked moment, and one that is in stark contrast to the torrent of emotion that Sabina has been experiencing, and one that leaves her hanging on a thread that threatens to snap at any moment.
As an extra touch, and one that doesn't seem to occur in American movies, DON'T TELL gives some its supporting characters their own lives by telling parallel stories that may not be central to the action but at least sheds some info on them. It's a technique that rounds the movie out quite well in parts but becomes rococo on others. It's almost as if director and writer Cristina Comencini loved the characters from her novel of the same name so much she wanted to include all of them in one movie, and while that's okay in an ensemble, this is a drama that focuses on one woman's road to her past, and becomes cinematic filler. It's as if Krysztoff Kieslzowski would have crammed the events of his TROIS COULEURS trilogy into one movie: it would have been too much, even when all three stories are inherently powerful.
On the upside of supporting characters, Sabina's gay best friend, Emilia (Stefaina Rocca), lives in isolation and is totally dependent on her due to her blindness. Sabina, however, decides to introduce her to Maria (Alessandra Finocchiaro), a friend and co-worker in the dubbing field, who's been separated from her husband and awakened to her own lesbianism. The scene where Emilia in her blindness reveals Maria's beauty is potent as it's simple and in a single shot, their attraction and seduction looks utterly beautiful. Their own relationship could spawn a movie in its own right, because it goes through its own shades of darkness that mirrors Sabina's, and is self contained.
On the downside, Sabina's boyfriend, Franco (Alessio Boni), has a storyline that should have terminated when she leaves to the US, but we continue to see him initiating an affair with another woman. The director of the soap opera where he works also gets more screen time than necessary, and his "comedic" presence is a little jolting to a story that is melodramatic. However, such things are a small complaint, because DON'T TELL (LA BESTIA NEL CUORE) is very moving at times and has a visual climax that brings back the past into the present in a seamless montage of vivid images.