Belle Starr (1941)
7/10
Black people...on the sidewalk?!
27 November 2007
OK, this film wants us to sympathize with southerners who took to banditry after the Civil War. So what evil and disgusting Yankee devilry do they show us? A check-suited carpetbagger telling black people they can--gasp!--walk on the sidewalk and sit on the front porch, and a lot of happy black folks celebrating their new freedom.

Oh, well, you can understand, then. Blacks on the sidewalks?! God help us! Keep your powder dry, boys! I normally deprecate the simple-minded practice of holding the art of other eras responsible to our standards of political correctness, but I don't care--that's just plain foul.

Of course, it's not completely racist; there are decent black folks in evidence, too: they are the ones who sympathize with their oppressors and help them fight those lousy carpetbaggers who want to let them sit right on the front porch where anybody can see them!

It's been a few years since I saw *Gone With the Wind*: was it this hamhandedly bigoted in its treatment of blacks?

It's s shame, because one you get past the overt racism, this is actually a pretty good movie, with one of Randolph Scott's better performances.
12 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed