Review of Monte Carlo

Monte Carlo (1930)
5/10
Even Lubistch can make a dud...a musical comedy with only one memorable song...
21 December 2012
Strictly for devotees of Jeanette MacDonald who have to see every one of her films. Pairing her with leading man Jack Buchanan is a big mistake here. He has neither the looks nor charm to be believable as her love interest.

She does get to warble at least one attractive and well-remembered song: "Beyond the Blue Horizon," but all the other musical numbers are patter songs that merely fill in the gaps between some not too witty dialog.

The tiresome tale is about a girl who runs away from her wedding and then mistakes a wealthy man (a Count) for a hairdresser. The mistaken identity goes on for almost the entire film without resulting in any real payoffs. Jeanette is her usual charming self but Jack Buchanan is really wasted here and never gets a chance to show what a great tap dancer he was--as in "The Bandwagon" years later with Fred Astaire.

This is one even Jeanette's most ardent fans can afford to skip.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed